Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion · 1862
20scan
of 43

Essay on a Settled Land

…our brothers to go up there and to dwell there, each man under his vine and under his fig tree and his olive; and our eyes shall not be lifted to the gift of flesh and blood, but sweet shall be the sleep of him who tills the holy soil, and He who dwells on high will add to him an everlasting blessing; and this is: the horn of salvation shall shine forth, selah. And the words of our Rabbis of blessed memory in Megillah 17 shall be fulfilled: "And why did they see fit to say the ingathering of the exiles after the blessing of the years? Because it is written: But you, O mountains of Israel, you shall put forth your branches and bear your fruit for my people Israel, for they are near to come." So, first of all, endeavour to bring it about that the Holy Land should give her fruit, by making her a settled land, with field labour and vineyard, and not waiting for the ingathering of the exiles, as said above, selah.

Third Essay.

Essay on the Service, Part 1.

  1. Of the three things on which the world stands, one is the Service: to offer sacrifices and to raise a sweet savour before Him; and "we will render for bullocks our lips" in the study of the order of the Service, as our master Moses son of Rabbi Maimon did for us, composing before us all the ways of the Service and all the laws that pertain to the Land of Israel when Israel dwell together in the Land.

And let us too occupy ourselves with the Holy of Holies, to go deep into the law: if we should be permitted by the governments to do on the holy mountain as our heart desires, if there should be permission at present for such a thing, to raise a sweet savour before Him, or not? And especially, according to the proofs I brought above from the Jerusalem Talmud and other places, that the beginning of the salvation will come while the nations rule over us, and by their will they permit us to build a new altar in Zion, and in the Service of the Temple with joy and gladness in His salvation: what is the ruling?

And I answered and said: Behold, at first sight there are three obstacles; but the wind shall carry them all away, as we shall clarify, with Yahweh's help, from the mouth of books and from the mouth of scribes, and as was agreed through me (after an exchange of letters which I have copied at the end of our essays on this) by two great men of the world, whose souls are at rest, on whom the whole House of Israel leans, namely my lord, my teacher and master, the great and pious Gaon, the humble, the master of all the children of the Exile, our teacher Rabbi Akiva Eger, of saintly and blessed memory, and after him his son-in-law, the great and pious Gaon, our teacher Rabbi Moses Sofer, of saintly and blessed memory. The obstacles are these: 1. that it is very hard to build a Sanctuary according to its pattern, of which He made them understand, by the hand of Yahweh upon them, the likeness of its form; 2. that we are all impure through the dead, and we have no ashes of the Heifer to purify us, and how shall we tread the sole of our foot in the dwelling of Yahweh, blessed be He; 3. to find a fit priest of attested lineage, of the seed of Aaron: who will let us know whether there was not a taint of disqualification in the presumption of his fathers? And as to all three I shall clarify that there is no obstacle in them at all.

  1. The halakhah has already been decided in the Talmud according to Rabbi Joshua, who said: I have heard that they may offer sacrifices even though there is no House, and eat most holy things even though there are no hangings, lesser holy things even though there is no wall, because the first sanctification sanctified for its time and sanctified for the time to come (Mishnah Eduyot chapter 8, and the Talmud, Shevuot 16, Megillah 14, Zevahim 107). And these are the words of Maimonides, chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House, halakhah 15: "Therefore all the sacrifices are offered even though there is no House built there, and most holy things are eaten in the whole Court even though it is in ruins and not enclosed by a partition, and lesser holy things and second tithe are eaten in Jerusalem even though there is no wall there; for the first sanctification sanctified for its time and for the time to come." Thus far his words. And our master the Kesef Mishneh wrote, in the course of his debate with Rabad, and these are his words: "Perhaps in the time of the Destruction permission will be given us to offer sacrifices." Thus far his words. And according to the opinion of Rabad, who ruled there like the one who says it was not sanctified for the time to come, and that one who enters there is not liable to excision, there is certainly no obstacle now to offering sacrifices; for if you say it was not sanctified for the time to come, then of course the high places are permitted and one may offer sacrifices in any place, as we say in Megillah 10: I have heard that they offer sacrifices