With the Zionist Commission
By LEON SIMON
(The first installment of the vivid Palestinian impressions of Mr. Leon Simon, member of the Zionist Commission, appeared in the October Maccabaean. They are reprinted from the English Zionist Review.)
(3) HEBRON
HEBRON is in a way more eloquent than even Jerusalem of the contrast between the Jewish past and the Jewish present. In saying this I am not thinking simply of the condition of its present Jewish population, though that is poor and degraded enough in all conscience. How indeed should it be otherwise, seeing that Hebron is one of the four "Holy Cities"? But Hebron emphasizes our low estate in a way peculiar to itself. In Jerusalem we still cut something of a figure. We are the largest single nationality there; a great deal of the business and some of the industry of the city is in Jewish hands; Jewish learning and teaching, both in the old style and in the new, are at home in Jerusalem; and both the Jewish philanthropy and the Jewish nationalism of the West have made their mark on the city. But in Hebron the Jews are nothing; they might all disappear, and Hebron would remain what it is. And yet in Jewish history Hebron is a city beside which Jerusalem is a mere mushroom. While the story of Jerusalem begins with David, Hebron goes back to Abraham, to the very beginning of our race. It contains the graves of the Patriarchs; its neighborhood is full of reminiscences of our national infancy. It was also the seat of David's kingdom before he moved to Jerusalem. Remembering these things, one is overwhelmed by a sense of loss and of retrogression such as even Jerusalem does not excite.
I quote from my diary an account (written at Jerusalem on April 24th) of a brief visit to Hebron.
“To-day Dr. Eder and I went to Hebron in a motor-car placed at our disposal for the purpose by the Military Governor. We set out at nine this morning, and were back before five. The journey (about twenty-five miles each way) was delightful. The road is very good as far as Bethlehem, not so good thereafter, but still tolerable; and there was practically no dust—a pleasant contrast this to the journey from Jaffa. The sun shone brightly the whole time, but it was not too hot, and there was a strong and refreshing breeze, especially on the return journey. The country is very pleasing. The road runs between hills which are like very large mounds, grass-covered but with much bare stone showing. In parts I was reminded of the Yorkshire moors, and I should have loved to get out and clamber over the hills. It would be a great country for a walking tour—though I suppose one would have to carry a supply of water. Wild flowers abound, and there are beautiful valleys of olive and fig trees, besides much ploughed land. Hebron itself is one of the most beautifully situated towns I have ever seen, and its natural advantages are enormous. The country around is extraordinarily fertile, and produces the best grapes in Palestine, besides olives, almonds, wheat and barley. The climate is perfect, and there is abundance of water. Some day it will be a fine city. But at present it is otherwise. The Arabs—there are said to be about 20,000 of them—are of the usual Palestinian type, and though many of them are quite rich, they are content to
spend their days in dirty narrow streets and to go about clothed like beggars. The number of Jews is now about 850. They own no land, and have been used to living on Chalukah; and now that that source of revenue is cut off, they have to live on such meagre charity as they can get. But in Hebron also the awakening has begun. Many of the young men want to work on the land or at anything else; there is already a Hebrew kindergarten, and they are anxious to have schools and to have the Hebron branch of the Anglo-Palestine Company reopened in order to promote industry and commerce. All this will be done in time, and if we can get some land and introduce an agricultural element, the Jewish community of Hebron will soon become progressive and thriving. It is really not very difficult, especially now, to make the transition from the old life to the new. It wants only a few men of energy and initiative to set the younger generation on the right track—We came to Hebron quite unannounced, but we were soon taken in charge by the Rabbonim (Ashkenazi and Sephardi—they seem to live in harmony) and the leading men of the place, who took us into their best house (it belonged to one Kliansky, now dead, and is inhabited by his widow and children), and talked to us about the community and its needs. Then they showed us the hospital and the Yeshibah—both at present occupied by the military authorities, but soon, I hope, to be restored. They are both good buildings, but the Yeshibah was badly damaged by the Turks, who also stripped the hospital bare, though they did not injure the building. After that we had a talk with the Governor, who was very friendly. Then we had lunch (we had brought our food with us), and afterwards were taken to the kindergarten, where we heard the children sing and were presented with a bouquet, and to the Cave of Machpelah, which Jews are not allowed to enter. Incidentally we saw the old Jewish ghetto—a weird hive of incredibly narrow and malodorous passages. We started back at three, incidentally taking with us, at the request of the army doctor at Hebron, a harmless lunatic to be deposited at the Jewish Lunatic Asylum here.”
This account of Jewish conditions in Hebron requires some modification in the light of information obtained afterwards. The present acting heads of the community, which has lost both its old Rabbonim, do not command sufficient authority or possess sufficient learning to raise the level of the community and make Hebron a real home of Torah. Steeped in spiritual as well as in material poverty, Hebron is hopeless even as a centre of the old Yishub. Before I left Palestine the Ashkenazi Rabbonim of Jerusalem were proposing to send a Rav and some scholars to Hebron to relight the lamp of learning and constitute a proper Rabbonim authority. That is an idea which has a claim to Zionist support, for Zionism has now to shoulder responsibility for the old Yishub as well as for the new, and it cannot hold its hand from the task of helping—or rather compelling—the old Yishub to live up to its own ideals. But Zionism cannot rest satisfied with that. It must do for