further. But all these are empty words before the fact that our people are left without an intelligentsia and there is no one to direct its life. That is why I said that I illuminate all this differently, evaluate it by a different measure, and I can tell you quite frankly, what that measure should be. I value it as worthless—these gilded patterns on a deserter's robe, these platitudes on the theme of the narrow, the broad, and the universally human—because it is untrue. If a man leaves a small closet for a large hall, it means he has followed the line of his own advantage, and nothing more. Do not misunderstand me in a banal way, I am not talking about monetary advantage; but to follow the line of one's own advantage means to go where it is easier for a man to satisfy his appetites and demands, where the atmosphere is more refined, the environment more cultured, the resonance wider, the stage more solid, and in general everything is more magnificent and richer. It is only for this reason that they leave, and there is nothing elevated in this, for any average man prefers Rome to a village, and would even agree to be the one hundred and fifteenth man in Rome, just to walk on marble and not on a village street. Perhaps that is the point, that only average people reason this way, and that is why Bialik and Peretz are with us, while in Russian literature Mr. Tan and I don't remember who else are laboring; but this does not make it any easier for the people, if they are left with generals and have no officers, and desertion remains desertion. I am not scolding anyone for this, I am a sober-minded man and see no shame in desertion, but a simple, prudent calculation: at this post, for me, an intellectual, it is difficult and cramped, and over there it will be easier and freer for me—so I am relocating. To the free, their will. It matters little that a crowd has been left in the closet without leaders and without help—after all, no one is obliged to be a good comrade without fail. A happy journey to you. But do not dress up calculation in the rags of principle, do not refer to lofty considerations that did not and could not exist for people who abandoned us in such an unheard-of abyss and danced over to the other side, to the rich neighbor. You will not deceive us with these parables: we know well what this is about, we know that we are now culturally destitute, our hut is desolate, in our la-
104
