The Maccabaean
who would insist on speaking Hebrew to a legionary; and, surely, there is not one who would refuse to answer a question put to him in Yiddish.
As, you see, it is all a pack of lies and it is going to increase by leaps and bounds, as the boys come home. And, in a very short time, they will all be back in America, as it is believed that all those who return will be sent out of the country within a month. They number much more than it was expected a few months ago.
Small wonder conditions in Palestine are much worse than anybody outside of the country could imagine. In fact, the country has nothing of its own. Everything must be brought in and, just now, the country is still enemy territory, no import, no export, and, as a result, the workingmen in the cities cannot find work, and business is at a standstill. There is only one flourishing industry, the schnorrerindustry, with’ the Zionist Commission as the chief concern and the Chalukah institutions as the best client. In the colonies Jewish workingmen could find work, if ihey could bring themselves to work while starving. I said starving and I mean it. According to most conservative estimates, it requires 714 shillings a day to give a white man the most indispensable necessities of life. Necessity is an elastic term. Decent clothing, for instance, is in some quarters regarded as some sort of luxury.
Now, you cannot expect a man to pay $1.90, when he can get an Arabian for less than 50c, at the most 60c. So, the Jewish workingmen are barred from our colonies. They do not find anything to do, except to knock at the door of the Zionist Commission. The Commission can do very little, because Palestine is still enemy territory. They contemplated some quite unnecessary road building for the benefit of the workingmen. But the latter refused, saying that the Jewish public is not rich enough to squander money on unnecessary things. They proposed, instead, to spend the money in making land ready for cultivation. This, for some reason or other, could not be done.
The trouble with the working men is that they are "batlonim." They think more of a Jewish homeland than of themselves. Not so the colonists. They know very well that in order to create a homeland we must have sound colonies, which means the colonists should live in comfort. To attain this, they must have cheap labor, that is Arabian labor, and the means whereby to get it—loans. That's what they are interested in. And loans they do get. Petach-Tikvah got $250,000 and wants now a mere trifle of $2,000,000. Of course, they do not insist on the Zionists making the loan. They are ready to take the money wherever it will come from. But, as there is no other source, the Zionists will have to grant that "loan"—practical men, not "batlonim."
The Zionist Commission tries very hard to please all the elements and, naturally, pleases none. Our orthodox leaders are on the war path now against the new institutions of the "Apikorsim." Oh, we have a most warlike Rabbinate. The conference, preliminary to the constituent assembly, granted equal suffrage to women. Now our rabbis discovered this to be against the spirit of the Torah; and the battle between our progressive and retrogressive elements is raging, limited by the lack of paper only. Are we not playing at high politics? A constituent assembly, representing a population of about 100,000, mostly living on charity, without power to enforce its decrees, grand! However, it is not going to be convened, owing to the efforts of our rabbis. Urged on by this success and imbued with martial spirit, the Rabbinate has proclaimed a holy war upon the institution of a Jewish civil court. The motto of Israel's spiritual leaders is: Nothing, but by our consent. Healthy appetite, eh? But this most necessary institution refuses to succumb to the efforts of our priests.
But, let's drop it and get back to our subject. We are more than 300, determined to stay here, no matter what the conditions. Dr. Eder, the provisional head of the Zionist Commission, does his best to dissuade us from doing so. He advises us to go back now and return in a year or two, as it is impossible to find work and the Commission can do nothing. He seems to be amazed at our determination to stay. Well, you cannot go ahead and tell him that you are doing it because a certain stretch of land, called Carmel Promontory, fascinated you, or that a short trip to Lower and Upper Galilee has sent you off dreaming of things past and things to come. It's all rot one is ready to live or die for, but impossible to talk about.
I am again off the trail. The Zion Commonwealth, through its representative, Mr. Rosenblatt, offers work for 100 boys. The rest will have to find work somehow, or else they will not be discharged. The British government demands a written offer of employment for a year, in order to be locally demobilized. There is going to be some wire pulling before we get over this difficulty.
I fear the picture is too dark. There are other sides to it with more light. The Zionist Commission has done much good work. There is a younger Hebrew speaking generation and many things that gladden one's heart.
PRIVATE CHAIM GALPERN,No. 4133, Co. "D," 39th Battalion,Royal Fusiliers, Palestine.
With the Zionist Commission In Palestine (Continued from page 312)
A few words only need be added concerning the relations with the British authorities. It is necessary to bear in mind that the present administration is military—and is filling in only a transitional period. No one who knows the high standards of British honor can doubt that a civil administration appointed to carry out a mandate based upon the Balfour Declaration and its acceptance by the other great nations will do its full duty and will show the same tact and ability which has won for Great Britain the devotion of all its colonies and the admiration of the civilized world.
I might close here. But I cannot do so without voicing my conviction that, difficult as our task is, we shall succeed; and our success will be because we shall overcome the obstacles through energy and determination, we shall excel because of our high purposes. We shall build up and populate a land that has been devastated for centuries by applying our best powers. We shall succeed where others failed because of our greater love for the land, —because of our readiness for sacrifice. It is only through our people that the land will again prosper, will be healthful,—its bare hills clothed in vineyards, groves and forests, its barren plains covered with grain fields and luxuriant vegetation, with prosperous villages and towns everywhere, with a population excelling in all the arts, in knowledge, in culture, and in the highest of all, in social justice. In order to accomplish this we shall need our best and our ablest sons and daughters. It will require the best that is in us individually—and as a people. But we, the Jewish People, can afford only to do our best.
The Revelation
"Many of the Zionists whom I had thought lacking in courage showed themselves fearless to a degree when under heavy fire, while Captain Trumpledor actually revelled in it, and the hotter it became, the more he liked it."
The story of this Jewish captain and of his Palestinian comrades-at-arms is told by the commander of the famous Zion Mule Corps, Col. J. H. Patterson, in his thrilling tale
WITH THE ZIONISTS IN GALLIPOLI
The Most Unique Episode of the World War, Most Vividly Told It is yours free if you obtain for us five subscribers to the
Maccabaean The Zionist Monthly
A year's subscription is $2.00. The book (Publisher's Price, $2) will be sent to you free and postpaid, upon receipt of the five subscriptions.