Page 8. — "Die Welt" — No. 21.
(continued from page 7)
…great success of the Basle Congress has taught the "Choveve Zion" that their reserve was not justified, and Bentwich has felt that the time had come to set forth, in a serious and authoritative manner, the relation of English Zionism, as the "Choveve Zion" uphold it, to the Zionism of the Continent, as Herzl has created it.
Thus arose the essay in the monthly review "The Nineteenth Century," whose title, "Philo-Zionists and Anti-Semites," is certainly not the happiest of choices, just as the rendering of the beautiful name "Choveve Zion" by "Philo-Zionist" is ambiguous, misleading, and untenable. The article itself has not gained in its plan from the place in which it came to be printed. In "The Nineteenth Century" Bentwich speaks to the great English-reading public of the whole world, to Jews and Christians, to friends of the Jews and to anti-Semites, to Zionists and anti-Zionists, to the initiated and to people who have the haziest notions of the Jewish question, of the Jews, and of their hopes. Bentwich wished to do justice to this immense public — and that has not served his essay well. In order to attach the magnitude of the "Choveve Zion," unknown to the public of the "Nineteenth Century," to a known one, Bentwich took as his starting point the papers of Dr. Emil Reich, who in the same review fell foul once of the Jews in general, another time of the Zionists, but also of the Protest Rabbis. Bentwich takes upon himself the quite superfluous labour of correcting the errors of this Dr. Reich and of refuting his reproaches; only then does he come to the Basle Congress, and at last to the kernel of his essay, the oratio pro domo, the vindication of what the "Choveve Zion" strive for.
It is a great pity that the warm language, the beautiful thoughts, and the valuable facts of the essay do not come fully into their own on account of the ill-conceived plan. For we have every reason to rejoice over the article. Herbert Bentwich shows us therein that we are one with the "Choveve Zion," not only in our aims, but also in our ways and means. Bentwich has nothing to object to in Herzl's ideal, which is likewise the ideal of all Continental Zionists, save the Gestor Negotiorum Judaeorum, the seven-hour day, the "Truck System," the republic.
A selection of striking passages from the essay may serve to bear out what has been said.
"Anti-Semitism, of which in truth nothing good can otherwise be said, has nevertheless, if not created, at least drawn to the surface something good — the consciousness of our national unity, the historical community within Jewry. The heart and soul of Judah have been stirred to their depths! What slumbered in the stifling air of the Ghetto as a heroic germ, as a silent inclination, has become a storm-flood of national feeling. This feeling was not, to be sure, new to us; for, as Dr. Emil Reich very rightly says, "when others were spelling out the primer of the idea of nationality, the Jews already possessed elaborate text-books of that idea." Dr. Reich holds, indeed, that this sentiment and the endeavours bound up with it are a proof that the Jews lack patriotism in those lands where they are but guests. This assertion has been made often and as often refuted; in England at least it was finally disposed of some years ago in this very review. But the first answer to the question, "Can the Jew be a patriot?" is this: "the Jew is a patriot, and that not only in those peaceful victories in which the Jews of all lands have from of old taken the most distinguished part, as the numerous writers of the first rank, the political leaders and artists of our time bear witness, but also in wars, no matter whether he be well treated or persecuted — as the heroic deeds of the Jews during the Franco-German and the Russo-Turkish wars bear witness; and at this very moment, moreover, 125,000 Jewish soldiers are serving in the Russian army! At the Basle Congress there assembled, in the heart of Europe, for the first time since the beginning of the Diaspora, a family council of the Jews, to weigh every side of the so-called Jewish question and to discover the means of solving it. The delegates, who came at Herzl's call from New York and Baltimore in the west, and Jerusalem and Jaffa in the east, from St. Petersburg and Riga in the north, from Fiume and Constantine in the south, met one another like brothers who had long been parted, and, like their forerunners in Babylon more than two thousand years ago, they too raised their hands in solemn oath: "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem!" There it came to light, the eternal youth of Jewish feeling, which is the same in all the lands of the Diaspora.
That is Herzl's work! All objections to his original plan vanish into nothing before it. Rabbis have protested against the Congress? All the rabbis of Jewry might have pondered the Jewish question for centuries without achieving such a rebirth of the ancient ideals, such a visible advance in the striving after their realisation, as the plan of this free-thinker and journalist of the century's end has brought about.
World Chronicle.
Vienna in Africa. At Constantine, supplementary elections for the town council took place on the 9th of October. For want of other candidates the anti-Semites were victorious. After the result of the poll had been announced, a great street demonstration took place. The crowd passed howling through the town, crying: "Long live the French fatherland!" and "Down with the Jews."
Lueger Interviewed. The Burgomaster of the imperial capital of Austria, Dr. Lueger, is from time to time seized by the unconquerable craving to shout a resounding "Down with the Jews!" out into the world. For of late he has been tormented by secret pangs of soul. He is slandered behind his back, he is brought under suspicion and compromised before the masses, and, worst of all in the business, all these slanders and insults proceed from the fountain-head of every evil — from the Jews. Jews spread the rumour that Lueger's anti-Semitism is beginning to nod, nay, that it never really existed at all. Dr. Lueger an anti-Semite? Such nonsense! His anti-Semitism was only a deceptive fata morgana, meant to lure on the vast electoral caravans, the hundred thousand camels laden with economic burdens. The phantom must dissolve into nothing once the demagogue has won the golden chain of office. So the Jews whisper; but Lueger is indignant in his inmost soul, and issues his correction: It is entirely untrue that my anti-Semitism is beginning to fall asleep; the truth is rather that I shall now refuse the Jewish pupils their exemption from school fees. — It is a lie from A to Z that my anti-Semitism is beginning to cool. The truth is rather that I am withdrawing the subsidy from the Jewish orphans, &c. &c. This Paragraph 19 Lueger lately trotted out once more before the representative of a Hungarian paper in an interview. Dr. Lueger declared that he did not hate the Magyars, but only the Judaised conditions which they tolerate. The impoverishment of the Hungarian gentry, of the lesser nobility, that kernel of the Magyar nation, is in Lueger's view the work of the Jews. In Hungary, he said, one cannot buy a drop of wine, a grain of wheat, a horse, without the mediation of the Jews. When the Vienna innkeepers and wine merchants come to Hungary, they must apply to the Jews, if only because these speak German. The purchaser is then delivered into their hands. "In Hungary," said Dr. Lueger, "the Magyar tongue may perhaps prevail, but in no case the