The Maccabaean
to attempt to "get anywhere" in the limited space at my disposal), and second, for the personal tone that may pervade what I have to say. For I went to Europe as a student—more specifically, it is true, of philology, but inevitably and generally, of the seething masses of humanity in whose midst I lived—and I was under no obligation to reduce my observations into a report to be presented to this or that investigating commission.
First, then, let me say at once that I was more than agreeably surprised by the intensity of the Jewish life that I encountered in Paris. It is a fact that this Jewish life is not so easy to find; that it conceals itself rather carefully from the scrutiny of the average stranger in France, and that it is only by means of the key of Jewish self-consciousness that one may discover it. But he who has this key, who approaches Parisian Jewry with the “Shalom” on his lips and the desire to share in the opportunities to live the Jewish life in Paris fully and freely, turns the lock with ease and is welcomed into the sanctum. If it were possible for me to express in bare words my gratitude for the magnificent hospitality that was extended me by representatives of all classes of Parisian Jewry, I should be writing paeans in their praise for the rest of my life. But nothing would be less convincing than this; and so I say to those who have not yet enjoyed this experience: Find out for yourselves!
Parisian Jewry, as I saw it, is composed of three very distinct classes, two of which I may be passed over cursorily in this attempt to afford a glimpse at Zionism abroad. The first of these classes, the assimilated and assimilationist Jews who form fully three quarters of the Jewish population of Paris, are, of course, not to be reckoned with at all; where these people are not thoroughly internationalist or cosmopolitan, they out-Herod Herod in the violence of their French patriotism. The Reinbachs used to be cited as the "locus classicus" for this attitude; it may, therefore, be stated that at least one of the three celebrated brothers has shown himself, in recent public utterances, to have become undeceived in his belief that total assimilation is the panacea for Jewish ills and to have measurably awakened to the value of the Zionist ideal. The second of the three classes is made up of what might be termed the "Consistoire" Jews. Members of the "Consistoire israélite de France," for the most part of Alsatian birth or origin and still clinging more or less faithfully to traditional Judaism, these people are Jews only in the synagogue (which most of them attend only on the high holidays and but a few every week), and are utterly cold to the continued existence of Israel as a nation; for them, France is the fatherland and they can conceive of no dual allegiance. The same is true of the remnant of Alsatian Jews in Paris who are rigorous in the observance of the law and the tradition; they are Jewish Frenchmen rather than French Jews.
This brings us to the consideration of the remaining class of Paris Jews. This class is made up of those Jews for whom the Russian pogroms of 1880-81 meant a new dispersion, who found refuge in the recently established, liberal-minded third Republic. Faithful to their century-old instincts, these Jews have kept together (they inhabit, for the most part, the ancient quarter of Paris known as the Marais), so that the division between them and the Alsatian Jews is sharp and unescapable. They have their own synagogues, their own communal institutions, and what is more to the point here, it is they who are the Zionists in France. So much so is this the case that it may almost be taken as axiomatic that those Jews who speak French are not Zionists, and that those who are Zionists speak Yiddish. An interesting illustration of this fact, and one that reminded me strongly of New York, Baltimore, or any other American city with a large Jewish population, was afforded by the first session of the last annual convention of the French Zionist Federation, which I was privileged to attend. Mr. Sokolow was to deliver the address of the evening, and as his
utterances were to be in a measure official, and as there were Paris journalists present, he properly began to speak in French. But he had not proceeded far before he was interrupted by vociferous cries of "Yiddish, Yiddish" from the galleries, and he was permitted to continue only after he had promised to address the second session in the "Mame Loshon."
My introduction to Zionism in Paris was of a nature to impress me. To the end of learning whether, and just how, I might be .of service to the cause during my European sojourn, I called upon Mr. Sokolow at the Hotel Meurice (where, incidentally, the King of Spain and the Shah of Persia put up whenever they visit Paris) and was received with a charming affability and treated“to a remarkable feat of memory with regard to the smallest details of the Zionist diplomat’s visit to Baltimore some five years ago that left me in no doubt as to who was responsible for the Balfour Declaration and, since then, of the San Remo decision. Moreover, at the well-appointed “displomatic headquarters” of the Zionist Organization in the rue Edouard VII, where Mr. Sokolow throned during the Peace Conference, I had the pleasure of being presented to his two “secretaries of state,” Mr. A. N. Hyamson, the able author of “Palestine: The Rebirth of an Ancient Nation,” and M. Roger 'Levy, one of the few young French Jews who boasts of being an ardent Zionist. French Zionism, properly speaking, has its headquarters in the rue de Rivoli, where meetings of one kind or another are held, where the Peuple Juif is edited, and where a delightful French Yiddish may be heard at any time of the day.
Of particular interest to us is the "Association des étudiants sionistes de France," which is a rank misnomer, in that of the twenty to forty students who attend its meetings, not one is French by birth. This organization is of a rather anæmic constitution, though two or three of its leaders, Roumanian Jews, principally, are fiery enough; the most important enterprise it undertook during my residence in Paris was the holding of four meetings, on successive Tuesdays last December, addressed by Dr. Pasmanik. of the "Comité des délégations juives," who aroused considerable comment by his advocacy of the establishment of a powerful Arabo-Jewish Semitic state.
In Belgium, where I spent the brief winter vacation, I had the good fortune to attend one of the sessions of the annual convention of the Belgium Zionist Confederation, held in Antwerp. I found the Belgian Zionists, under the leadership of M. Jan Fischer, to be well-intentioned and willing workers, though handicapped by the lack of resources. In Italy, where I met only individual Jews, I found Zionism to be an accepted, though scarcely a very vital fact. And when I saw, in the Ghetto Nuovo at Venice, a building whose keystone bore the legend: "zachar l'chourbon," I thought of the day when the memory of the destruction of the Temple shall have been eradicated by the recreation of a living, functioning Jewish state on the ancestral soil, with, who knows? the construction of a third Temple as one of its most cherished ideals.
The European Zionists claim that we in America are applying the Monroe doctrine to Zionist aflairs. Whether this is so or not, the Jews of the United States must be made to realize that in their hands lies the future of the Jewish Palestinee From them must come the inspiration, the leaders, the funds; the Jews of Europe are too engrossed in the enormous task of recovering their economic equilibrium, so sadly shaken by the war, to assist in the re-establishment of the Jewish State. Now is the time for American Jewry to demonstrate its readiness to continue the leadership it assumed at the outbreak of the European war. And it is for the Jewish student in the American colleges 10 dedicate himself whole-heartedly to the achievement of the task that so many generations of his ancestors deemed the sole end of life, the sole “raison d’etre” of the existence of the Jews as a nation amongst nations.