Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 13 · 27 August 1897
2printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 2. — "Die Welt." — No. 13.

For the rest, it is not at all correct that there is today no disinterested advocacy of the rights, the freedom, the welfare of others — in other words, that idealism no longer exists.

Idealism is supposed to have died out? Those who say so are either people who wish thereby to excuse their own shabby disposition, or — idealists. Idealists, to be sure, who — to their own affliction and that of others — only believe themselves still to be such, while in truth they parrot to the scientific materialists things these never said. At most they share with the most superficial among the latter the common trait that, alongside the logically ponderable causes, they neglect the imponderable ones, and alongside the coarse primary causes the fine secondary ones — that is to say, they are ultra-modern men of intellectual fashion.

They may, with their loftiest smile of wisdom, bury idealism — it lives quietly on as though nothing had happened. Not the idealism of the knights'-castle romantics and moonshine lyricists, which never lived at all, but simply the fact that men are not determined in their actions by economic grounds alone. With this fact, in the sense of which all men are idealists, though in differing directions and in unequal degree, everyone reckons who has something to carry through for which he needs men. Above all the politician. Even the dogmatic Social Democrats, sworn as they are to the very strictest economic materialism, cannot forgo the help of those who out of idealism act against their own personal and class interest.

How then should the Zionists not also be permitted to set a part of their hopes upon idealism? It would have to be, to be sure, an idealism of a higher order than that upon which the humanitarian Zionists speculate when they rely upon the charitable instinct and a vague Jewish piety; it would have to declare itself, on the Jewish side, as a national-individualist disposition, and on the side of the non-Jews as enthusiasm for Zionism, as Philozionism.

Demonstrations of sympathy for national struggles for freedom have existed in all ages. That they are still possible today has been proved by the late Turco-Greek war. If the Greeks fare not so badly at the conclusion of peace as they might have expected under the strict law of war, that is to be ascribed not solely to the slight friendship of the Powers for Turkey, but also to the philhellenic sentiment of several peoples, which reacted upon the cabinets. And what were the throngs of volunteers who fought for Greece, because they believed they were thereby fighting for an ideal, if not magnificent testimonies to political idealism?

Or should there not take place in the case of the Jews what was so abundantly done for the Hungarians, the Poles, the Greeks? Yes — that is precisely the objection of the second sort of doubters. They say: what exists for others does not exist for us; for us, the hated of all the world, the Jews, no sympathies will be found.

It must be granted that this objection is the weightiest of all. In the mouth of an opponent of Zionism it would be formulated somewhat as follows: "If you expect so much love from your Golus hosts, then they cannot be so bad as you pretend, and then you have no need at all to depart out of your Golus." But despite this seemingly crushing logic there lies here a grave fallacy. For, in the first place, sympathies for a people as such and enthusiasm for a principle as such are by no means things that must go together. And, in the second place, the ill treatment which the Jews experience at the hands of the European peoples is to be traced back to old conditions still for the present subsisting, whereas any eventual Philozionism would have first to be founded upon new premises, yet to be created. Hitherto one knows only how the peoples dealt with the ghetto Jews or the assimilation Jews; how they will bear themselves toward a new race of Jews striving after a homeland of its own, or better, how they will bear themselves toward that striving itself — upon this no conclusion can be drawn from the old experiences. The Jews, otherwise antipathetic to them, may through Zionism, and within its province, become sympathetic to them.

This is evident. But this conviction must press itself upon us still more strongly when we examine the nature of those sympathies which the peoples of Europe are wont to bring to other national strivings after freedom. Here again Philhellenism is the most characteristic. At the beginning of our century it was enthusiasm for the Hellenic ideal of culture; in its latest manifestation it is partly Christian, partly European feeling of solidarity, partly devotion to the principle of nationality.

Have we corresponding motives to offer for Philozionism?

As concerns enthusiasm for the Hellenic ideal of culture, there answers to it a conceivable enthusiasm for the Jewish ideal of culture — on the one hand as a romantic hope for a new Biblical age, on the other as a modern hope for great social achievements of the reborn Jewish people. For both forms there is a receptive public: for the first, the Anglican — and in part already the Germanic-Protestant — men of the Bible, of whom even now a goodly host fights on our side; for the second, the Europeans of pronounced social feeling. Of these, it is true, but few have as yet joined us. Yet might not the bulk of them stand aloof merely because they know nothing at all of us, or nothing precise? Because nobody goes to them and points these men to the inevitability of our cause and to the socially progressive nature of our people? But of that later!

To the Christian feeling of solidarity — which, moreover, plays today the most trifling part in Philhellenism and similar movements — we can indeed set over against no motive of equal value for Philozionism. But the European feeling of solidarity would have to stir in our favour also, and in far higher degree. For all those who are deeply penetrated by the lofty world-conquering significance of European civilisation — and these are precisely the choicest spirits, without distinction of political and social party position — will not be able to close themselves against a movement fitted to open new territory to Europeanism, and that by wholly peaceful means.

With a Philozionism proceeding from the principle of nationality it appears again to be a more difficult matter. For here a curious confusion of ideas has its voice among several nations Especially the Germans, though the nation most disposed to hostility toward the Jews, are nevertheless wont — with the exception of the avowedly anti-Semitic elements — to demand of the Jews the abandonment of their particular Jewish strivings. They are not in the least conscious of their contradiction, which is partly the consequence of their doctrinaire manner, somewhat slow in the progress of thought, and partly an inheritance from the era of emancipation and assimilation. Now does anyone seriously believe that a nation so highly gifted as the German will not at last free itself from such a remnant, and that it must not be possible to hasten this development? All the more since, from the other side, the anti-Semites, amid much confusion of thought, preach with ever greater success the indubitable difference between German and Jewish nationality?

Thus we see, then, that there may be motives enough to bring forth a lively and purposeful Philozionism. But we must also take care that we awaken these motives in the non-Jews, and especially in the leading spirits among them. That shall be one of our foremost tasks, to which