THE MACCABAEAN
SELF-TAXATION
WITH the entrance of the United States into the war, every citizen is prepared to meet unusual taxes to enable the government to prosecute the war with diligence and efficiency. There are few who demur, but all seem to be willing to contribute whatever may be necessary in order that the prestige and honor of the United States may be maintained. Only those who lack an understanding of the implications of patriotism and citizenship voice their discontent by indirect attempts to embarrass the government. But they cannot evade the payment of taxes. Since the outbreak of the war, the Zionist organization has gathered the funds to maintain Palestine and the movement by appealing to the loyalty of Jews and of Zionists. The suggestion was made soon after August, 1914, that every Zionist tax himself for the Emergency Fund. We could not tax Zionists, for we have no power to impose obedience. But we thought that every Zionist realized that in a time of crisis and of great need, there should be a spontaneous response to the call for funds, not spasmodically contributed, but contributed with the regularity and certainty of taxes. How many Zionists have met this obligation? We are ashamed to publish the record. The percentage is so small, that our enemies would be justified in saying that not even the Zionists have measured up to the standard, that not even Zionists, who are presumed to be devoted nationalists, and ready to make sacrifices for the cause, are capable of rising to the occasion. Their patriotic flame only flares up occasionally, at moments of great excitement or emotion, but they cannot be relied upon for continuous interest. There are about 30,000 organized Zionists in the United States, with about 50,000 additional shekel-payers. If only the 30,000 organized Zionists were to pay on the average of one dollar a month, we should have enough to meet our Palestine budget and over. If only all those who had declared themselves in favor of the Basle program were to give fifty cents a month, we should have an income per annum of $480,000, more than ample to cover all our obligations.
A CALL TO ACTION
ALL talk of a negotiated peace does not take into account the fact that peace is now actually being negotiated, although not many of the impetuous peace-makers are aware of it. The peace conference will in all probability ratify to a large extent the status quo at the time it convenes. It will take into account not territory acquired, but the strength and power of the nations involved as registered not only on the battlefield. It will also have to give credit to the achievements of nationalities, their virtues, their culture, their self-determination. Not only what they possess, what they assert and claim, but what they sacrificed during the war will be reckoned in the final inventory.
The Jewish people will also be tried by that standard. Not only what soldiers they have contributed and lost, not only the property which has been destroyed, and the thousands of lives uprooted, will be counted, but the spirit of devotion and sacrifice they have exhibited with regard to their own national interests. If the Jews are to be recognized as a nationality, and given their proper place in the world, they must show that during the war they acted, and sacrificed, in a manner befitting a nationality and deserving of recognition as such. Not as suppliants must they come, but as proud equals of all other nations that have staked their destinies upon the outcome of the war.
Undoubtedly, when the reckoning is made, what the Jews have done to help their brethren in other lands will be counted as a favorable sign of the international brotherhood of the Jews, indicating that the Jews have made sacrifices for interests that extend beyond the boundaries of their own homes. But what will count most will be the manner in which that help was given, whether it was given as to brothers in distress, or as to distant relatives, whose pain must be assuaged in self-defense against the charge of heartlessness and ingratitude.
But of far greater importance than the international relief given by Jews to Jews is the reaction of the Jewish people to the prospective grant of national autonomy in Palestine. If when nations have been speaking of re-establishing the Jewish people upon an autonomous basis in their ancient homeland, the Jews indicate indifference or, at best, a platonic interest, that attitude will be taken into account. It is not what the Jews will do when the opportunity is offered in a practical form, but what they did when the proposition was set forth, and their reaction had some bearing upon the determination of the nations in formulating their policy toward the Jewish question. If the Jews facing such an opportunity—for the first time in two thousand years—go ahead with their own personal affairs as if nothing had happened, and refuse to be stirred by the event, then undoubtedly, the practicality of the Jewish homeland proposition may be questioned. In order to take advantage of the situation, we shall have to be politically farsighted, and with a knowledge of diplomatic procedure, must not act like real-estate operators who take nothing for granted until the option is sealed by the offer of a deposit. The petty experience of a provincial Jewish organization cannot be applied to an enterprise of the magnitude of the re-establishment of the ancient Jewish people upon an autonomous basis.
Not what we shall say or do when the matter comes up in a peace conference, but what we do here and now constitutes our reaction to the Zionist proposition. Does the prospect of a Jewish homeland fire the Jewish imagination? Does it inspire them to unusual sacrifices? Do they begin to think and act like a nationality? As we answer these questions, so our destiny is determined.
We address these comments more particularly to Zionists. We have urged the Zionists time and again to take up the Restoration Shekel Campaign. It is not phantasy, or a desire merely to stimulate the enrollment of Shekel-payers, that has led to the designation of “restoration.” It is our unbiased conviction that the. Jewish reaction in this campaign will have a large influence in making the testoration of the Jewish people an actual reality. We have so expressed ourselves in circular letters to organized Zionists, and we state it here so that all who read may appreciate the importance of this Shekel Campaign. But how have the Zionists expressed their appreciation ? How they rallied quickly to the Shekel Campaign? Time is of the essence of the action. Just the same slackness, just the same inertia, just the same leave-it-for-tomorrow policy has been encountered in a large number of cities. Nothing seems to make the desired impression, nothing that can be thought of seems available to bring about— in Zionist circles—that sort of national self-sacrifice which has been witnessed in many of the countries now at war. A sign from Heaven ‘will have to be drawn, before some of our earnest Zionists can be gotten to translate their earnestness and sympathy into action.
It is a terrible prospect! The Messiah may come and find the Jews interested in their pots and kettles, in their own immediate troubles. And the Messiah may come, and the Zionists themselves—the elect, the self-chosen,