The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
70printed page
scan 28 of 70

THE MACCABAEAN

followed as takes place in the mind of the creator of a story: he too observes life before he embodies his observations in the tale he has to tell. "Enrich the emotional life of the children; make them look into the hearts of others, but do not let them study themselves. Do not speak of their duties to neighbors, but of what the pretexts are for conflicts, what differences of temperament they can accommodate themselves to, what their eyes and ears can detect in the varying expressions of the face and voice: thus you can help them to be good neighbors. Lead them to understand what is right, not through an abstract analysis, but through their insight into people and into far-reaching effects." In the Society for Ethical Culture he saw an over-emphasis of the intellectual, the logical, the understanding mind not balanced by the understanding heart. The effect of his expressions of opinion was heightened by his personality. Here was a man who evidently had gone through an ordeal of some sort that made him see things hidden from the eyes of many. One must at some time have been exiled from life—by grave illness, by an isolating experience—in order to know life. Perhaps the months Dr. Foerster spent in prison had given him this knowledge. We thought "Here surely is the young disciple for whom the Ethical Society has been looking; it is he who will wear the mantle of Elijah."

ee eee eee ene en EE I We met again a few years later. Our correspondence in the interval had not prepared me for the shock I now received, although if the letters are re-read in the light of what followed, intimations can be seen in them of the change that had taken place. The friend whom I had looked on as “one of us,” that is, as a modernist through and through, fundamentally in accord with Felix Adler, now appeared in a different light. Now when we met, instead of speaking as of old, of the great movement of which we were a part, he talked about things I did not understand at all: religion in the traditional sense, the cultural value of ancient forms and ceremonies, hours spent in devotion, monasticism. The teacher looked upon as a guide led away from the straight path ‘nto a maze. He spoke of things the mind of the free-thinker had to condemn who already visualized him as a Catholic, a lost ethical soul. This was a shock such as might have been felt by a young follower of Karl Marx, if his prophet had suddenly reversed his doctrine to preach capitalism; or, let us.say, as would be sustained by any of us, if a trusted Zionist leader were today to face about and work for the assimilation of the Jews. The world would become unreal, and we should doubt our judgment of everyone and everything. To some men, the events of their life are in large part the stages of their journey in search of wisdom; and strange though it may seem to those whose adventures are wholly along a different route, an experience of this sort leads them well-nigh to despair. How go on living if the old philosophy has ceased to give support, and teachers undo their own instructions? Could Dr. Foerster now be right? For the first time it seemed possible that another sea of consciousness existed within us than the one that ordinarily buoys us up,—a sea that if stirred into motion would carry us to the shore of what we call the supernatural, whence “higher energies would filter in.”* It seemed possible, and yet the notion seemed insane. Could I but reach Professor Adler, he would bid this nightmare

begone that turned the universe into a chaos in which reason lost control.

Professor Adler was in Switzerland at this time, but I did not know his address. Wherever I went I looked for him, on every train, in every city. We went to Paris, and on the night before we left for Boulogne the proprietaire of our hotel asked me to translate an English telegram she had received—a request for the reservation of rooms for the next day. I had been holding the telegram with my thumb over the signature, but on giving the paper back to the proprietaire I saw the name Felix Adler. Had we been able to postpone our departure for a few hours, then, figuratively speaking, too, there would have been a postponement of the parting of the ways. This could not be arranged, however, and thereafter the thought of the coincidence became only a source of desire to see purpose where there was only chance.

Dr. Foerster still felt that his place was in the Ethical Society. Although he believed that ethics would never replace religion, "because ethics, if deeply experienced, must lead to religion and to a new relation to the old symbols," yet he said definitely that he considered the ethical work the most urgent task of the age. This was comforting to hear, though no one could settle back into perfect ease who was pricked into wakefulness by his letters. These were wonderful letters. Perhaps some day, after the war is over, permission to publish them may be obtained. They discussed the use of symbols, the needs a church organization responds to, the sources of strength that are not tapped by the ethical philosophy. Yet, although I tried to understand his views, I could not. They aroused a rebellious spirit in me. I took my place firmly on the platform of the Ethical Society, to which I thought Dr. Foerster would soon return.

Lest a wrong impression be given through these exclusive references to one domain of inquiry, perhaps I should say that during this time Dr. Foerster was close to earth in the experiences of daily life. He was a public-spirited man, actively concerned with many of the questions of the day. As saith the preacher:

"To everything there is a season,And a time to every purpose under the heaven:A time to weep,And a time to laugh;A time to mourn,And a time to dance;A time to seek,And a time to lose;A time to keep,And a time to cast away."

And now another coincidence, more striking than that referred to previously, marked the history of those days. Another trip to Europe brought two friends of mine and me for five weeks to an out-of-the-way village in Switzerland of which we had never heard before. Off and on, during the earlier part of the summer, the Foersters and I had tried to arrange for a meeting. But we lost track of each other without concluding an arrangement. They did not know where we were, nor were we acquainted with their plans. In the meantime Dr. Foerster had sent us his book, "Jugendlehre." This book in its references to religion and to the Church was painfully reactionary, and yet it was in other respects modern. On the one hand it showed the author forth as a gifted psychologist and educator; but, on the other hand, it made

* A phrase used by William James