THE MACCABAEAN
Jew; the German Jew began to arrive about fifty years before the first large wave of Russian immigration. Approximately, again, the total strength of the Spanish-Portuguese Jews in this country may not have exceeded thirty thousand when the German Jews came; the German Jews counted some three hundred thousand when their numbers were at the highest and the Russian immigration may, in due time, rise to something like three millions.
The small number of the Spanish-Portuguese produced some names of considerable prominence; in politics and literature the standing of Judah P. Benjamin and Emma Lazarus has not yet been outranked by any American Jew or Jewess from other strains; in sculpture Sir Moses Ezekiel held an honored place; in other departments there are other names of high repute; yet in commerce and industry, in journalism, music and on the stage, as well as in the diplomatic service, the German Jew, partly owing to his far larger numbers, partly owing to the progress of the country, rose considerably higher, despite the fact that he has never attained to the social standing of his Portuguese co-religionists; and he has succeeded in organizing his congregational life, and even more so, his charities, to a rare degree of public efficiency. As factors in American public life the German congregation and the Reform Rabbi are far more prominent than were their Portuguese predecessors, with possibly the solitary exception of Gershom Mendes Seixas. It has also come to pass that the institutions and charities built up by the German Jews are generally regarded as models of enlightened, advanced and thoroughly systematized philanthropy.
The real rise of the German Jew virtually coincided with the incipient decline of his Portuguese brother; just when, after the war of the secession, the fortunes of the German Jews advanced most rapidly, the equally rapid decay of the Portuguese, through business, conservatism and social stagnation, began to become evident.
eR, oe "₪ Altogether different was the relationship between the Russian wave of immigrants and its German predecessors. The German Jew is far, as yet, from showing any symptoms of speedy decay; he seems to have still before him the larger part of his career as an element in American public life; he has extended far greater assistance to the Russian newcomer than what he himself had received from the Portuguese community at the time of his arrival ; his communal life is far more distinctly organized and his social existence far more clannish than had been the corresponding factors among the Portuguese. The German Jew regards the Russian Jews as his inferior, as he had himself been looked down upon by the Portuguese; but while the Portuguese hardly wondered at his German brother’s ambition to build up congregational and philanthropic organizations of his own, the German Jew is rather surprised that the Russian newcomers should, out of their poverty, make every attempt to build up Jewish lodges, Jewish orphan asylums, hospitals and old people’s homes of their own, even though he is aware that his own indifference to the dietary laws has much to do with these endeavors and ought to remember that others, as well as himself, might prefer to man and steer their own charities.
In the last few years, however, the division has gone further, as, in the course of natural evolution, it was bound to advance.
The Russian, Galician and Rumanian Jew has made rapid progress along many lines. He has not yet organized his congregational life into systematic co-operation or his ministry to wider influence and general prestige; he has succeeded in forming lodges which command a large constituency and he is building up charities of great promise. As yet whatever power he commands is
due most largely to his numbers and, in a less degree, to his many individual successes in commerce and the professions, to his Yiddish press and, above all, to his vote.
The fact which eludes the observation of superficial people and which is bound to prove of incalculable importance to the Jewish developments of the near future is the certainty that the immense numerical preponderance of the Eastern Jew is turning, slowly, but surely, into a preponderance of power and decision along many lines. For the present this impending change manifests itself principally in the rapid strengthening of Zionism and in such a victory of the masses over the classes as was witnessed in the final adoption and the successful enactment of the Congress-idea. But that striking difference between the Jewish apathy of the assimilated classes and the intense interest in matters Jewish of our half-assimilated masses which determined the complexion of the Congress, that same difference will lead to the same unmistakable effects in other lines of Jewish endeavor. Just because the assimilated American Jew has been so largely weaned from interest and active participation in things Jewish, being trained to let his money act for him, while the great masses from the East are still eager to read, listen, learn, act where Judaism and the Jew are concerned, it is easy to prognosticate that henceforward, in one field of Jewish work after another, it will be the Eastern Jew whose voice will be paramount.
Already, even at this stage, the Eastern Jew has assumed leadership in many places of eminence, though, as yet, the fact is not patent, except to those who are in possession of "inside" information. Even in the Reform pulpit the numbers of eminent rabbis of Russian birth or parentage is far larger than most people are aware; the time is coming (if not already at hand) when classes are graduated from the Hebrew Union College itself which are recruited almost entirely, or even wholly, from the children of Eastern Jews. Among our social workers similar conditions are readily observable. In many Reform congregations there is a steady infiltration of Eastern elements through Sunday School and Confirmation Class, and as a symptom of growing prosperity and assimilation; as race-suicide is steadily thinning the ranks of the over assimilated, it is not unlikely that, in the end, the Reform congregation of German origin will owe its preservation to the immigrant from Eastern Europe.
Yet, while the Eastern Jew is rapidly rising in the social scale, while many a prosperous son of Russian immigrants marries into some fashionable German family, the social line not only continues to be drawn quite distinctly between older and more recent immigrants, but the ignorance of the German Jew regarding the life and doings of the Eastern Jew who may live only a few squares from him is nothing less than amazing. In our large cities there must be thousands of Jews, young and old, rich and middle-class, who have scarcely ever seen the "Ghetto" districts of their city and who are as ignorant as any Gentile might be of the living conditions, interests and leading personalities of those districts. It is even a fact, amazing though it may sound, that the Reform rabbi often does not know his orthodox colleagues even by sight, having no social contact or common interest whatsoever with them. Such a state of things is inconceivable in the South or West; but it can be explained, though not justified, from the fact that the large Ghettoes form a world of their own which is independent of outside affiliation.
According to the familiar rabbinical law he is wise who recognizes the thing which is being born. We stand at a parting of the ways which it is best to take into account in all our work and plans for the unfoldment of Judaism in this country.