No. 7. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
This manifested itself now in social, now in political, now in cultural form. Everywhere it was a crass Jewish distress that calls for urgent remedy. The speaker then rejects the reproach that Zionism was merely a reaction called forth by anti-Semitism. Zionism was as old as the Jewish people. New in it is only the political form in which it has presented itself to Jewry since the Basle Congress. It was an error to seek to set Zionism in opposition to German citizenship. One might very well fulfil one's duty as a citizen and yet be a faithful son of the Jewish people.
In the discussion that followed, Herr Gotthelf was the first to address the assembly. He gave himself out as a representative of the social-democratic view, against which the Social Democrats might well protest energetically, since with his chaotic utterances he achieved nothing but an involuntary success of hilarity.
The next speaker, Herr M. A. Klausner, was already taken more seriously. He begins with the confession that the aims of Zionism have in truth not yet become clear to him. God had promised the Jews to lead them back into the Promised Land, but He alone; we had therefore no right to anticipate the prophecy. The speaker emphasises that he is of course in favour of the support of the colonies, so long as they signify only a humane work of relief; political Zionism, however, and in particular the idea of state-building, he regards as a danger against which he could not warn every Jew urgently enough.
Amid stormy cries of applause Dr. Herzl now rose and began:
"Ladies and Gentlemen! I have unfortunately but a short time in which to be together with you and to contribute to the clarification of matters. It was most welcome to me to see two directions of the opposition represented in the two gentlemen who spoke before me. Herr Klausner has already once before done me the honour of attacking me. It was at a time when it was still possible for me to read all the attacks, and I hardly think that I should still have Herr Klausner's words in my memory to-day had they not been among the first that were directed against me. At the time when the "Judenstaat" appeared, Herr Klausner remarked in a criticism of it: 'if these are the ideas of a single man, then they are the ideas of a madman.' Meanwhile the single man has found comrades, and I believe that the madhouses would have to be substantially enlarged, and new ones built besides, were one to lodge them all therein. We have at least achieved something: we have brought it about that the movement has stepped out of the frame of a discussion, whereas Herr Klausner has contented himself with declaring the thing a madness. He himself admits that he does not know the essence of Zionism; this reminds me of the saying of an English parliamentarian: 'I do not know the reasons of the Government, but I disapprove of them.' Herr Klausner, who does not know the essence of Zionism, disapproves of it. I will therefore repeat the aims of Zionism in the form in which the Basle Congress adopted them. The Basle Congress formulated the programme of Zionism thus: 'We wish to create a home secured under public law for those Jews who cannot or will not assimilate.' Every word in this sentence I believe I can defend, and you will find that in doing so I do no great violence to reason. Above all, Herr Klausner held in his polemic that our brethren in Basle looked askance at the "Judenstaat" — my child, as he puts it — and disavowed it. Do not forget what this pamphlet is and was, and what the Basle Congress has become. This pamphlet was the attempt of a single man to bring some light into this Jewish question and to offer the proposal of a solution; no one is responsible for it but myself. And what was the Basle Congress? There the purposeful representatives of the Jews had already come together and had concerned themselves with setting for Zionism its nearest aims and bounds.
Upon the very delicate ground of your civic conception I may not enter, since I speak to you as a foreigner. I would only say to you that one cannot well see how the attempt to create a home for a part of the people that feels itself superfluous, how the acquisition of a territory by way of a public discussion, how this could react injuriously upon the rights of those who wish to remain. Do you not know, then, in what a colonial age we live? It is a consequence of over-population, and of the social question that thereby takes ever crasser shape, that many peoples strive to found overseas colonies in order to direct the stream of emigration thither. This is the policy that England has pursued for decades, and which serves as a model for many peoples. I believe that Germany, too, has taken its run toward becoming a Greater Germany, ever since it looks out over the seas and endeavours to found colonies everywhere.
When, for example, Galician peasants emigrate to America, I cannot see in what way it should work injuriously upon those who remain behind. A guided emigration of Jewish masses can do no harm. To be sure, we wish to prevent it, to guide the emigration into the right channels, to give it a firm goal, so that we do not lead it out into misery. Herr Klausner has nothing against our directing them anywhere in order to better their lot; only to one place does he not wish them to go, to Palestine, because he believes that they will one day come thither according to God's will. I hold that, if Herr Klausner can free himself for a moment from his prophetic imaginings, then in the territory of Palestine — and there is a Palestine, it lies on the Mediterranean Sea — places will indeed be found that are suited to settlement. And if we now hold that this land is especially suited, because we are still bound to it by an ideal tie; if we now believe that what could never hitherto come to pass can now be effected, if the situation is turned to account, if the old national ideal takes on political forms — then in that, too, there seems to me to be nothing wrong.
People have indeed attempted to found colonies in other lands, and you know the name of the benevolent man, of Baron Hirsch, who attempted a colonisation in Argentina. After the experiences in Argentina, a kind of royal tomb for Hirsch. A number of people were transplanted without being done any good, and because they lacked the tie that is necessary to bind men to the soil, this benevolent colony has been given over to ruin. Now it seems that the gentlemen would have nothing against charity-Zionism, namely against the kind that "charitably" settles Jews in Palestine. But you cannot treat a people with charity. Charity can extend only to the individual. Nowhere are there more schnorrer than among the Jews, and schnorrerdom is a great infirmity. Charity exercised upon an entire people is called politics, and the charity that a people seeks to exercise for its own prospering is the politics of that people. There is no politics that is not permeated by intentions of welfare. We do not believe that we can solve the great question by sending away the individuals, the people who cannot at all be taken in at a glance: 'Throw him out, he rends my heart!' The question is not to be solved in this way: for he whom one has had thrown out comes back, and the transplanted schnorrer is not saved; whereas if one solves the matter from the outset in the comprehensive way, then he is helped who goes, and he who stays. Whoever wishes to assimilate, let him assimilate. We only hold that the gentlemen to whom utility counsels the furtherance of Zionism ought not, through all manner of assertions, to seek to hinder the fruitful spread of this idea. And when we do that which seems to the gentlemen especially questionable, when we wish to make the colonisation not merely political, but rather from the outset endeavour to secure it under public law
