...wavers. What then shall we say, we who build almost our entire defense on the fact that fate has for the most part vindicated us? But I consider possible, even quite probable, another, far more terrible case. Jewry has become extremely agitated; it seems we are one of the foremost peoples in the number of the mentally ill. In that atmosphere of persecution, which the fable of ritual slaughter creates around us, there may in the end arise among us maniacs who have become obsessed with this fable. If I am not mistaken, there was such a case in Padua in the 16th century: a Jew, David Morpurgo, went insane and began to shout for the 3-year-old daughter of his Catholic neighbor to be brought to him—he would slaughter her and sprinkle her blood on the matzah. The rabbis bound him and handed him over to the authorities; fortunately, his insanity turned out to be obvious, and the matter did not end in a pogrom. But in 400 years our nerves have become badly frayed, and now it would be no miracle if a more subtle maniac were to appear, one who would not shout, but would simply take and do it. I consider it a strange piece of luck that this has not happened so far. Do not forget what a nightmare we live in, under what horror our youth is being raised. We have already seen those who have gone mad over revolution, over terror, over expropriations; in the epidemic of suicides there is an undeniable admixture of mental disorder; the recent sexual craze also brought forth a noticeable element of overt maniacs.
And so, if such a disaster breaks out, what will we say, what texts will we pull out? Will we wait for the rehabilitation of our people's name from the court and the experts: if they recognize that he is a madman, then our honor is saved; but if the maniac turns out to be a Jack the Ripper type, sober and balanced in all things except his mania, and appears healthy to the experts, then shall we, it means, consider ourselves dishonored forever? For such will be the inevitable conclusion from our own mania—to react to every reproach, to accept national responsibility for every misdeed of a Jew, to justify ourselves before anyone and everyone—including before God knows who.
15
