Book-New and Old
Conducted by BERNARD G. RICHARDS
THE SPIRITUAL FAMILIES OF FRANCE
The physical diversity of the French people, so often noted and most recently remarked by Gertrude Atherton, whose war work in France has enabled her to come into contact with all the elements of the French people— this physical diversity has its counterpart in a spiritual diversity. Despite, however, the multiplicity of manifestation of the French spirit, it remains whole and distinct. Diversity is only the natural product of a civilization like the French where the individual is not straight-jacketed pro forma, but is enabled to develop and express himself in freedom.
In the course of this individualistic development a curious, paradoxical situation arose. One of the most active and strongly pronounced elements of French society, the Radical Socialists and Syndicalists, went so far as to declare at one of their congresses at Marseilles in 1908 that in case of war they would declare a rebellion. No doubt at the time they did not realize that this very freedom which permitted them to make such a declaration was a gift of their own country and would be destroyed the moment their country were destroyed. When the question, therefore, faced them in August, 1914 as to whether they should carry out their declaration or defend the free condition which made the declaration possible, they could give only one answer. To the Vandal from the North who came down to destroy the civilization of France with the spiritual freedom which it implies, they responded by shouldering their arms and baring their breasts to the barbarian invader. Thus, to them, the defense of France means the defense of what they cherish and hold most sacred.
It is curious and yet profoundly significant that the war in France has had the same meaning for all the diverse spiritual families of that land. No matter how antagonistic these families might have considered themselves in their relations to each other, all of them felt exactly as the most radical element in French society felt, namely, that to defend France was to defend their most sacred spiritual possessions.
It is this wonderful union of all the elements of French society in the defense of the sacred heartstone, that Maurice Barres, perhaps the greatest of all French publicists, sets forth in his book, “Les Diverses Familles Spirituelles de la France.” (The Different Spiritual Families of France). Boston, Houghton and Mifflin Co. ($1.60 net.) M. Barres simply quotes and comments upon the mass of correspondence from French soldiers on the firing line who, face to face with supreme dangers and supreme experiences, reveal the workings of their souls. The correspondence which M. Barres lets us read is that of men
who have already made the supreme sacrifice, and that sacrifice together with the splendid strength and sublime sincerity which breathes from their letters, gives the book a power to move not surpassed by anything in the great mass that has been written on the Great War. The Catholics and the Protestants, the Socialists and Traditionalists, all receive due acknowledgement of their heroism on behalf of endangered France.
What interests us in particular is the chapter that M. Barres devotes to the Jews. It should be noted that M. Barres used to be identified with the Anti-Semites in France. In the Dreyfus affair, M. Barres stood with the French Jingoes. A native of Lorraine, M. Barres has embodied the fiery and concentrated nationalistic emotionalism which only the experience of national misfortune has the power to evoke. It is therefore noteworthy that in his present volume M. Barres pays a glowing tribute to the patriotism, devotion and heroism not only of the French native Jews but of the alien and adopted ones as well.
In this chapter on the Jews, M. Barres analyzes the spiritual experiences of a number of Jewish types and individuals. There is Robert Hertz, son of an immigrant German Jew, who is happy that he is able to vindicate with his life his right to the glorious privilege of French citizenship. There is Roger Cahen the free-thinking super-intellectualized Jew, who looks upon war and its dangers as a welcome opportunity for deepening his soul. Then there is the native, religious Jew, exemplified in the Jewish chaplain, M. Bloch, whose heroic death, met in the act of extending spiritual solace to a dying Catholic soldier, is one of the sublime epic incidents in the War. The Algerian Jews, also, forming as they do a large proportion of the French Zouaves, are mentioned gratefully and admiringly by M. Barres.
But the most interesting figure of all is an alien Jew, a Zionist, a young man of fiery and prophetic temperament. Amédée Rothstein offers himself to France because he is convinced that the Allies victorious will rehabilitate the Jewish people in Palestine. It is curious to note that M. Barres does not really understand Mr. Rothstein. It must be borne in mind that M. Barres wrote before the British and French Declarations. He seems to look upon Mr. Rothstein as a sublime but rather deluded idealist.
“Did he,” asks M. Barres, “expect to obtain from the victory of the Allies the realization of the curious plans, which are not without grandeur, of Dr. Herzl, or did he, more simply and with more certainty, desire to increase through sacrifice the moral force and prestige of Israel? One word which he ut-
tered leaves no doubt of the strength and direction of his thought. He told his friends he would meet them after the war in Palestine.” Amédée Rothstein, for “having displayed remarkable vigor and coolness” and for “having particularly distinguished himself on the 25th of September, 1915, by being the first to leave the trenches, and vigorously carrying his men along with him,” rose to rapid promotion. He fell on August 18th, 1916 at the head of his men, struck by a bullet in the forehead. Mr. Barres reports also his ultima verba. “At the present moment,” wrote Mr. Rothstein to his chaplain, “I hold my life as wholly sacrificed, but if fate should be kind enough to spare me, after the war I shall consider my life as no longer belonging to me; and, after having done my duty towards France, I shall devote myself to the great and unhappy Jewish People from whom I am descended. My dear Chaplain, in case I should die, I should very much like to sleep under the Shield of David, A Mogen David would rock me with a last thrill and my soul would be happy in the thought of sleeping my eternal sleep under the shadow of the emblem of Zion.”
With thousands of Jewish Legionaries now fighting together with the British and French for the liberation of Palestine for the Jewish People, in accordance with the official promise of the Allies, M. Barres no doubt now understands much better what it was that was agitating the soul of Amédée Rothstein, which goes to show that even to bring understanding to the finest and deepest minds, verbal propaganda is as nothing compared with the convincing power of events.
I. G.
THE AWAKENING OF TREDICK
The slow and halting realization of the significance of the war on the part of the foreign population of this country has been a source of much study and investigation, and amateur sociologists and naïve uplifters are still speculating as to the meaning of the divided opinion and the stress of conflicting emotions which prevailed on the East-Side during the early stages of the world conflict. But Tredick is a typical New England town, almost entirely inhabited by natives of the country, and graphically pictured for us in “Khaki” by Freeman Tilden (New York, The Macmillan Company, $1.50), as characteristic of hundreds of towns of the same size, and Tredick was exceedingly, painfully dilatory in recognizing the full significance of the great war. Tredick’s response to the sinking of the Lusitania was a holding of a pacifist mass-meeting.
“The news that the great ship loaded with men, women and children—not soldiers—had