The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 7 · July 1919
206printed page
scan 28 of 36

The Maccabaean

dox. But now, there is a new spirit in the Agudas-Yisroel, and especially among the juvenile group-element. The prevalent idea among the young people is, that the Jewish national program must be supported. From the junior groups of the Agudah, the spirit has infected the general groups.

“The attitude, however, of the German emissaries of the Aguda in Poland has been disavowed by the Mizrachi from the first, and we have never endorsed the action of the other German Orthodox Jews in this matter. Especially the Polish Mizrachi have made front against their attitude. This, however, is a closed incident. What separates at present Mizrachist orthodoxy from the other groups, is not the Zionist demands, but the ways and means towards their realization. This is the task that we Mizrachi have set ourselves: if a new Jewish culture is to be erected in Palestine, we must take care that it should not be created ex nihilo, or founded upon French, English, or German culture— in fact upon anything but that old Jewish tradition which has outlasted twenty centuries. The Agudah has approached no Zionists with certain demands. The Administration has answered, and I want to say, as regards their ofhicial reply: I am glad that it reaflırmed the assurances of previous Congresses, that nothing will be undertaken in Palestine that runs counter to the tenets of traditional Judaism. But I wished the reply had added this: ‘Zionism is a movement resting upon democratic principles. If you Orthodox desire to maintain your principles within Zionism, all you have to do is to join in such numbers as to insure you a numerical majority. If, on the strength of such a majority, we realize our demands, it is plain that the entire Orthodoxy will have to uphold us, and that the Jewish masses of the East, the custodians of our religious traditions through many centuries, will all join.’ ”

Herr Lichtheim’s Palestine referat contained the following passages of more than common interest:

“We want to make Palestine a homestead for the Jewish people. With this simple sentence, we have enunciated a problem of the utmost difhiculty. There is Palestine—a strip of Mediterranean littoral, of diminutive extent, economically undeveloped, to a large extent devastated—and there are our people, fifteen millions, dispersed over the face of the globe, its parts of extremely varying mental and economic structure. Our colonization is to reunite land and people—easy in concept, enormously difficult in the execution. We must figure with the needs, wishes and capabilities of fifteen millions, with the natural limitations of Palestine, with its location, its frontiers, climate, population and economic possibilities. The accounting is by no means smooth reckoning, and the process of re-uniting land and people bristles with difhculties.

“Of course, we all know that Palestine proper is not extensive enough to shelter our entire people. We must see to it, first of all, during the political negotiations, to get favorable boundaries. Palestine proper consists of about 30,000 square kilometers, and, under favorable conditions, may possibly support five million people. We need not envisage just now any overflow-settlements in Northern Syria and Mesopotamia. For the next decades, we must face the fact that the labor of several generations will be necessary before three million people can settle upon holy soil. The colonization of an entire country is always a difhcult prob-

lem which can be solved only step by step. Enormous amounts of capital are requisite to acquire the necessary soil for settlement, to sanitate it, parcel it out, provide it with roads, cisterns and forests. The human material for agricultural colonization needs to be, for the most part, especially reared and trained. Noteworthy industries, capable of sustaining large masses, do not exist. They may spring into life later on, but only with the buying power of a well-to-do agricultural population to back them. A mushroom-growth of industries, completely dependent upon export, would be distinctly harmful to the economic upbuilding of a Jewish commonwealth

“0.0. The fact is, we must decide upon definite immigration policies. Our task is a threefold one: in the first place, we must carefully coach the Jewish people regarding the possibilities for the immediate future, so as to prevent an indiscriminate rush toward Eretz Yisroel. Secondly, we must organize, as far as possible, a regulated and selective emigration in all countries. Finally, we must do everything needed to ease the lot and smooth the way for desirable firstcomers on Palestine soil. For all these purposes, it is necessary to create distinct institutions. In Palestine itself, we must have a Central Immigration Bureau. This Immigration Bureau has to provide provisional shelter and medical aid, give every requisite information, and serve as a national labor bureau. This Central Palestinians oflice must be in permanent contact with emigration oflicers in all countries, whose first aim it must be to inform all aspirants about local Palestinian opportunities, and to prevent a chaolic rush. The emigration oflices, furthermore, must promote, as far as possible, the formation of emigrant groups. The formation of such groups, cemented together through a common place of nativity, a common profession or through special group interests is very important because it keeps interest in the cause alive and facilitates the spread of Palestinian information. The group itself is a basis for selective sifting, chiefly of the automatic kind. Unfit elements, after receiving definite information about pioneer hardships, are likely to drop out; the others will be forewarned and forearmed. The formation of a common treasury among workmen’s circles is likewise to be encouraged, the treasury to display the cost of group transportation, of sustenance during the first season of settlement, of the sending of advance agents, etc. The emigration oflices must enter into compacts with steamer lines for Ihe securing of standards of comforts and sanitation during the passage, must sent their own confidential agents with each transport, and so on. To render a selective immigration practicable, I endorse Dr. Ruppin’s recommendation, to extend certain privileges, such as cheaper transportation, the free use of employment agencies, first credits, etc., only to those that emigrate to Palestine with the secured consent ‚of the emigration ofice. That sounds like a severity but it is merely an absolutely necessary safeguard, if we do not want to see the beginnings of our colonization work trampled down into the dust by chaotie cohorts of the unfitted . . .

“If it is our duty to restrain the unfit, it is no less our duty to further and to help in every way those that are really fit for pioneer work. . . . What Zionist organizations must teach, is not only agriculture, but Hebrew as well. Prospective immigrants must be made to understand that the duty is incumbent upon them, to create for their children a Hebrew Palestine.”