The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 8 · August 1919
225printed page
scan 11 of 40

The Maccabaean

way to the final redemption; in all our subsequent Egypts the women and the homes have had much the same function of healing the spiritual wounds that had been smitten by the respective Pharaohs.

Yet these reflections are far from exhausting the subject of what should be the normal, the just relation between Zionism and Judaism. Zionism needs Judaism; it is not complete without it; the unreligious Zionist is an incomplete Zionist; his Zionism is self-contradictory and inconsistent; it disregards or misunderstands Jewish history; it makes the mistake of seeking to continue Jewish history in a spirit antagonistic to its entire previous development, to superimpose upon a career, consistent in all its parts, a continuation completely out of harmony with what had gone before.

I am perfectly willing to admit, as a psychological axiom, that, in the logical course of development, national instincts precede religious teaching, that a wholesome and vital religious life must be, safely and deeply, rooted in national traditions, in a national environment; what I cannot and will not admit is that the time has come, when Israel must seek his greatness and his ripeness in material, rather than in religious and spiritual ends. For, no matter how beautiful and desirable, no matter how completely in accord with prophetic vision and prophetic preachment the consummation of social justice might seem, no matter how assuredly such a consummation will bring about a moral advance, it is a materialistic ideal, after all, which can achieve neither complete contentment nor perfect harmony, least of all represent the last word in soul-growth. The supreme end, after all, must remain the old ideal of the priestly commonwealth, the holy people. Unless our model plan of social equality, unless our pattern government of utter righteousness in the dispensation of opportunity and privilege, unless all these lead to higher levels of spiritual manhood, to finer atmospheres of religious living, they will certainly have fallen short of their ultimate fruitage.

There may be those, of course, to whom religion spells a mere survival from unsophisticated days, a superstitious encumbrance, left over from the periods of mankind's infancy. It is not difficult to meet these on their own ground; if anything is obsolete and out of date today, it is, on the contrary, both the cocksure sophomorism of the uncompromising atheist and the shallow pseudo-rationalism of the unimaginative agnostic; we have arrived at a day, when, reading the boundless world of fact in the light of the mystery which enfolds it, we bow, in our readings of inner life, past and present, to the omnipresence of religious instincts and needs which are as firmly grounded as are any of the other pillars of the explorable universe.

Religion will vanish as little out of the life of advancing humanity as nationality will. A colorless unfaith is as unlikely in the ultimate evolution, as is an indiscriminate internationalism. As long as man will breathe, his yearnings and aspirations will shape themselves into systems of uplifting and comforting faiths, just as his loyalties will cluster around endeared habits, precious traditions, noble memories and cherished associations. These two, the memory and the hope, the loyalty and the faith are meant to cling to and twine with one another, to support and to

strengthen each other. The sturdiest and healthiest Zionism must be a deeply religious, a genuinely Jewish Zionism.

It is as absurd to conceive of a Jewish race without Jewish faith, as it is to posit a Jewish faith without a Jewish race. As little as you can draw any line, in the preachment of our prophets, between their religious faith and their moral teaching, between their spiritual manhood and their Jewish manliness, between their yearning for a sincere, God-pleasing worship and their fiery indignation against social, political, moral wrong, between their belief in a just, merciful, omnipotent God and their faith in progressing, sin-purged, war-freed man, so little can you imagine a non-religious Zion, a Holy Land resurrection, unkindled by any spark of religious faith.

One encounters, now and then, some of those absurd creatures who are haughtily proud of their remote Jewish ancestry, and mortally ashamed of their next-door Jewish relations. It is the most absurd, also the most contemptible of conceivable inconsistencies. These are the men and women who consider themselves aristocrats, because descended from generations of martyrs, and their brothers vulgarians, though surrounded by the continuing halo of that martyrdom. They claim for themselves the heritage of their heroic ancestors; but they repudiate that heroism, in their own lives, as stupid folly. To die on the pyre in Spain is to them, in the retrospect, the height of a romance; to die defending your dear ones against the fiends of a pogrom is something that fails either to appeal to their admiration or, much less, to arouse their sense of brotherhood.

In a way, the non-religious Zionist reminds one of these snobs, only his snobbery is intellectual, where theirs is of the social order; but in inconsistency, in the foolish attempt to snap the thread of continuity, he ranks alongside with them. You hear a radical extol the loftiness of the prophets, the constancy of our martyred generations; with what consistency can he praise their characters, their ideals, their preachments, their lives, and yet refuse to share the convictions which formed the pith and marrow of their manhood? If they were, indeed, martyrs (which means witnesses), then the thing to which they testified, through these ages, must have had some worth; else they suffered, senselessly, in the service of the merest delusions; or can we, with any approach to truth, contend that it was for the bare existence and continuance of the national bond that they lived and died?

No, the unreligious Zionist commits, religiously, the absurdity which the un-Jewish race-Jew commits racially; to the one, religion, to the other, race is something that was admirable in the past and is worthless in the present.

We speak of the Jewish spirit as the one constant element in the checkered course of our evolution. It is something utterly undefinable; it is that which stands out as typical in the Jewish life of the ages. From the type there is infinite variation, even to the length of opposite extremes; but it is the typical that stands out as our original contribution; and that typical something has been, beyond all doubt, intensely, unwaveringly, pervasively religious. The Jewish spirit has been, it always will be, deeply religious. It is a fervidly religious Zionism, and no other, that is bound, in the end, to rise to the place of authority.