The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXII, No. 10 · December 1919
351printed page
scan 53 of 82

The Maccabaean

willing to invest it. Remember that the Administration, when elected, expects to be trusted by you, as evidenced by the act of giving it power; and simply because you do not like me —and I do not blame you—is no reason why you should change the whole method of electing the Executive Committee, without giving ample time to the consideration of this proposal.

wi wii p’vpVSal “I confess to you that I am disappointed that the Zionist organization should spend hour after hour in talking about machinery and, in so doing, losing sight of our purpose and our object. I want the Organization to be free to-morrow, the day after the Convention adjourns, that we may g0 back to our synagogues, if to synagogues we go, or whatever our particular field in life may be, and, during all of the holy days, during the Rosh Hoshanah, begin our work far tha ranse The ranse needs jr

“No one has told you of the burden that rests upon us, the crushing burden.

bush > Fin “Do you think we enjoy going back to New York, those of us who may be members of the Executive Department, burdened as we are—and burdened with what? Not only with the overwhelming task of getting done what you have put before us, of meeting the obligations which you have imposed upon us, but now with the necessity of spending three of the best and most precious months after the summer vacation, talking about the arrangement of a vote on a constitutional chanse of minor imnortänce.

“I ask you to vote for the substitute motion, in which I have no pride of authorship, merely that we may go back to work, and that we may give our fellow Zionists the chance to pass an earnest judgment upon this question.”

_ The final note of the discussion was sounded by Mr. Neumann in the followine address:

“Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen: I had never suspected that on the floor of this Convention my puny self would be matched against the peerless eloquence of our leader, Dr. Wise. I might have considered twice before I undertook to defend the resolution, had I understood what was confrontinz me.

“However, I desire first to read to you the substance of our proposed changes, free of all intricacies of the terminology of the Constitution and its amendments.

“The following are the proposals, simply without any details, or without any complications:

“The members of the Zionist Organization of America shall elect the members of the National Executive Committee by direct vote, on the basis of one for every three thousand members.

“The present Administration shall determine the precise method of election and the basis of representation.

““Secondly: The National Executive Committee shall elect the heads of the following departments—and then we name them:

“* Palestine, Organization, Education, Finance, General Jewish Affairs.

“These heads of departments shall be officials of the Zionist Organization of America.

“The Annual Convention shall elect no more than ten members at large, to serve on the National Executive Committee, in addition to those elected by the direct vote of the members, and the election for members of the National Executive Committee—and consequently also the Administrative Officials—shall this year take place not later than December 1st.

“Until the members of the New National Executive Committee are elected, the present Executive Committee and Administrative Committee shall remain in power.”

“As to the question of haste, I submit that these resolutions are not being acted upon in haste. There have been occasions when we have acted much more hastily upon

vastly more momentous questions and issues than these, Last year we undertook what was really a revolutionary reorganization of our movement. I was in favor of the district plan, but I knew that it meant the surrender on the part of the Zionists of habits of mind, of habits of association and forms of association to which they had grown devoted through twenty years of service in the Zionist cause; and yet, when the Administration convinced us that this was necessary for the good of the cause, we yielded our personal objections, and we all sank our differences in order to create this new and beautiful Zionist Orsanization af America.

ET “And yet that was not done by referendum, there was no commission appointed at the preceding Convention to prepare the plan, and there was no discussion of it in the regional conferences. There was nothing. The Admin-, istration came in with a plan. We argued the plan for a day or two. We trimmed it, changed it, amended it, and then. acted upon the plan, and that settled it for the rest of the year, and for all time, so far as we are concerned. Who was hasty then? We are not trying to ram things down people’s throats, and there is no reason why anyone should attempt to ‘obstruct the wishes of the Zionists, if thev desire to do somethine.

“There was done precisely what Dr. Wise wished to have been done. It was considered by the Zionists at various regional conferences. In New York, which represented something like 500 delegates, fully one-third of the total delegation of the Zionist Organization.spent two days elaborating upon this and other resolutions. It was considered -by the Minneapolis Regional Conference and other midwestern regional conferences, and the Chicago delegation considered this thing very carefully before the Convention. I submit that we were not hasty, and we are not hasty, and I submit that we have a right to express our free judgment on this question, on the. floor of the Convention, at this verv time.” j on

Dr. Wise’s substitute resolution was now taken to a vote. The vote was recorded as 237 for and 261 against. Next was the vote on the minority report, the adoption of which required a two-thirds majority, it being an amendment to the Constitution.

Mr. de Hass asked that the vote be taken seriatim. This was seconded by Mr. Neumann. The Convention then voted on the main question of the resolution. The vote was declared 309 for the amendment and 182 against.

As the chairman announced that the vote lacked the necessary two-thirds majority by 26, following this there was an insistent demand from all parts of the house that there be a roll-call. It was then moved and seconded that a roll call be taken at the next session, after which the Convention adjourned at 6:37 to reconvene Thursday morning.

EIGHTH SESSION

THE MASS MEETING, WEDNESDAY EVENING, SEPTEMBER 17

The largest attendance of Convention week—a tightly packed audience of 4,000 souls—crowded the Auditorium when the meeting was called to order at 8:50 P. M. The Zimro Ensemble rendered a beautiful program of six numbers, which was greeted with long-continued applause by delegates and visitors alike.

At the conclusion of the musical program President Mack took the chair, and at the outset of his address to the enthusiastic masses of delegates and visitors before him, invoked the memory of Theodor Herzl and of the first Zionist Congress, twenty-two years ago, before recounting the recent triumphs of the movement and reminding his