The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 5 · May 1919
29printed page
scan 24 of 34

The Maccabaean

Naturally much of the book is familiar to readers of the Saturday Evening Post, where the experiences of Mrs. Egan first appeared. She is virtually the only civilian allowed to enter the British War Zone in Mesopotamia since the military operations began there.

To anyone who has lived in the Arabian Nights and Persian lore, the prospect of a visit to Bagdad at any time is alluring. To go at one of the biggest moments of the world's history and to witness the brave end of a brave man is breath-taking.

General Maude is described as an inveterate worker, working all the time he was awake. He made every detail of his operations his personal business and delegated unshared responsibilities to nobody. He did not know what fear was. The attitude of his personal staff was devotion without question, and when he was not present they expressed their concern in his welfare with utmost freedom.

The story of General Maude’s death has been told in various ways. There seems little doubt that he developed cholera after drinking coffee into which he had poured cold raw milk. This fatal cup he drank at a unique entertainment given in his honor in a Jewish school. It has been said that he knew that the milk was unfit, and out of excessive courtesy drank it. It is said also that he did not know. Mrs. Egan, who was present, describes the entire entertainment, and it would seem from her description that no one present knew, although she says that later there was a suspicion that his enemies had murdered him.

The book continues after the death of General Maude and describes something of Lieutenant-General Sir William Marshal, Corps Commander on the Eastern Front. He was appointed to succeed General Maude in full command of the Mesopotamian Expeditionarv Force. E.F. Takins up the

burden Sir William obeyed that last order of General Maude to "carry on." Mrs. Egan's book is well worth while possessing.

The House of Judah

The House of Judah. By CHARLES EDWARD HEWITT. New York, Cincinnati. The Abingdon Press. $1.00.

This book is a love story of the days of Jesus and Paul. Naturally it is Christian in its point of view and so interprets the prophecies of Isaiah and all the other sanctions that Christian theologists think they find in the nronhets.

The book is interesting. Its readers can well be those who are curious about the manner in which the theme is treated, or who are still at the age at which a mere love story has thrills, no matter what its value as literature.

The Feast of Esther

The Feast of Esther. A Full Account of Its Laws, Customs and Rules. By ISAAC UNTERMAN, LL.D. Chicago, Ill. Jewish Publishing Company.

This little book describes for children the various laws, customs and rules for the celebration of Purim. It also retells the story of Esther not in an especially new way. It will be extremely interesting, however, to those who do not know the history of the mediaeval celebrations of Purim and who have not access to the sources that describe the dramatic dialogues of the fourteenth century. A German dialogue is given in free translation.

EMILY SOLIS COHEN.

Gleanings and Echoes of the Press

THE most important event of Jewish significance in Paris after the hearing of the Zionist representatives before the Council of Ten is the interview given to Judge Julian W. Mack, president of the Zionist Organization of America, and other Jewish representatives by the American Commissioners Robert Lansing, Colonel House and General T. H. Bliss. At this interview Judge Mack and his colleagues made the plea that the Jews be recognized as political groups and given minority rights in all the countries of Eastern Europe admitted to the League of Nations.

The representatives of American Jewry, however, of which Judge Julian W. Mack is chairman, did not confine themselves to asking national recognition to the Jews of Eastern Europe. They also advanced the claim of the Jewish people to Palestine. The latter claim is now considered as having been recognized by the Peace Conference. The first claim, however, is not so generally understood. Judge Mack advocates that the admission to the League of Nations of Poland, Bohemia, Ukrainia and other new states that may be proposed, be conditioned upon the granting of guarantees to the rights of speech, religion, and so on, to the Jews as a national group. The importance of this demand can be measured by the fact that in the reconstruction of central and eastern Europe, the fate of from eight to ten million Jews is involved. f

Another encouraging line of activity carried on by the representatives of American Jewry, is the integration into one unit of the various Jewish representatives now in Paris

from various lands. Unless the Jews present a united front to the Peace Conference on these fundamental claims, the Peace Conference will probably fail to give them any serious consideration.

However successful Judge Mack and his colleagues may be in organizing various Jewish representations, it is certain that he will not succeed in gathering into the fold one class of representatives. We are referring, of course, to those gentlemen, quite a number of whom have gone from America ostensibly for the purpose of advancing Jewish rights, but in reality with the sole object of placing obstacles in the restoration of Palestine to the Jewish people. The psychology of these gentlemen is as dificult to understand as that of the German junkers. Fighting in a thoroughly bad cause, they are compelled to use thoroughly bad methods. The facts, however, are always against them. They pretended that the Zionist representatives had bartered away the rights of the Jewish people in return for Palestine. Such was their explanation for the failure of the League of Nations Commission to include a clause in the covenant guaranteeing religious liberty. Before the exact reason for this failure was known, that pretension had a certain plausibility. They could not, of course, prove their contention. On the other hand, their contention could not be disproved. Now, however, that it has been explicitly stated that the failure to include that clause was due to the Japanese demands for the inclusion of another clause, it would be reasonable to expect that the pretense would no longer be

One Twenty-eight

May, 1919