The Maccabaean
East. Comment on a view so expressed and so supported, is superfluous.
It brings a certain relief to come to a book like that of Mr. Schreiner’s. For, as Sir Thomas More would have said, this at least “is somewhat.” It is a record of experiences that did not fall to the lot of everyone to have. Mr. Schreiner was correspondent for an American paper or papers, in Constantinople during the war, was personally present at the Dardanelles while the bombardment of the forts was going on, and in the Gallipoli trenches, and saw with his own eyes the wreck that the 1908 massacres had made at Adana, and part of that most pitiable of human spectacles, the dreadful caravan that Talaat and Enver sent into the desert to solve the Armenian problem. We may well suppose that Mr. Schreiner has accurately recorded the external experiences that it was his privilege to have. If the internal experiences had been even measurably adequate to the moving and dramatic events he is chronicling, we should have abundant reason to be grateful. As it is, one can only regret that it is possible for a little man to rub up intimately against big things, without notably increasing his stature.
Much must be forgiven the writer’s evident lack of proper training. Intellectually he is as raw as an imperfectly calorified potato. There will be a time when a rather large stock of general information and rather full apprehension of the spiritual heritage of the race, will be demanded of those that undertake the responsibilities of journalism; but, so long as nothing is required beyond a fund of natural impudence and a certain volubility of phrase, we must resign ourselves to encountering schoolboy solecisms in books like this, as well as to the tone of self-complacent vulgarity that characterizes most of them.—as it does this one.
Mr. Schreiner has obviously taken Mark Twain as his model of style. However the turns of phrase and unexpected endings that made up so large a part of Mark Twain’s humor, are personal and peculiar to the man. When they are imitated in cold blood, they are frightfully vapid and dull. Otherwise, Mr. Schreiner evinces an adolescent propensity for “Ye Gods,” and “Boom!” that make one wonder whether Tarkington’s Seventeen was not rather a state of mind than a number of years. He is perpetually introducing French phrases that are not one whit clearer or better than the simplest English expressions that they replace, and are, in the original the veriest banalities. On several occasions, his erudition tempts him into referring to the Koran as the Qua’raan, although Quran is all that the most pedantically precise transliteration will get out of the. Arabic word, and although Koran is a definite English word with a history older than the oldest monument of Journalese. When he mentions the virus Constantinopolus, and the bacillus Constantinopolus, it is less the absurd blunder in grammar that attracts our attention, than the crass pretentiousness. But crassness and pretentiousness are writ large all over the book. It is only its vivacity that makes it possible to read it quite through.
Mr. Schreiner is at some pains to depict himself as a fellow of infinite resource, enterprise, energy and wit. There is introduced another journalist, one Swing, who may or may not have really existed, but who is obviously brought in merely to set off the superior resource, enterprise, energy and wit of the inimitable Schreiner. We gain the distinct impression that the American embassy
visibly leaned on the only correspondent in the Near East, whenever it desired any special favor of Enver, and when we take up Mr. Morgenthau's book, it is with real surprise that we discover that it was the American Ambassador who gained for Mr. Schreiner permission to visit the Dardanelles.
But if the writer's crudities may be overlooked, there are other things harder to forgive. It is a hard thing to charge a man with moral callousness, and I should not like to say this hard thing of Mr. Schreiner. Yet he knew, not by report, but by the unblinking eyes of flesh, the tragedy of Armenia, and the sight seems to have moved him to nothing deeper than the exclamation "Poor wretches!" or "Poor devils!" He gives an undue prominence to Turkish exculpation, and he has nothing to say of the assignment of personal responsibility. Indeed, in other respects Enver has been quite too gracious, to make it possible for him to judge that dapper little assassin harshly. He has been unable, he tells us, to "run to earth the story" that Enver was directly implicated in the shooting of Nazim Pasha. We wonder whether it would have been quite so difficult for a man less dazzled by the authentic autograph of Enver himself, obliging photographed for us.
If J have found fault with Mr. Benson for being too violent and with Mr. Schreiner, for being too mild, in their reactions to the Armenian atrocities, it is because these atrocities can be set forth without unnecessary rhetoric and without palliation. Mr. Morgenthau’s book shows us that it is possible. It is a truism, discovered several thousand years ago, that, where the facts are too dreadful for words, a simple statement of them is the most effective portrayal. A considerable portion of Mr. Morgenthau’s book deals with the Armenians and _ his straightforward recital of what occurred, stirs the reader to a passion of anger and pity. And it does not exhaust itself in that. The evidence presented fully justifies the verdict of guilty that he himself,and the majority of men with him,—have brought against the ruling clique of Turks and their German accessories after and before the fact.
The rest of Mr. Morgenthau’s book is of equal interest and, from a documentary point of view, of even higher importance. It is the sort of thing that in previous generations, used to appear twenty or thirty years after the events, when memoirs of statesmen revealed motives and forces at work, that were not suspected at the time the events occurred. The expansiveness of Von Wangenheim makes us acquainted with the now famous Potsdam conference of July 6th and while the world did not wait for this piece of evidence to make up its mind as to responsibility for the war, it is of value for confirmation. This matter is the particular portion of the book that roused most attention when it was published serially in the World’s Work, and it is perhaps the most important sec- . tion in it. For myself, I confess to have read with greater zest and enlightenment, the vivid portrayal of the Young Turk leaders. It is an illuminating suggestion of Mr. Morgenthau’s that to understand Talaat, we have but to keep in mind certain types of political leaders, produced in a stage of our municipal politics, only partly discarded. He mentions no names, but not a few of these vigorous and forceful personalities occur to all of us that are older than jackals,—men of real power diverted to evil, by a defect of moral character, as well as by the