LIGHTS AND SHADOWS OF THE JEWISH WORLD
Articles and News Letters from Maccabaean Correspondents
The Turning Point
(From Our Correspondent in Palestine)
YOUR correspondent would fall short of his duty towards the readers of THE MACCABAEAN if he failed to record the fact that the turning point has been reached in the Zionist work in Palestine. Various views are taken of this crisis, or turning point, some of them extremely gloomy. Those who take the gloomy view are convinced that a crisis is impending which is threatening the whole fabric of the Yishub, endangering the success of the Palestine effort, postponing, probably for an indefinite period, the realization of the most cherished of the Jewish plans with regard to Erez Israel, undermining the credit and prestige of the Zionist Organization, involving the whole Jewish people in at least moral bankruptcy. There are others who take a less tragic view of the situation, believing that the present movement had to terminate, but that it will not be turned back, that it will at this decisive moment take a new and better course. All agree, however, that the crisis has been produced through the refusal of the American delegation at the London Jahresconferenz to assume the leadership of or responsibility for the World Organization and its work in Palestine as long as that Organization does not embrace new persons and adopt new methods for the old.
It is not your correspondent's province to discuss the stand the American delegation took. It is within his province to report briefly how that attitude affected Erez Israel. It has affected it in many ways, notably in a financial way. America's active participation meant all through the war and post-war period 80 per cent of (accountants make it out to be 69 per cent) the budget of the Zionist Organization. American aloofness means that that liberal proportion may no longer be continued.
What does it mean for Erez Israel?
The Zionist Organization has been engaged, through its agency, the Zionist Commission, first, in the task of maintaining and rehabilitating what was left in Palestine after the war and more recently it has been preparing to receive a large immigration from Eastern and Central Europe. Practically it has been feeding the present population and was preparing to feed as many newcomers as the British authorities would allow to come into the country. (It has been said that the Yishub was living from hand-to-mouth, the hand being that of the Zionist Commission.) The development of the agricultural groups, the creation of certain small and highly necessary public works, to keep at a possible minimum the number of unemployed; the assistance given to the colonists and the maintenance of a certain number of essen-
tial industries have been among the more far-sighted undertakings of the Zionist Commission. It has in addition been spending much of its money and expending a great deal of its energy in carrying on political and propaganda activities, in defending the Yishub against actual dangers, in averting possible dangers and in generally meeting emergencies. (These things were done; whether good or bad, economically or extravagantly, it is difficult to say.) A school system embracing twelve thousand Palestine Jewish children was maintained, the Hebrew language and literature advanced. But all the time it was preparing for the moment when immigration would begin. With that in view, the Commission, relying on the enthusiasm, determination and resources of the Jewish people, submitted before the Conference comprehensive schemes covering several of the useful activities involved in state building, such as drainage of swamps, irrigation, afforestation, every phase of agriculture, road building, house and barrack construction, town planning, and the extension of the educational system to include the popularizing of Hebrew among the immigrants, etc.
A number of these schemes are as yet only paper schemes; a number, such as education, agriculture, afforestation and some constructions, are in actual operation. They must go on, for as new immigrants come in (some six thousand have come in, including about two thousand pre-war residents who have been "repatriated" since the Armistice) they must be immediately absorbed in the existing operations, or new operations must be created for them.
Assuming even that not all of the Commission's plans are acceptable, the minimum provision that is to be made must be commensurate with the present commitments plus those incurred in the constant stream of immigration, the present average, before the new Immigration Ordnance, being over five hundred a month. What it will be after the publication of the ordnance depends naturally upon the provisions that are made by us.
Now it is said that the American Organization has repudiated the old budgets and refused to assume responsibility for new commitments on the ground that much of the proposed work is really the task not of the Zionist Organization, but of the Palestine Government. Even the large and costly task of education (half a million dollars a year) the American Zionists are said to have declined to assume, believing that the parents should in an ever-increasing measure defray the cost of their children's education.
The result of this reported repudiation is a most embarrassing financial situation in Palestine. Everybody knows, and talks about it, that the Zionists have no money. What the moral effect can be after the universal belief, which the