The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 2 · February 1920
59printed page
scan 17 of 36

The Maccabaean

the doctrine of physical weakness, his mental stature was immediately lowered and in time obliterated. The negative philosophy of physical weakness made possible the positive phenomenon of an intense Jewish intellectuality against which the world was at all times helpless.

Every stratum of the Jewish people today is more or less affected by this philosophy. If it is not consciously experienced, it is none the less in operation. For the last generation, however, this philosophy of weakness has gone through a very interesting transformation. Those Jews who regard their Judaism and their national future with conscience and also good sense have strong reason to abandon the purely negative attitude as comprehended in the philosophy of physical weakness, which in the past was indispensable and prophylactic. Having blazed the way to a sound national future, a victory calling forth moral and physical courage of the finest description, they reached a stage where they can view every manifestation of weakness with abhorrence. Freedom begets physical robustness. The average height of the American born Jew is considerably greater than that of the Russian or Galician Jew. But the physical and spiritual vigor of the Jewish youth born on the free soil of Palestine is even more telling. The splendid normality of Jewish life in the Palestinian colonies makes unnecessary an undue emphasis upon one or another aspect of Jewish life. A happy and complete evenness, a well-rounded adjustment, is what thoroughgoing Jewish emancipation has brought forth. Square shoulders and unwavering eyes may as well as not be co-extensive with resolute Jewish learning, religiosity and idealism. The new Jewish philosophy is the philosophy of strength and not of weakness, of completeness and wholesomeness, and not of physical or moral dejection.

Those elements in Jewry that have not accommodated themselves to the new era in Jewish historical development are still under the sinister sway of the morbid trepidity which centuries of oppression have erystallized. Originally physical weakness brought on by the cruelty of nations, it reveals itself today in a lack of appreciation of physical perfection or in a spiritual faint-heartedness which very often reaches the condition of moral cowardice. The anti-nationalist attitudes of Reform and the social radicals may be explained by the weakness-strain which Jewish suffering has caused to be idealized. Whereas for many centuries physical self-denial guaranteed spiritual and intellectual ardor, emancipation, in the case of the anti-nationalist Jews, has meant the breakdown of the Jewish spirit without the age-long tendency to weakness disappearing from their mental make-up. The negative mentality of the Reform Jew or the Jewish radical is due to a distinctly pathological fact. The Jew who labors and prays for a renewal of the historic continuity of the normal Jewish life can dispense with the attitude of weakness and find himself face to face with sanguine courage. The Jew who flouts the future possibilities of Jewish nationhood or despises the national strivings of the Jewish peoples has lost the capacity for moral triumph and spiritual power. He is still in the vise of the weakness tendency. In his subconsciousness fear is an insistent force. He denies his selfhood and the world does not accept his denial. Having dismissed all that has

constituted Jewish achievement and civilization, he nevertheless has not found a means of exorcising his inherent faintness. He no longer suffers physical deficiency, but his gain in this respect is vitiated by a growing moral decadence and an absence of Jewish spiritual values.

But the national rebirth of Jewry has witnessed a resurgence of an ancient virility. Jews are indeed harking back to what was normal, even mandatory, in Jewish life when the Jews were in the splendor of their national hardihood. Like the leader of the tribe of Judah who plunged into the Red Sea and conquered its waves, young nationalized Jewry is making a bid for a glory and a power that is sanctioned by and memorialized in our sacred literature. The men of the Jewish Legion are truly like the Maccabees. For the liberation of their land and people they have waged war against the hereditary enemy and at the same time against those Jews who, without knowing it perhaps, had risen in the defense of an ancient moral disease—the moral weakness which has brought ruin to Western European Jewry and which but for the very national renascence contemporary history is acclaiming would have brought the death of a great part of the Jewish people.

The reappearance of the love of courage and vigor physical and social is not going to mark the passing of what is fundamental and eternal in Judaism. We are only going back to a remote traditional practice. The members of the Synhedrin were required to be men of harmonious fulsomeness men of learning, piety, bodily dignity, eco nomic sufficiency. The Jews in the early years of the diaspora clung to the ideals of an ancient régime in which wholesome practicality was not despised. Like the elders whom Moses was instructed to select and truly were the elders the captains of Israel were the members of the Synhedrin. But Jewish leaders of the recent past have not been faithful to the desirable norm. Despite the fatality of moral self-reviling from which they suffered, they pre tended to be the sceptered rulers of the Jewish people. It was a sad spectacle. A people inspired by an ages-long passion for final deliverance and freedom, straining at the leash of the diaspora, inherently staunch and forceful, could not be led adequately by men who boldly reduced the malady that was destroying them to a formula of political and religious dogmatism. In the error of moral weakness they saw a marvelous revelation of truth. Jewish history to these dated back in some cases to the French Revolution and in others to the Mendelssohnian dispensa tion.

The untruthfulness of it all has been called. The most radical departure in Jewish thinking and acting did not take place in Hamburg in 1818 or in Berlin a generation or two before that eventful year in the history of dogmatic Reform. The most significant change in the attitude of thinking Jews has occurred within the last twelve months. Never before has such a blow been struck at the untenable dogma of physical and moral weakness which if not expressed in so many words has been lived and articulated by an appreciable section of our people. Day after day the repudiation of the philosophy of weakness is growing in volume and intensity. Its utter rejection is a matter of but a few fleeting years.