...turning into a solid nation of assistant sworn attorneys. . .
The devil knows what. . . you're some kind of persecutor of enlightenment. It's sickening even to listen.
- Listening to the truth is always sickening. It is bitter. And I am not in the least a persecutor of enlightenment. I can speak of the benefits of enlightenment with no fewer fervent words than you, and quite sincerely. I only ask you not to forget that what is at work here is far from just an inner thirst for knowledge, but also an external factor—and a very ugly factor. I have nothing against the thirst for knowledge. But on one condition: that it does not interfere with professional differentiation. The trouble is not that the son of a major tailor gets a higher education (may God grant more of them!), but that he will then abandon his father's workshop with its solid clientele and start running around the magistrate courts with his tongue hanging out.
In Europe, time and again, you will find people with higher education who are at the head of a furniture or shoe-making workshop inherited from their father. They probably even introduce new methods into the old business, so that their diploma benefits their craft. I have even met, in St. Petersburg, behind the counters of large shops and large workshops, the owner's son in the epaulettes of a polytechnic institute, the owner's daughter with a diploma from the Bestuzhev Courses. That is a different matter, that is wonderful. But with the Jews, it is not so. A Jew with a diploma invariably scorns commerce, not to mention his attitude toward "some" tailor's or furniture workshop, even if it were an old, solid, well-established business. He will go into commerce only out of extreme necessity, when all other avenues are closed; he will go with his head bowed, with an inner revulsion, as a person goes to something demeaning. It is easy to imagine what kind of merchant he will make. Allow me to ask: what is the reason for this contempt? Where is it written that commerce, industry, and manufacturing offer less scope for an intelligent person than the "liberal" professions? Absurd. Why, even our Odessa grain...
75
