Mount Tzvi
…the Tent of Meeting, and it lacks a great act. And at first sight it appears that what Tosafot wrote (Zevahim 59), that even one who offers up outside is not liable in this time, because it is not acceptable inside without an altar, is not the view of all; for below (61a) they changed their approach, and these are their words: "And if you say: and from where do we know below that Rabbi Yohanan holds it was sanctified, because he holds one who offers up in this time liable? Indeed I might say to you that he holds it was not sanctified, and even so there is no permission after it. And one may say that if it was not sanctified he would not be liable, because it is not fit for the entrance of the Tent of Meeting, since they were entirely set aside; but if it was sanctified, it is not set aside, for he can build an altar in its place and offer upon it, etc." Thus far the words of Tosafot. And on first view one must examine why they needed this, that he can build an altar; let them derive it from this, that just above it is plain to them that what we said above, that for an altar that was uprooted one burns incense in its place, the same applies to the sacrificial portions; thus for the burning of the limbs we do not need an altar at all. But in truth this is not so, for were it not for this reasoning, that it is in his power to build an altar, it would have been set aside already; and since it was set aside before the slaughter, there is no longer any liability, neither for the slaughter nor for the offering up. And if so, it necessarily follows of itself that their intention in this reasoning, that it is in his power to build an altar, is that this reason avails so that it does not even count as "lacking time"; for otherwise they would have answered nothing, since one who slaughters what is lacking time is exempt also for the offering up, and why then does Rabbi Yohanan hold one who offers up outside liable? (And one should consider the contradiction between the words of Tosafot against each other, for above (59b) their approach is that even according to Rabbi Yehudah there is no burning when the altar is damaged, and here they state without qualification that even according to the Rabbis there is burning without an altar.) And according to what is mentioned above, one may say that although this reasoning, that it is in his power to build an altar, does not avail to make him liable on account of it also as one who slaughters outside, as Tosafot wrote above, that it follows a fortiori from one who slaughters outside before the opening of the doors of the Sanctuary, nevertheless Tosafot here hold that at any rate it is not "lacking time"; and in this they disagree with the approach of Tosafot above, and here they hold that it is entirely like one who slaughters at night, which with regard to liability for slaughtering outside counts as "not acceptable inside", and he is exempt, and nevertheless for the offering up afterwards he is liable if he offered it up outside by day, as is explained in Maimonides and Rabad, chapter 18 of the Laws of the Procedure of the Sacrifices, halakhah 17) see there. And this is because night does not count as "lacking time". And according to the words of Tosafot here, certainly the same applies to one who slaughters outside before the opening of the doors of the Sanctuary: granted that for the slaughter he is exempt, nevertheless for the burning outside he would rightly be liable as one who offers up. And when we examine closely the language of Tosafot, that they needed to add that the reason one who offers up in this time is exempt, according to the one who says it was not sanctified, is because it was entirely set aside, it seems from this at first sight that the essence of the exemption is because the sacrifice has already been set aside; and even if Elijah comes today and the Temple is speedily built, this sacrifice is set aside and will no longer be accepted; and because its disqualification is in its own body, it counts as not fit for the entrance of the Tent of Meeting, and he is exempt, as Rabbi Yohanan said above (59a): both this and that are unfit. And consequently we can say that even according to the one who says it was not sanctified, it is not a settled matter that one who offers up outside in this time is exempt, but it depends on the dispute whether living animals are set aside; and one who does not hold that living animals are set aside, even if he holds it was not sanctified, nevertheless holds one who offers up outside in this time liable. And Rabbi Yohanan follows his own approach, for he holds that living animals are set aside; so the Talmud rightly proved that he holds it was sanctified for the time to come, for otherwise he would not be liable, since it has already been entirely set aside and it is an unfit sacrifice. And according to this it necessarily follows that Resh Lakish too holds like Rabbi Yohanan, that living animals are set aside; for otherwise he should have held one who offers up outside in this time liable even according to his approach that it was not sanctified, since there is no disqualification in the body of the sacrifice, and the Temple will speedily be built, and it is fit for offering; and even if we say that one who slaughters outside in this time is exempt, by the a fortiori argument from one who slaughters before the opening of the doors of the Sanctuary, nevertheless it is not like "lacking time" according to the approach of Tosafot here, but its law is like one who slaughters at night, who is exempt for the slaughter and nevertheless liable for the offering up, except according to one who holds that living animals