Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 17 · 24 September 1897
4printed page
scan 8 of 20
Facsimile · scan 8 of 20
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 17.

(continued from page 3)

…akin to the Turks, and would come thither to increase the population-strength of the country in place of a rapacious people, in place of the refuse of all the Occidental nations, without the slightest endangering of the security and integrity of the Empire. On the contrary, they would bring to it the co-operation of their labour, their high intelligence and their prosperity — nothing but new elements of thriving, of order, of consolidation — in order to help the Government in the establishment of internal order and above all of financial equilibrium, and to place at its disposal the capital as well as the immense credit which they command. Thereby Turkey would be freed from the oppressive tutelage and the burdensome protectorate of the European haute finance.

One sees already from this simple presentation of the state of affairs what immense advantages Turkey might draw from the execution of the Zionists' plan, and one sees at no point what Turkey should have to object to in it or to fear from it. — The endeavours of the Zionists are legitimate and honourable, and carry within themselves the pledge of devotion toward him who should take them up and support them. Will Turkey, which has hitherto been so magnanimous toward the Jews, set herself against them?

That is by no means to be assumed, and the exalted and wise Sovereign of Turkey has too lofty a mind, too much heart, too powerful an intelligence, not to esteem the motives of the Jews . . . . The Zionists have without doubt nothing to fear from that quarter in the execution of their plan; and if they find slanderers and enemies in Europe, nay even among a part of their own co-religionists — among the Turks and with His Majesty the Sultan they have no refusal and no hindrance to expect for their sacred and sacredly patriotic work, which through colonisation aims at union, quiet happiness and peace."

We should weaken the significant declaration contained in the arguments of a journal standing so near to the Turkish Government were we to add so much as a single word of commentary.

The Jews in Holland.

From Basle through Germany and Holland, back into English and Jewish life — thus did I gradually return to everyday existence and to everyday views. But it is not my personal sensations that I mean to portray; I would furnish merely a study upon the course of the Congress, in which I took a modest part. Let the German delegates tell of their native land; I shall occupy myself with Holland, whose Jewry was not officially represented at the Congress. Two Dutchmen were indeed present, but only as guests.

When one stands upon the principal bridge of Amsterdam and contemplates the sluggishly flowing Amstel, the great heavily laden canals which form the arteries of this land of timber, and the ponderous steps of the people sauntering at their ease over the narrow stone pavement; or when, if one reads Dutch, one buries oneself for a few minutes in the perusal of a Dutch journal — one will arrive at this conclusion: the Dutch are slow, pedantic, intensely materialistic and very reserved.

The most important newspaper of Holland is the "Handelsblad," which also, in accordance with its title, devotes the greatest space to commerce and finance. Dr. Max Nordau said that the assimilatory tendency leads the Jews to adaptation (mimicry): this holds true of the Dutch Jews. One no longer perceives the bloody pages of Netherlandish history in the Holland of to-day; in vain should we search for a Spinoza, or for a Menasseh ben Israel, in the present Jewry of Amsterdam, and the Jewish printing-houses have long ceased to groan under the heavy burden of the many volumes of Jewish literature.

Of what sort, then, is the Jewry of Holland? Trading, industrious, taciturn, without knowledge of any but local movements, or feigning such ignorance (a few branches of the Alliance israélite universelle excepted); — cleft into two great camps: the extreme Orthodox and the absolutely indifferent. Here, in one of the oldest free centres of Judaism, one finds no brotherliness. In neither of these parties does the virtue of moderation prevail: each sees only the mote in its opponent's eye. The result is: that there exist a small but earnest party, closed in upon itself, and a great, heterogeneous, unorganised mass of Jews to whom the mere name of Judaism appears hateful, and who openly display their contempt for religion and its ordinances.

What most strikes the stranger in Holland, especially when he comes fresh from the scene where the fraternisation in Israel was so gloriously attested, is that in this city, so significant in Israel's history, every Jewish feeling has so completely died out. The Dutch Jew seems to have grown weary of himself. He is an egoist; he has lost the idealism, the romance, the sentiments of freedom belonging to his race. His Semitic blood has stagnated through the long standstill; he has become the most phlegmatic among the Dutch. The Dutch Jew was in fact emancipated long before the law conferred upon him his legal freedom. He is the eldest among the "free" in Israel, and he had long since emancipated himself from Judaism itself. The Rabbis do not understand the situation; they are indifferent toward the masses and satisfied with the faithful attachment of the few, whose number is in course of dwindling.

One may write the same chapter upon Zionism in Holland as upon Ireland, for up to now there is no Zionist in Holland. The emancipated Dutch Jew has hitherto rejected the idea of national unity. If he is very orthodox, then he knows nothing of the work of the Congress, for the organ of the Chief Rabbi notified the protest of the German Rabbis with pleasure and joy, and that so thoroughly that in the past week it could not even find room for the smallest notice concerning the sittings of the Congress.

The ostrich in his stupidity hides his head! The irreligious average Jew knows nothing of Jewish nationalism and Zionism, but a great deal of atheism and socialism. Both parties agree up to a certain point in their narrowness of heart. In my report to the Congress upon the situation in England, I mentioned that there exists here a pronounced antagonism between the sentiments of the Russo-Polish and the Dutch Jews. The Dutch Jew despises the Russo-Polish Jew. I have spoken with men otherwise liberal in their thinking, with God-fearing people, and I have never heard a word of true sympathy, an utterance of brotherly loving-kindness, for the oppressed in the north and south-east of Europe. Here and there I caught a note of tolerance out of the remarks, and once it was even hesitatingly conceded that the Congress had undertaken a work for humanity — and even then there was no lack of ifs and buts. I will only say plainly that Zionism has not yet found its way into the ponderously functioning brain of the Dutchman! —

When, some three years ago, I attempted to interest a few Dutch Jews in the movement, I found their mental faculties so fallen asleep that they could not grasp what their English and German neighbours were undertaking.