The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 6 · June 1919
75printed page
scan 36 of 40

The Maccabaean

Industrial Franchise In Palestine

(Continued from page 143)

ployees, profits in accordance with their value to the industry in question, based upon the wage-earnings of every man, and payable in dividends out of net profits. Furthermore, the privilege of becoming an investor or shareholder will inure to every employee, and, if necessary, shares of persons not otherwise interested in the industry will be retired, upon just terms, in favor of employees seeking to invest surplus earnings in the industry in which they are employed.

5. While competitive enterprises will not be permitted in Palestine as being destructive of economic values and against public policy, ample provision will be made that no person for whom there is need in any given industry be excluded from participation in it. This can be effected, for example, through the medium of public examination similar to our civil service examinations, assuming that the individual in question can not avail himself of other means.

As an illustration at random, I have chosen a sugar plant. But it is obvious that the industrial organization of Palestine should begin with enterprises of whose success there cannot be the least question. Moreover, every emphasis should be put upon the development of such agricultural and manufacturing industries as will tend to supply the basic needs of Palestine itself and make its population as self-supporting as possible. We know something of the agricultural possibilities of Palestine. Among feasible industrial possibilities, I might mention the textile industry. I am reliably informed that this industry alone would be capable of maintaining 75,000 to 100,000 persons in Palestine.

III.

Given the conditions above mentioned, it will be possible for labor and capital to obtain a foothold in’ Palestine with the least delay ond upon terms that will offer the maximum returns consistent with security for both. It will still be incumbent upon the government to charge itself with the responsibility of enforcing adequate labor laws respecting sanitary working conditions, hours of labor, minimum wage limits, etc. Indeed, such regulations can be most effective only under conditions of economic stability and the standardization of values. For example, how effective can we expect minimum wage laws to be if the prices of commodities remain unrestricted? Moreover, under economic anarchy we can force the employer to adopt sanitary measures, but what do we do to prevent him from succumbing to competition and throwing his employees out of work?

Doubtless the extension of industrial franchise to all industries must occasion problems and difhiculties. Manifestly I cannot discuss them within the limits of this article. Nor is it necessary to claim for industrial franchise that it is a panacea. Let it suflice to say that it is the right method of approach as distinguished from the wrong.

In his very interesting and instructive book, “Business— A Profession,” * Justice Brandeis makes the point, however, that there is a limit to the point of efliciency in big business enterprises; and that that limit is the capacity of the executives to cope with the situation. That is certainly true under existing conditions, which are bound to circum-

vent the capacity of any individual. Under economic anarchy, it is not sufficient that one may be a good mechanic, workman, inventor, banker or organizer; one must be able to combat the waves of competition which daily threaten to overwhelm him. It is not surprising therefore that when the Trusts, in defiance of public opinion and government authority, essayed to assume more and more burdens, their efficiency began to suffer. Despite enormous capital they had no secure footing to begin with.

Again, there is an impression that is gaining headway that the nationalization of the soil will cure our economic ills. But of what avail is it who owns the soil if all are privileged to play fast and loose with the values derived from the soil? It is not private ownership but speculation that we must check. Hence, under industrial franchise the individual would be safe in his private possessions. It is only when he attempts to enter the market to affect economic values that public policy compels a prescribed course, whether the subject-matter of his attempted trade is land or anything else. How speculation in land can and should be prevented I have indicated in my book already referren tn

If we look over the field in America, we can hardly fail to see that public franchise bestowed upon any industry carries with it the right of supervision and rate-fixing. It is true that some of our public utilities try to circumvent this right by corrupt methods. But corruption is simply a microbe, a disease that must be fought. It is not an impeachment of that franchise-system which gives the public the right of control. What is the franchise? It is a recognition of the fact that we struggle under conditions, not of capitalism as is so persistently claimed, but of economic anarchy in which there can be no security for anyone. Public franchise prevents trade competition or the competition of values in an area in which it is plainly manifest as destructive to the interests of all concerned. Why not extend industrial franchise to all economic spheres?

Both the workman and the consumer pay a high premium for the use of capital under conditions of economic risk. Eliminate that risk by means of the industrial franchise, and we eliminate the necessity of paying the premium for the risk and simply pay for the use of capital operating practically without the possibility of loss. Instead, we cause the consumer to confront the producer, enable them to deal directly, without intermediaries, and pay for the actual cost of production.

Along these lines, I submit, it is possible to enable the worker to become the beneficiary, instead of the prey, of industry; safeguard the interests of legitimate enterprise and, in the very act of safeguarding, earn the right to control it in the interest of all concerned—the worker, the consumer and the investor.

Palestine today is a country without those highly ramified vested interests intrenched in other lands and immovable in the face of all necessity. It is still on the threshold of its new upbuilding. In meeting the problem of settlement and of its new life New Judæa can throw a bridge across to the land of its desire upon which the whole world might walk. It would be in keeping with the record of the Jewish people in meeting its national problems in former ages; and with its eternal significance to the world of nations.