The Maccabaean
lessness. One of these is the imitation in Palestine of Europe and America. The modern houses built in Jerusalem are a failure, the sloped roofs with their red tiles a mistake. That is where the new Jewish quarters are so disappointing. In Palestine you want flat roofs or small domes. It is more suitable to local conditions. The sloped roof robs you of the best room in the house—the roof. It drives you back to the cave from which civilization is only now struggling to emerge. The Arab villages approach more the requirements of climatic conditions. They are more in line with local tradition. They are reminiscent of the style which inspired the Christians to promote the Gothic art. The cloisters are derived from what has been rediscovered during the Crusades in the East. The Spaniards stuck to that style. You have some of the finest houses in Spain. The plan for the Hebrew University, Geddes has been told, suggests an Arab village. Well, it should suggest such architecture, but with the beauty of old Jerusalem with which it seeks to be in keeping. Of course that does not present you from adopting modern conditions too. And then the great central dome, based on the hexagon, the Mogen Dovid, gives a form of construction distinctly Jewish, all previous domes being an octagon or a square. The problem is short, to evolve a style distinctly Jewish, and thus no longer Arab, but still Oriental and not Western.
THE MOST HABITABLE OF CITIES
In the same degree as Professor Geddes is reverent towards the old city and its venerable aspects, he is merciless with regard to the unsightliness of much of the new city. The walled city is the most beautiful, delightful, habitable of cities. It wants slight improvement, conservative surgery and moderate repairs to make it all that is desired. The Armenian Quarter is full of air, sunshine, light and joy of life. In the Jewish Quarter, where the squalor is obvious, the houses are often delightfully clean—“clean as a ship.” The proposal to widen the streets in the old city is totally incongruous, fortunately impracticable. Professor Geddes is not interested in demolishing or destroying anything. He scoffs at the idea of taking the people out of the old city. He believes in people, especially women, always rising to the occasion whenever there is an attempt made to clean up dirt. General Allenby's army started to clean up and the people joyfully responded. (The popular notion that the people of the “slums” are dirty, degenerate, is a cruelly false as well as ignorant impression.) There are flowers in the old city and growing of flowers is a cultural index.
TAKE AWAY THE RUBBISH
But to afford people an opportunity to realize their desires for cleanliness you must take the rubbish out of the way. Take the rubbish and dirt and fertilize the terraces on the slopes of the Mount of Olives. To burn good manure among starving olive trees is like burning bread in the presence of the hungry. Remove the enormous masses of rubbish and ruin. Lay bare the old city of David like Pompeii. It's a project for all archæologists. Use the rubbish to fertilize the new vegetable gardens farther down the valley.
Use the twenty, thirty, sometimes forty or fifty feet of rubbish all around. The water will then run down and the women won't have to carry the water from Silwan; the present Arab gardeners will be better off than before.
OVERCROWDED JERUSALEM
There is overcrowding in Jerusalem, mainly in the southern and certainly in the Jewish portion of the old city. There is housing scarcity among the poorer working classes. But there is overcrowding the world over. That gives you license to build new houses, not destroy old ones. You can develop working-class suburb districts. But in everything make for local art instead of cosmopolitan rubbish. Keep the ancient magnificence of the Jaffa Gate, but get rid of your modern squalor. (The clock tower, for example, is the most dreadful piece of architecture in existence.) The lofty Russian Tower on the Mount of Olives and that of the German Hospice (Government House) lacerate the landscape and sky line. And Professor Geddes is very sensitive about grievous injuries to the landscapes, as he is mindful of serious archæological loss. He combines a reverence for the ancient with a refreshing sense of the practical. He wants the hill east of the railway station, now occupied by a cistern and manure heap, planted as a little park, where you might have a little Hale and Farewell (Ave et Vale) Cloister for travelers of all religions arriving in a devotional mood. He wants to preserve the pools, the Birket al Sultan and other "birkets," but not for ornamental purposes only. He wants them useful as well. He wants to stock them with fish, to keep them fresh and mosquito free.
THE UNIVERSITY AND MUSEUM
Professor Geddes' main interest is, I think, the University. I understand he stayed in Jerusalem, instead of going home during the college vacation, so as to do what town planning he could during the summer and be free for the University work next year. He thinks the University will begin with certain subjects: chemistry, physical science, bacteriology and Hebrew learning. The general plan has been made, the sums appropriated for these departments were generous, even exceeding anticipations, and it was possible and desirable to make a modest beginning.
In or near the city, independent of the University, a great Palestinian Museum should arise for the collaboration of all schools of archæology, tending to supply full geographic and practical values as well.
INEXPENSIVE DUSTLESS SUBURBS
His work in Haifa and Tiberias consisted largely in going over the plans prepared for the new Jewish suburbs. He has found everywhere a tendency to multiply roads, horrid “dust deserts.” By applying his conservative surgery he has succeeded in cutting down the numbers of lanes and roads, thus adding to the future residents' comfort and decreasing their expense. He has saved something like £8,000,000 for various municipalities in India. He is determined to save proportional sums for the Palestine towns, if they let him. For Geddes is an economist as well as a town planner.