The Maccabaean
minology, intended, good-naturedly, no doubt, to prepare some higher ground for co-operation or good feeling.
In his Message the President, citing this letter, expressed the hope that "the Palestinian question" would not be reopened at this time, except to re-emphasize the point of universal agreement "that we stand ready to aid with all our powers in the physical reconstruction of the land that for its hallowed associations is dear to many, so that for those who wish to dwell there, it may become indeed a land of opportunity." It is "physical reconstruction" and "land of opportunity" again, this time; all suggestion of spiritual values now recedes into oblivion; we are again on the safe and solid meeting-ground of the rankly material.
The anti-Zionists prefer not to "reopen" discussion, they would rather regard the whole matter as settled their way, no matter for Balfour or San Remo. Just as the President views discussion as "unwise and unnecessary," so the rabid anti-Zionists, going beyond him, are eager to stifle debate, to avail themselves of any parliamentary technicality or majority advantage, so as to throw out minority reports, to suppress discussion. Anticipating somewhat, it was one of the most unedifying spectacles to note the unfairness and intolerance, the pettiness and the factionalism with which the anti-Zionist majority wrangled, in the vain attempt to muzzle the other side. A comical incident was furnished, when one impatient anti-Zionist proposed to shelve all debate from the start by moving the previous question; the viva voce vote indicated, correctly and reliably, a large majority in favor of choking off discussion; but when the Zionists, by asking for a roll-call, challenged their opponents to come out into the open, there was a quick scuttling to cover and only fifteen defiant spirits were found to avow, over their names, that they favored suppression of speech.
To return, however, to the President's Message, so far as it disclosed the persistent animus of rabbinical anti-Zionism. It seems never, by any chance, to dawn upon the matter-of-fact-minded that it does not become a real rabbi (or even a loyal Jew) to view the possibilities of Palestine in no other light but that of "physical reconstruction," "land of opportunity," "good land to live in," and such-like aspects of prosy, crass materialism. If rhetoricisms about "hallowed associations" have any content beyond the mere conventional flourish of pulpit parlance, why, then, Palestine has something more than simply an aggregation of soils to offer to the Jewish man with a soul; it ill becomes a rabbi (or even the mere Jewish layman with a soul above the commonplace) to speak of San Remo as "an event which must stir the imagination of all Jews"; it will do that much for any intelligent Gentile amateur of things romantic, be he without a particle of religious sentiment or of Jewish sympathy; to the rabbi such miracles must speak an entirely different language from that merely of the unexpected and the incalculable. It is the curse of our business-like and practically efficient rabbinate, one of several losses entailed by its modernity and advanced assimilation, that it forfeits the perception and the receptiveness for the deeper and finer things in religious and spiritual development, its sympathy and touch with the wider Jewish world, its appreciation for historic Jewish values and historic Jewish aspirations. When the steadfast longing of almost a score of centuries beholds its golden sunrise of incipient fulfillment these eyes, accustomed only to the hard glare of a commonplace world of practical trivialities, are
too dull to perceive the glows of spiritual beauty or, beneath them, the deeps of divine mystery. Hence a rabbinical convention which does not thank Providence for the consummation'of San Remo, which has no word of grateful acknowledgment to those who brought it about, no tear for the martyrs, certainly not a spark of contrition or self-condemnation for the unworthy röle of bickering criticaster, of railing skeptic, nay, occasionally, of reckless denunciator which it has played in the past.
It is an unpalatable task to relate, even without going into details, the methods and procedures of the Zionist debate at the Rochester convention, even though, despite deceiving appearances, the victory rested, in the main, with the Zionist minority. It is the old story of one Pyrrhic victory after another for anti-Zionism. The authorities, in both the principal seminaries, may be, more or less blatantly, anti-Zionistic; yet, by a significant coincidence, at about the same time, the Hebrew Union College Monthly publishes an article by one of this year's graduates: "How I became a Zionist at the Hebrew Union College" (in this year's graduating class of ten there are seven Zionists, two sympathizers and one anti); while, at the Theological Seminary, the students, in a published statement, tell the Jewish world, through the president of their student body, that every one of them is an affiliated Zionist and takes an active part in the work of one or the other of the Zionist organizations.
That the Reform conference is, more rapidly than might appear on the surface, drifting towards Zionism, is evident not only from the affiliations of its younger members, but from other sub-surface indications. At the Rochester Convention the younger men were deprived of the opportunity of casting their vote by the assignment of the Zionist discussion to the last hours of the closing day, when most of them had left. At the same time, even the anti-Zionist majority resolution, which was adopted by the overwhelming vote of 56 to 8, bespeaks unmistakably an advance towards the Zionist position, no matter though the resolution itself is almost as crude, inept, whimsical and immature as had been numbers of its predecessors: it is simply impossible for the anti-Zionist to avoid betraying his poverty of Jewish enthusiasm, his obtuseness to the deeper meanings of Jewish past and startling present; sterile notions and barren speculations will force themselves into the place of inescapable inferences.
But, despite all this, Jewish note and spiritual aspect are coming to the front, even in these sophisticated deliverances. To be just, there is a desire for union, for a common platform, a desire which seems to spring from a sense of fraternity and a prompting of Jewishness. The chairman of the Committee on President's Message, somehow, deluded himself into a sincere belief that he could frame a report which might satisfy both sides; yet he felt constrained to reasserve the old Chicago absurdity to which no clear-headed Zionist could ever affix his signature. In his zealous effort to meet the Zionists, he went to the length of admitting, in a way, the momentousness and the promise of San Remo; he even conceded, not quite as half-heartedly and vaguely as had been done before, that spiritual influences might be looked for from a Jewish Palestine.
Some of his followers, of course, strained at the leash; one of them, to whose illumined historic intuition the Russian revolution had meant that "the Jewish problem was solved and the bottom had dropped out of Zionism" had, with equal discrimination, pronounced the San Remo treaty