The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 1 · July 1916
180printed page
scan 20 of 54

Leon Kohn, of Newark: There has been a great deal said in the discussion to-day by many speakers of the democracy of the Congress Movement. Those of us who presented the substitute resolution are not attacking the democracy of the Movement. We are not opposed to the principle of democracy. But we believe, to make democracy effective, you must preserve the instrument of democracy. Let me explain my position by giving you an example of American history, which I have already quoted to some in private conversation. At the time of the American Civil War, the burning question was the question of human liberty—the slavery question. When Lincoln went into office he did not begin his administration with the Emancipation Proclamation, because he was more anxious to preserve the Union as an instrument of liberty in the future, than of solving at that moment the immediate problem at hand. And we who bring the substitute resolution are more for preserving an instrument for the organic unity of American Jewry, than of solving the immediate questions that are between us and the other groups. For, granted that we who propose the substitute resolution lose out, and granted that you call the Congress and the American Jewish Committee call its Conference—who will be the victor? Not the American Jewish Committee, and not we, for as long as there are two bodies, each claiming to speak authoritatively in the name of American Jewry, we are both defeated, and the Jewish People is defeated, because there is no one voice that does actually speak with authority for the Jewish people. What is it that is offered us now to remedy this grievous situation from which all Jewish people will suffer? We send a committee of three, without power, to carry on negotiations which are not the basis of action when they are presented to our body. We do not need to explain our action to the American Jewish Committee, but to the whole American Jewish public, to the press; but we do owe it to the American Jewish public and to the Jewish People throughout the world to formulate some sort of negotiations. And if we do not make a further attempt to heal the breach, an attempt which may seem hopeless—but we have no right to give up hope until the last minute—we cannot come before the Jewry of the world with clean hands. I would urge upon the delegates here, not because they are afraid of the American Jewish Committee, not because they have any feelings of respect for any members of the American Jewish Committee, and not because they have great admiration for the leaders of the Congress Movement, but for the interest of the Jewish People of America and the world at large, to order a further attempt of negotiations with a view of attaining peace.

Abram Goldberg, speaking Yiddish: Mr. Goldberg pointed ‚out that the Zionist organization was compelled to enter the Congress movement, in order to protect the Zionist cause. The Congress movement at first turned to the American Jewish Committee, asking it to call the Congress on a democratic basis. This the American Jewish Committee refused to do. When it had no other means for establishing the Congress, the Congress committee approached the Zionist organization. At this critical time, it would have been sui<ide for Zionism to have allowed the American Jewish Committee or any other non-representative committee to speak for the Jews of America. It became necessary for us to take action. What we have done has been right in line with Zionist policies. We have entered general Jewish life with a view to creating conditions that may lead later to the reawakening of all Jews to their national responsibilities. The opposition declines to allow this reawakening to occur. Their opposition is directed against a fundamental Zionist principle. We are therefore in duty bound to take up the issue and to see it fought out in Jewish life.

Mrs. Richard Gottheil, of New York: I feel that having been a delegate to the second Zionist Congress that convened in Basle, and having had the privilege to know our late leader, Dr. Herzl, I have a few words to tell you. When Dr. Herzl convened the Congress, he put upon our Zionists a duty. This duty is that whenever any meeting or any gathering of Jews get together to solve the future of the Jewish People, this should be a concern of the Zionists. That is why I feel that it is our duty, each one of us Zionists, to be ready to work in behalf of this Jewish Congress, which should be

a democratic Congress. Dr. Herzl did not go to the mighty in Israel. He came to you. That is why this Congress ought to be our concern. The whole of Jewry is looking to us American Zionists. This is the time we must do our duty as a democratic body in the democratic land.

Dr. Solis-Cohen: I want to applaud the action of the Inner Actions Committee, and I want especially to call attention to the last words, both in the German and in the English (Second Paragraph of IAC resolution re-read to delegates by Dr. Solis-Cohen, English Translation made by Dr. Solis-Cohen.) “The Inner Actions Committee urges that the American Jewish Congress reach an understanding with all parties and organizations of the Jews of all lands which are willing to support the movement to secure equal civil and national rights for the Jews.”

We have only to consider what that phrase “National rights” means. The word assimilationists has been thrown at some of us; and assimilationist, in the days when I was a boy in America, and ever since, as I have grown up as an American citizen, assimilationist meant one who has deserted his religion. The attempt is being made to import into this country an idea which is foreign to this country. In Russia and other lands of persecution to assimilate means to desert your people. In America.there can be no national rights except the rights of American citizens. In the other lands where group rights are given, the American Jewish Committee has distinctly affırmed that that Committee and that Conference will support the movement to secure for Jews equal rights, including civil, political, religious and full legal rights, including group rights. I yield to no man in my admiration for those who have carried on and are carrying on the work of the Zionist Organization in America and elsewhere devotedly and self-sacrificediy. But they must not—we must not—take advantage of that work to introduce a foreign and extraneous issue. There is no one among us, either those who oppose or those who accept the majority report, to whom the word traitor can be applied. No one. But if there had been a traitor among us, he could not have brought forward an issue that would more delight the heart of the Czar of Russia. He could not have done better than divide American Israel and paralyze its councils. He could not have done better than to say to the world, that those who have secured the abrogation of the Russian treaty are not representatives of Israel. I do not expect the minority resolution to carry. We are here only to voice a protest. We are here to protest that the Zionist Movement to which we have been devoted for a generation, some of us, shall not be nullified by binding it up with an issue which, however great in itself, is not the issue of Zionism. The organization of Zionism must stand for unity and peace, or Zionism cannot stand at all.

During Dr. Cohen's address, which was in large part a repetition of his speech at the opening of the convention on Sunday afternoon, there were a number of interruptions. The chairman called upon the delegates repeatedly to desist from interrupting the speaker.

Morris Rothenberg, of New York: There has been a question raised here to-day as to whether or not the Congress Movement is the Zionist Movement. I want to say for myself, having been connected with the Congress Movement, that the Zionist Movement is not the Congress Movement, but were it not for the Zionist Movement (and be it said to its everlasting credit) there would be no Congress Movement in America. I say that the Zionist Movement has every reason to be proud of the fact that it has brought forth a Movement which is to be an open forum for the discussion of Jewish matters to people who are interested in Jewish matters, and I say.it is to the everlasting credit of the Zionist Movement of America that they were willing to come into this movement and throw in their question among all questions to be decided. The minority reports asks us that we shall make further efforts for peace. Those of you who have been associated with the Congress Movement know that every effort has been made for peace—but peace with honor and not peace with dishonor. There is a time when war is preferable to peace with dishonor. We could have had peace at the very inception of the Congress Movement. Yes, if we would have surrendered the very principle upon