The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXIV, No. 4 · November 1920
105printed page
scan 5 of 44

The Maccabaean

narrow limits must, in this respect, and for the reasons following, be strictly observed.

D. The development which is our objective is impossible except through a manly, self-supporting population. The conditions requiring speedy settlement, taken in connection with the character and conditions of the country above set forth, prevent our securing such a population by the process of letting the settlers shift wholly for themselves, so that only the fittest would survive, and of relying upon the old common incentive of striving for a fortune to induce the requisite sacrifices. We are compelled by the present conditions of the country and political requirements to create ourselves those new conditions under which self-support can alone become possible. But in doing so we must be careful to go no step further, otherwise we shall demoralize our settlers and make success not only impossible, but also develop a population of undesirables. Our care must, therefore, be to determine in what respect aid may be given without sapping independence and preventing or destroying the prevalence of manly self-reliance on the part of the individual settlers. To me it seems that we may go so far as to provide the new conditions and facilities above outlined, but not a hair's breadth further. That is, we may supply land, water, health, afforestation, credit facilities, some dwellings, institutions for necessary research and a limited amount of education, without necessarily debilitating and demoralizing the inhabitants. We cannot attain our objective of a manly, self-supporting population unless the settlers are made to realize that they must, and unless they actually do incur, in some form, hardships equivalent to those incurred by hardy pioneers in other lands. These hardships will be of a different character, but must be equally severe if we are to succeed. The slogan must be, "No easy money in Palestine," and "No easy living" for any human being. And the Zionist official must set the example in simple living, high thinking and hard work.

E. Immigration: It is clear that the Zionist Organization, as such, should not grant any financial aid, directly or indirectly, to effect any immigration to Palestine. But it is not clear that it may not properly grant certain temporary aid to those who actually reach the country. It is, however, highly desirable that the Zionist Organization of America, in particular, should not undertake to grant such aid, unless it become absolutely necessary that it do so. It would be much better, for instance, to have any such aid granted through the Joint Distribution Committee and let the International Zionist Organization and that of America confine themselves to work for immediate constructive measures in the upbuilding of the country. In other words, if it could possibly be managed, the task of caring for the immigrant from his arrival until he is absorbed in the industrial, agricultural or commercial life of the country, had better be assumed by some other organization. This is perhaps not logical, but the dangers attendant upon the other course are very great. On the other hand, it may be advisable to undertake some definite agricultural projects, by which immigrants may be permanently absorbed. We are committed to making a success of Balfouria. Experience gained in that project and that to be gained elsewhere in other land cultivation projects may show the way to that successful industrial agriculture which should be developed by us in Palestine. It is politically and socially important that Palestine should become largely self-sufficient.

F. The Palestine Government under the High Commissioner is about to issue a Palestine National Loan of £2,500,000. It is imperative for the success of the entire work that this be promptly and widely subscribed, for American Jewry must do its share. And to this the Zionist Organization, co-operating with all others interested in the development of Palestine, must at once devote all its energies.

G. Funds: It follows from the foregoing statement of objectives that the Zionist Organization may properly undertake to raise funds for the following purposes:

(a) Investments: (1) Palestinian Government Loan; (2) Jewish Colonial Trust, Anglo-Palestine Company and a land mortgage bank.(b) Quasi Investment: (3) Zion Commonwealth; (4) stock of Hydro-Electric, Power, Light, Irrigation, and Drainage Plant; (5) dwelling projects; (6) certain agricultural undertaking.(c) Gifts for: (7) Medical Unit; (8) research in aid of Palestine, Applied Science; (9) afforestation; (10) university, libraries, museums and the like; (11) land purchase; (12) current educational needs, limited in extent, leaving a large part of the educational burden on the Palestinians.

H. Application of funds: Insofar as we undertake to solicit funds for any purpose, we must undertake to see that they are properly applied. If, and so far as may be necessary for that, we must make the application through companies, boards or officials controlled by us. But it is to be hoped that such an improvement in administration by the International Organization may soon be effected that this special action may not be necessary generally.

Those who contribute funds to any of these purposes must have the assurance that all the funds they so contribute will be applied to the purpose for which it has been specifically contributed, whether as an investment or as a gift. To this end all funds required for:

(1) Administration expenses of the World Zionist Organization in all of its activities, whether in Palestine or in the Diaspora, must be covered by the Shekolim.(2) Administration of the Zionist Organization of America and of local organizations must be raised by membership fees or specific gifts for purposes of administration and propaganda.(3) No part of the money contributed by way of investment or gift should be used in defraying the expenses incurred in raising the money unless the part so to be used shall be clearly set forth in the prospectus in advance of any collection, and there must at all times be full and frequent accounting.

I. The instrumentalities by which these special functions to be undertaken directly or indirectly through Zionist efforts should be operated, must differ according to the needs of the service undertaken. For instance, there should be a competent and devoted Board of Trustees formed, who will be responsible to the Zionist Organization of America and the Joint Distribution Committee for the work of the Medical Unit.

J. Reorganization: I purposely abstain from considering the form which the reorganized Zionist Organization of America is to take for the very obvious reason that this raises many complicated and different issues. The solution