Dr. Blondheim, of Baltimore: I do not think there is any doubt that any of us regret the fact that sometimes The Maccabaean has personal references. But this resolution operates as a lack of confidence in our chosen representatives, the courageous men who have been fighting our battle.
It was moved and seconded that the motion of Miss Kussy be laid on the table. Vote: Eighty-seven voted that the motion be tabled. Twenty-six voted against. Carried, that the motion of Miss Kussy be tabled.
Resolution on the Million Dollar Loan:
Mr. Bernard A. Rosenblatt, Chairman, New York:
Resolved, That the Federation of American Zionist recommend that the Palestine bureau or commission appointed by the Provisional Committee shall undertake the organization of a corporation with an authorized capital stock of one million dollars for the purpose of conserving the Jewish colonies and developing the economic resources of Palestine on a business basis.
The Chairman: This is practically an endorsement of the resolution adopted by the Provisional Committee.
Unanimously carried.
Hebrew Propagannda Committee Report:
Rabbi Meyer Waxman, Chairman, New York:
“Whereas, It is accepted and agreed to by all true Zionists that there cannot be a renaissance of the Jewish nation without a corresponding regeneration of the Hebrew language, the historical national traditions and literary language of the nation.
"Whereas, It follows from the above principle that any Zionistic (individual) organization whose aim and purpose is to further the realization of the Zionist ideal which is the bringing about of a complete rebirth of the Jewish nation, is bound by its own principles and aspirations to devote a part of its energy towards the revival and spread of the Hebrew language.
I.
“Be it therefore resolved, That the Federation of American Zionists appoint a permant Hebrew propaganda committee consisting of three active Hebraists, the functions of which committee is to be to ascertain the extent to which the Zionists throughout the country participate in educational and Hebrew activities, in order to bring about co-ordination and to evolve a uniform plan of action. Further, This committee is to act as a central body, supervising and directing the above specified activities. Such committee shall co-operate with the representatives of the Histradruth Haibrith.
II.
"The said committee to be appointed by the incoming executive and be granted voting power at the executive sessions in all matters pertaining to Hebrew activities.
III.
"The said committee shall render an account of its work at the end of each year to the executive committee, and the results of their activities be embodied as an integral part of the report of the executive committee to the annual convention.
IV.
"Resolved, That the Federation of American Zionists urge all societies affiliated with it to appoint a standing committee of three, whose duty shall be to co-operate with the Federation committee in all Hebrew activities.
V.
“Resolved, That the Federation urge its affiliated societies to buy shares of the Hatoren association (so as to secure the existence) and to procure subscribers for the literary Hebrew weckly Hatoren as well as for the Haibri, an organ published by the Mizrachi Organization of America.
The Chairman: The first motion is before you: (Part I, carried.)
Second motion: (Part II, carried.)
Third motion: (Part III. carried.). rar en .e PL .% a ır BB TR TR I
Fourth motion: (Part IV., carried). Fifth motion: Resolved, That the Federation urge its affiliated societies to buy shares of the Hatoren association (so as to secure the existence) and to procure subscribers for the literary weekly Hatoren as well as for the Haibri, an organ published by the Mizrachi Organization of America.
Mr. Daniel Persky (who acted as a substitute on the Hebrew Propaganda Committee): This motion is not read in accordance with the resolution passed by the Hebrew Propaganda Committee, which had not given its consent to that portion relating to the Haibri.
Rabbi Waxman explained that he had inserted the Haibri portion without the consent of his associates on the Hebrew Propaganda Committee; but that he had added this point on the grounds of common sense; that in adding this he is speaking on the basis of fair-mindedness.
The Chairman: Inasmuch as the chairman of the committee has admitted that that part of the resolution which deals with the Haibri was not passed on by his committee, I rule that it is not part of the recommendation of the committee, but that it is an amendment of the resolution. The amendment made by Rabbi Waxman is that whatever the Zionist societies are asked to do for the Hatoren they should do for the Haibri, except with reference to buying shares of the latter publication. The action of this committee in bringing before the Convention a matter that was not passed by their committee was not fair to this convention. It should not have been brought before the house exception from the floor.
Decided, That a committee be appointed to go out and bring in a unanimous report on the above matter. Committee consisting of: Messrs. Goldberg, Lisitzky, Orlans, Meyer Freed, Dr. Levin and Joshua Neumann.
Report of Committee on General Relief.
Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein, Chairman, New York: The committee nominated by the Convention on the general relief question met yesterday, and we had delegates from cities outside of New York who are participating in the actual work of collecting money for relief. After a three hour discussion of every possible detail, we came to draw a resolution as the sense of the discussion:
“ Resolved, That this Convention direct and hereby directs the Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists to instruct its constituent organizations participating in the work in behalf of general Jewish relief to endeavor to secure a reasonable percentage for the Zionist Emergency Fund out of the general relief funds. In the event of the failure to secure such percentage all constituent organizations and the members shall immediately so notify the Executive Committee of the Federation, which shall report thereon to the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs. In all matters affecting general relief work, all constituent organizations and their members shall be bound by such instructions as they may receive from the Provisional Executive Committee.”
Mr. Lewin-Epstein: While the committees appointed in each city of Palestine by the Joint Distribution Committee, with the consent of the Zionist on that Committee, are distributing the money, the sums go to the Chalukah and are given just so as to enable them to buy bread and water. The Zionist committee in Palestine is also distributing relief funds, purely relief, but in an entirely different manner. For instance, there are one thousand Jewish families of the workingmen unemployed. There are four or five thousand souls suffering from starvation. Instead of giving them just bread, as a charity, the Zionist committee lends the money to the colonists or to industry with the understanding that this money goes to employ the unemployed Jewish laborers, giving them money in payment for their work. It helps in a double way. First of all, it helps to alleviate the suffering of the workingmen, and it helps to keep up the Jewish national property in Palestine; and besides this, it is given to them as a loan with a note against it. After the war they will have to pay that money back to the relief committees, and it will be used again as constructive relief work in Palestine. Instead of pauperizing the people we help them to sustain themselves by their work.
Moved to accept report.
Mr. Morris Rothenberg, of New York: I regret to say that I am opposed to the resolution offered by Mr. Lewin-Epstein. This is a very serious matter and I think it demands that we give a careful consideration of it. Unless we are careful in the step we take in connection with this question, we may bring on a fight which may injure our Oreanization in America to a serious extent. For the past