The Maccabaean
first visit. We were, however, glad to have the Y. M. H. A. building in camp, as it was, after all, a Jewish center, and the Jewish soldiers were naturally attracted to it.
WHERE THE WORK OF THE WELFARE BOARD FAILS
It may be well at this point to examine into the reasons for the insufficiency of the Jewish Welfare work. The Y. M. H. A. workers in the camps often seem to have taken up the work because nothing else offered itself at a particular given moment. They seem to think that every soldier feels that he is in "tzores," and all that he desires is to be coddled and sympathized with. Of his real mental and spiritual needs and longings they seem to have very little understanding. The haphazard manner (in contrast to the orderliness at the Y. M. C. A.) in which things tend to be conducted is, perhaps, best illustrated by the literature one finds in the Y. M. H. A. building. As to books, there is an exceedingly random and ever-growing collection of books which seem to be there only because their donors had no further use for them. At first there were practically no Jewish books to be had; all that was accessible were stray volumes with torn backs: "Trilby," "The Power of Steam." Later on better works, such as the Harvard classics, began to arrive, but, strange to say, there is not to this day a copy of Graetz's "History of the Jews" in our Y. M. H. A. By far the most praiseworthy achievement in this direction was the distribution by the Welfare workers of translations of the Old Testament and abridged prayer-books with an English translation and in a handy format. The work done in providing Jewish literature was, nevertheless, by no means inadequate. We found it difficult to understand why the Welfare League had not arranged to co-operate with the American Library Association as the Y. M. C. A. did. At the "Y" buildings and the Camp Library the A. L. A. had already supplied such works as Aaron Aaronson's "My Experience in Palestine" and Lieutenant-Colonel Patterson's "With the Zionists in Gallipoli." The Welfare League seemed to have entirely forgotten that the Jews bear the honorable title of the "People of the Book." It has since tried to make amends in this direction.
As for the remaining activities of the Y. M. H. A., very little can be said. Its principal offering certainly a very praiseworthy one the holding of the "Minyan" in the evening, usually at the request of a soldier who has "Jahrzeit" or who may be saying "Kaddish" for one of his parents. I remember one pleasant incident in this connection. We were about to commence service on Friday evening, when the Welfare worker asked whether any one of the soldiers desired to lead. A young man immediately volun-
teered, and he conducted the services admirably, as he had a fine voice. It turned out that he had been a "Chazan" in a small town in Pennsylvania before entering the army. We all pressed him to return the next week, and he promised to do so, but we never saw him again. He had probably been transferred during the week.
THE REASON FOR THIS FAILURE
Though considerable good has been accomplished in Jewish endeavor at the camps, there is still much that is lacking. The efforts expended do not suffer primarily, or even principally, from their paucity, they suffer rather from a lack of proper direction. The work, for the most part, is in the hands of men who have not the slightest conception of the great national convulsion through which Israel is at present passing, and of the promise of the future. A brilliant exception or two only confirms the fact that there are virtually no Zionists engaged in the work. It is to be hoped that some Zionists may take it up. It offers opportunities for serving the Jewish people as real as, though less romantic than, enlistment in the Jewish Legion. The Zionist organization must become active on every front.
The men now carrying it on work after the manner of mission houses rather than of protectors of the welfare of Fellow-nationalists. The Y. M. H. A. Building has become a sort of feeble institutional synagogue, a "Kaddish factory," with trimmings. And the Jewish soldiers in the American Army instinctively feel that something is missing here, and they thirst for something bigger, deeper in Judaism. They desire, in the midst of the strongly leveling environment in which they are living, to maintain their Jewish identity intact—their identity as complete Jews, not merely as Jews who are saying "kaddish" for deceased parents. It is this strongly nationalistic spirit for which the Jews in the army are looking. It is the duty of the American Zionist organizations to provide it.
SHACK OF JEWISH WELFARE LEAGUE AT CAMP UPTON
THE JEWISH SOLDIER IS DEEPLY AND FRANKLY JEWISH
The Jewish soldier is at present in a position, more than ever before, to appreciate the Zionist movement. Living as he does, an abnormal life, in which the economic and social aspects are practically wiped out, he is brought face to face with the real problem with the existence, and he knows, if he never knew before, that he is a Jew. They are all ready to lis-
ten to discussions of Zionism and anxious to know what it is all about. Their desire for such information is heightened by the fact that, despite the sameness of purpose which animates all the soldiers in the United States Army, the