Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 6.
(continued from page 5)
…him until his breast was filled with immense woe — now he learned Talmudic dialectic and bold, winged wit. He had always moved within wide horizons and looked upon nature only with al fresco eyes — now he came to know the idyll, the joy of the infinitely small. His spirit, for all its pathos, wandered restlessly to and fro and overturned itself in abrupt extremes — now he learned logic and the sure-footed dogmatic development of a subject. All this he acquired in the dark and bloody Middle Ages, and only one small thing was still wanting to him, that he might find the spiritual bond for all these precious parts as well — a land of his own, the firmly rooted soil of a homeland.
It would indeed be very easy work if one chose to trace the misery of the Jews back to material causes. But I maintain that even after the striking out of all written and unwritten paragraphs that stand in force against the Jews, the deeper Golus-misery of this stock would still not be at an end. The psychic sufferings only begin to be felt when the most crying physical want has been in some measure relieved. Every Jewish intellectual worker will understand what I mean. To him, to be sure, it would not be difficult to take a single Jewish quality as his point of departure and to develop it to the highest perfection. One may become a rigidly systematic, imposing dogmatist like Karl Marx or Spinoza. One may raise Jewish wit to the pitch of virtuosity, may become a delineator of the infinitely small, or a brooder, or an enthusiast and man of pathos. But when it comes to gathering all these qualities together in force, then there results that shrill, motley, iridescent multiplicity which throws out prodigiously many germs and brings very, very sparse blossoms to ripeness as though by accident. I have already recalled Heine, and will here bring forward only one embittered Jewish opponent of that poet, who likewise won for himself an honourable place in German belles-lettres. Berthold Auerbach strove with all his might toward the village tale, toward plain naïveté and the highest epic shaping of simple conditions. He possessed in a high degree the bent toward the idyll. But beside it there lived in him the brooding sense and the mighty religious-pedagogic imagination of Judaism, which simply did not suit the figures of his Swabian peasants and yet, like everything original in the nature of a man, struggled elementally for expression. Thus Berthold Auerbach, who abhorred precisely the dissonance in Heine's nature, could not avoid falling into a quite similar dissonance, could not create a lasting work of art, and will in no very distant time be wholly forgotten. This poet darkly divined what he lacked, and therefore strove with all his might after assimilation to German nationality. That was assuredly a perverse striving, and he ought on the contrary to have striven after a condition which would have permitted him to depict Jewish peasants instead of Swabian ones. For a settled peasant people of Jewish nationality would, after centuries of sitting upon the soil, have brought the national intellectual endowments it had brought with it into the right equilibrium with the requirements of its calling. It is very probable that the Jewish peasant would rear further within himself the brooding sense, the wit, and the pathos of his forefathers. But all this would grow together with the soil and the daily labour into a closed and naïve whole. A Berthold Auerbach of the future would not need to suppress his nature, and could accordingly, by faithful reflection, bring forth a perfect work of art. And as with art, so with life. Into the European state of the present the Jewish statesman or man of society introduces after all an alien element, which does not coincide with the innermost essence of these institutions and is felt as a disturbing dissonance. The only great statesman of Jewish descent, Lord Beaconsfield, rose to eminence, characteristically enough, among the English, whom their puritan biblical training had made to resemble the Jews. In spite of his eminent deeds he enjoyed with a very large part of the English people the most pronounced antipathy, which by no means sprang solely from his conservative party position. But the glowing, ardent imagination of this man stood in too crying a contrast with the cool English temper not to be felt at the least as disturbing. Benjamin Disraeli felt better than Berthold Auerbach what he lacked, and dreamed in his youth of a Kingdom of Judaea. For such a kingdom he would have been the right statesman, and would not have had to wait until advanced age in order to attain by very questionable ways the position of power which he absolutely needed for the unfolding of his high statesmanlike gifts. All this Professor Leon Kellner has already sufficiently shown in his essay upon Lord Beaconsfield published in these columns. In one point only is he decidedly in error. Even if Disraeli had never through early baptism acquired the capacity to become English Prime Minister, he would yet never have been the man to prepare the new Jewish State, or even to found it out of nothing. There was, to be sure, in Disraeli as in Auerbach a portion of that glowing, agitatory eloquence which flings new thoughts and ideas among the masses. But in the core of their being both were bound to practical activity, Auerbach to poetic production and Disraeli to creative statecraft. This impulse pressed imperiously toward exercise, and since these men found no material congenial to them, they were obliged to help themselves with substitutes: Auerbach with his Swabian peasants and Disraeli with the nobility of England. In the same way, to spin the matter further, Heinrich Heine reached for the folk-song that was sung upon the Rhine, since there was at that time no peasant people upon the Jordan to lend expression, in naïve and streaming songs, to his glowing eroticism, his melancholy, and his exultant joy in life.
I am at an end, and must now draw the sum in dry words. There is no Jewish national character, in so far as by character one is to understand a unified wholeness, the spiritual bond for the divergent partial moods of a being. This bond has been denied to the Jew, and this lack must bear the chief blame that the many brilliant qualities which we have named as Jewish marks have often enough degenerated into a questionable virtuosity. And when this for once did not happen, in that a single outstanding gift fought its way victoriously upward, then even to this victorious talent the legitimate development to the last and highest remained ever denied. It is a brilliant testimony to the original power of the Jewish genius that it wrested yet many a thing from foreign and brittle material. But that alters nothing in the fact that it nevertheless laid hold of the wrong material and was cheated of its highest effects — witness Heine, Auerbach, Disraeli. Yet at all events the several qualities of the Jewish national character, as we have just described them, are simply brilliant, and might, once the unifying bond has been found, unfold into a very high flowering of culture and of humanity. And this spiritual bond would be nothing else than a very bodily, tangible homeland, the Jewish State, the sovereign clod of earth.
New York Letter.
By Michael Singer.
In my last "Letter" I believe I indicated that that portion of the New York rabbis which has constituted itself into a "Board" likewise held a meeting last week, whose sole purpose was the whipping through of a resolution brought in by Dr. K. Kohler, the president of the said Board. A few private persons were also drawn into that conference, and now it is announced full-toned in the papers that the rabbis and "representative" Jews of the New York community have taken up a position against the Zionist movement.
Nowhere, however, is it said whom the gentlemen "represent," nor is anything heard of the rabbis having been authorized by their respective congregations to take up a position against our Zionism. The
