THE MACCABAEAN
DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS
ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901
VOLUME-XXI-III-XXIX
Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by "The Maccabaean Magazine," 44 East 23rd Street, New YorkEntered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries, includingCanada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents.Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of ad dress.
CONTENTS
EDITORIALS
What Was Accomplished at Philadelphia
We have just emerged from the difficult task of successfully managing the largest convention ever held by the Zionists of America. It is not a simple matter to review the event at this time. The significance of a convention of such magnitude becomes apparent some time after the record is completed. At this time, the feeling is general that the Philadelphia convention deepened Zionist consciousness, that its business was transacted with unusual intelligence, and that the enthusiasm generated was held within bounds owing to the sober realization of the fact that with such large responsibilities thrust upon us caution must be exercised in order that the world may be impressed not by our capacity for enthusiasm so much as with our capacity for practical achievement.
It has been charged against the convention by our friends who have been accustomed to the oratory and discussions of the Zionist Congresses, that too little time was devoted to theoretical reviews and academic formulations of policy. No clear survey was given of the problems of the Zionist movement at this time. We are described as being too practical, too much engrossed in organization problems, too much concerned with practical plans. This charge is short-sighted. We are now facing the critical period of Zionist history. We shall be judged not by our ability to formulate theories and accurately analyze conditions, but by the decisions we make and the judgment we employ in meeting the practical features of the Zionist program.
Zionism as a theory of Jewish life, Zionism as the formulation of the solution of the Jewish problem, is meeting with general endorsement. They are few in number who oppose Zionism as a theory. Our opponents controvert assertions as to the need of having a democracy back of Zionism, they object to a version of Zionism —entertained by only a few people—ac-
cording to which religion is excluded from Zionism, but so far as the essential basis of Zionism, they have no serious objections to offer. In fact, such fragments of hostility as may be discerned in the utterances of the anti-Congressists are based wholly upon the democratic implications of Zionism that may be applied to Jewish life in the goluth. Outside of Jewry the world is favorably disposed. All indications point to the favorable consideration of Zionism by men high in station and influence. It is everywhere regarded as the comprehensive platform upon which the Jewish people can safely stand.
What there is left for us to demonstrate is the practicability of Zionism and the ability of Zionists to steer the ship of state through the shoals and pitfalls of a difficult course. Not what you think of the Jewish problem, but what you are going to do about it—that is the question. There have been volumes written on the Jewish problem as viewed by Jews and non-Jews. The hour is about to strike when the Jewish nationalitv is to be called upon to act.
The quality of the Philadelphia convention was therefore in harmony with the needs of the hour. The movement was reviewed in action. The organization in all its phases had its record presented, its achievements noted, and the way was charted for the next year's spurt of activity. The world saw a people seriously considering its practical problems, having passed its youthful period of discussion and theorizing; its romantic years had receded into the background.
The leading practical issue of the Convention was injected into it by a group of Zionists who have not as yet grasped the implications of the American Jewish Congress; out of their lack of understanding there arose the necessity of driving home the lesson of practical exigency which we had grasped at the Boston