The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIII, No. 5 · June 1920
186printed page
scan 32 of 57

Gleanings and Echoes of the Press

The Home Decree: Press Rejoicings and Congratulations in America and Elsewhere—Certain Sons of Belial—The Jabotinsky Affair—The Feisal Mystery—Other News and Views from O. E. T. South

WHEN, on Sunday, April 25, 1920, the telegraph flashed around the globe the news that the Treaty of the Entente Powers with Turkey will contain a clause declaring Great Britain the Mandatory over Palestine to protect and develop there a Jewish Homeland, a tremendous wave of cheering swept over both hemispheres by no means emanating exclusively from the international centers and scattered colonies of the Jewish world-community. Of course, the Jewish world-community, when its millennial dream came true, led the cheer in vast volumes of revelry, from San Francisco to London, from France to Egypt, from Finland to Palestine anywhere and everywhere where there are any Jews, many or few. As we are writing, the jubilation tokens of the Jewish press in many lands lie before us on our desk, in bold-faced headings in a veritable Babel of tongues: "Palestine Unser!" "La Realisation du Sionisme!" "Eretz Israel, Our Homeland!" and so on, in Dutch, English, German, French, Yiddish, Italian front pages in every language of any importance, all aglow with unquenchable chiliastic enthusiasm. But this vast volume of self-congratulation is as nothing compared with the extent of press-congratulations and encouraging press-comment from the Gentile outside. The entire international press with very few discordant exceptions grasped wildly at this solitary chance of commending an international arrangement about which there is very little factional dispute.

The greatest Jewish interest, for obvious reasons, centers upon the press-voices emanating from the metropolis of the new Mandatory Power—London. Lord Northcliffe, with his usual keen scent for successful or potentially successful issues and movements, is among the encouragers and congratulators. Among the mixed motives prompting his stand, ranks probably the chance to serve another admonitory notice upon the Lloyd-George cabinet. It is served in an editorial of the London Times. In its issue of April 27, the Thunderer thunders as follows:

The British Government must no longer be exposed to suspicion of seeking to evade an obligation solemnly undertaken. In this country it is hardly realized how strong that suspicion has become, not so much, or even principally, on account of the action or inaction of the British Cabinet itself, as because of the attitude of the British administrative authorities in Palestine, whose bias has been strangely anti-Zionist.

There follows then a sympathetic reference to the case of Lieutenant Jabotinsky—an affair to be briefly reviewed hereinafter.

The Pall Mall Gazette, in its issue of April 26, went on record as favoring the British Mandate—favoring it cautiously and with guarded qualifications. The London Evening Standard exhibits to the world a care-wrinkled brow:

The British Government is to be asked to create such conditions as would secure the entry of a considerable number of Jews into Palestine within the next two years. But what about the Arabs? An Arab Empire was proclaimed recently at Damascus. Is the Emir

Feisal expected to be content with a declaration that steps will be taken to respect Arab rights? British opinion . . . is fairly solid in support of the Jews, but this does not get over the fact that a very thorny problem still faces France and us.

A much warmer, less guarded and more neighborly tone prevails in the almost unanimous congratulations of the American press. The following editorial of the New York Globe is a fair specimen of a big chorus of cordial American press-voices:

The way is at last open for the establishment of a republic in the promised land. Zionists from many climes have bent their energies during the last two years toward the international recognition of the necessity of a permanent home for the wandering tribes, and with England's acceptance of the mandate for Palestine the time for planning passes, the time for action arrives. The promise of Secretary Balfour to Lord Rothschild is to be fulfilled, and the date of the founding of a Jewish state is at the option of the Jewish people who have demanded it. Better auspices could not be asked or desired. England has been the most just and most friendly of all European nations toward citizens of Semitic blood, and her protection means absolute security from outside dangers.

The land of Palestine is no easy, pleasant region—no refuge for lotus eaters. It yields well, but it demands modern scientific methods and a wealth of hard work. These the Jews must bring. And they will need tact and courtesy if they are to get along amicably with the inhabitants of the country already native and acclimated. The jangling of sects about the shrines of the Holy City is already fierce enough. Some way must be found to avoid religious contention in this birthplace of great religions.

Success or failure depends on the spirit of the venture. At the most it presents no difficulties comparable with the problems faced by pioneers in the new world a few hundred years ago.

Le Peuple Juif (Paris), in a splendidly edited jubilation-issue, breaks out, on its front page, into an uncontrollable shout of relief:

Aprés les angoisses que nous avaient causées les recents evenements, voici enfin la consolation espérée—a keynote endlessly echoed and re-echoed in the Joodsche Wachter, the Vienna Morgen-Zeitung, the Prague Selbstwehr, the Berlin Rundschau, the Cairo Revue Zioniste—wherever Zionist fears and Zionist triumph followed close upon each other's heels.

To come home for a moment from this survey of press-comment abroad: On our Yiddish newspaper row, on East Broadway, Zionism, for the first time, has scored with the Jewish Forward—which, for the time being, elects to be Jewish as well as forward. Mr. Cahan, who can be depended upon to speak respectfully of powerful and undeniable Jewish majorities, has "nothing but the deepest sympathy and the highest respect for all those who can wax enthusiastic over an ideal, and this is what we feel at this moment toward the Zionists." The Zionists, to be sure, were equally enthusiastic over their ideal one, two, three years ago, without any tokens of editorial esteem on the part of the Forward—but they were not then irresistibly in the ascendant, which makes a good deal of difference at 171 East Broadway.