The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 2 · February 1918
30printed page
scan 6 of 44

THE MACCABAEAN

nation: no ethical principle determines their conduct toward each other. It is impossible that the developing conscience of mankind will not demand that nations and states submit their sovereign wills to the restraints of the moral law—especially after the cataclysm that has followed the violation of the moral law in international affairs.

Group-personality is an admitted fact of psychology. A nationality is nothing else but a group-personality. Many and subtle are the definitions of nation and nationality. The subject is threshed threadbare. No one group of factors will fit the facts of every nationality. But every historic nationality is distinguishable by the naked eye. No microscope is needed to discover it.

Nationality is an historic development that can no more be inhibited than the physical reproduction of the race. Nationality is more than a racial or historic fact: it is heavy with the fruits of the spirit. Religion, art, language, literature, law and government rise out of our national existence to enrich and enhance the life of humanity. Civilization is the poorer for its repression, the richer for its flowering. There are some “internationalists” who realize that nationalities must and will exist, but who tolerate them as a token of the innate and ineradicable perversity of the genus homo. They ignore the simple fact that the nation, or the nationality, is the unit of the internationalism they dream of.

Theodore Ruyssen (Professor of the History of Philosophy at the University of Bordeaux) defines the ideal nation as “the close synthesis of the social soul, or collective will, with a system of political institutions. The collective will finds in the legal organism at once its expression and its support; but the legal organism, in turn, draws its energy and the consciousness of its growth from the collective will, and the life of the nation consists of the interaction of this soul which directs, and this body which achieves.” This general definition summarizes the striving of Zionism for a Jewish nation; that is, for a nationality plus self-government. The Torah itself is a product of the synthesis of the Jewish social soul with a system of political institutions.

The “principle of nationality” has been integrated in the thought of the day, and has the official endorsement of great states. Zionism, therefore, now takes its rightful place in the scheme of international relations—quite without prejudice to the ultimate political status of Palestine, or to the rights of our neighbor-peoples in the Land. There is already an “entente cordiale” between Zionist representatives and Armenian and Arab leaders. The Declaration of the British Government in favor of Zionism is a recognition of the need of righting an historic wrong.

Jewish achievement in the past has been primarily in the domain of the spirit. It has been argued from this premise that national autonomy is immaterial to the creative evolution of the Jewish religious genius. Yet the culture of the Jew was arrested in its development through the loss of political institutions. The Jewish people has been splendidly steadfast in the Dispersion, but it cannot be claimed to have been truly creative. Political freedom and equality for Jews, in this land and that, cannot fairly be expected to produce those Jewish values that can only be evolved from a healthy national life. To quote Ruyssen again, in order that nationalities may “become nations, in the full

sense of the term, they must gain political independence, through which alone a complete social life [the social life that is the matrix of all culture] can manifest itself.”

The wisest and greatest of Jewish statesmen, the Prophets, never insisted on the tasks and obligations of a sovereign state for the Jewish people. But they did insist that self-government was essential. Schools and synagogues alone, even in Palestine, cannot accelerate the world’s moral evolution. Schools and synagogues alone cannot create a national culture. Law and government are as much elements of national culture as philosophy and religion; in Judaism, law has been religion. Unless law and government are organic elements of Jewish life in Palestine, Judaism, even in the national home, can be no more than a pale shadow of itself.

Judaism first laid down the rule that by Law shall mankind be ruled,—Law for the individual, for society, for the nation, between nation and nation. Law is the cornerstone of democracy. Without Law, ethics and democracy and international brotherhood are beautiful but homeless spirits.

The Jewish people, at home in Palestine, will profit by the experience gathered in the four corners of the earth. Political freedom and equality are indispensable, indeed; but these alone do not safeguard justice or democracy. Peoples under democratic rule have suffered from the severest forms of economic oppression. International intrigue and aggression have gone on under the aegis of democratic states.

The Zionist does not seek to be at ease in Zion. The historic-spiritual rôle will have to be reassumed. The Jewish people is sponsor for the Rule of Law. All the problems of revived nationhood, material, intellectual, spiritual, will have to be interpreted and solved in terms of that Rule.

Zionism, as an ideal, has been a glittering symbol, a philosophy of life comprehending the ultimate reaches of thought. Now, a time of trial and stress lies just ahead in the Land itself. The stuff our dreams were made of will have to be woven into the fabric of everyday routine. How will the dream-stuff stand the test? Constant conflict between the opportunist and the hater of compromise will be inevitable. Perhaps new Prophets will arise to point the way to the heaven and earth of the old Prophets’ vision. We can be certain that a trial as “of gold in the fire” awaits us.

It may be too much to hope that the Rule of Force and Aggression will be abandoned by the mighty ones of the earth in times not remote; and that the Rule of Law and Reason so long ago proclaimed in Judaea will prevail. Nevertheless, the Great Unknown Prophet of the Babylonian Captivity dared to say:

“I have put my spirit upon him; he shall bring forth judgment to the Gentiles. . . .

"He shall not fail or be discouraged, till he have set judgment in the earth; and the isles shall wait for hislaw. . . .

“And, as for Me, this is my covenant with them, saith the Lord: My spirit that is upon thee, and My words which I have put in thy mouth, shall not depart out of thy mouth, nor out of the mouth of thy seed, nor out of the mouth of thy seed’s seed, saith the Lord, from henceforth and forever.”