No. 41. — "Die Welt" — Page 9.
(continued from page 8)
…question would run somewhat as follows: The "Israelite Union" is, as its name declares, a Jewish society, but a society which has borne itself very coolly towards Jewry, and towards Galician Jewry in particular. It will be remembered — for it is not so very long ago — that this Viennese association, which euphemistically styles itself the "Austrian" Union, gave abundant proof of its contempt for its Galician kinsmen. Nay, even now, when the "Union" would fain play the rescuer of Galician Jewry, its inward estrangement from Jewry betrays itself very plainly in the whole manner of the convoking and the conduct of this enquête. Were the seat of the "Israelite Union" Timbuctoo or Honolulu, certain extenuating grounds might at a pinch be adduced for the "Union's" way of handling the Jewish question. But now that the "Union" lies so near at hand geographically, we cannot possibly credit it with so much naïveté and ignorance as, to judge by the questions it has framed, it would lay claim to. Some of these questions are naïve to an inadmissible degree. There are ages, seasons of life, in individuals as in communities, at which naïveté is no longer becoming. And we, we Jews above all, are of such an age, and live in such a time.
But if the "Union" is really as ignorant as it pretends, then indeed its ignorance would have to be regarded as a subjectively compelling ground for the institution of an enquête — for the instruction of the "Union." Yet one may surely ask whether, in that case, it was necessary to beat the great drum. Whether it was necessary to invite "all parties" with such emphasis, in order to have expounded to it so much that it, the "Union," does not know of Jewry — and that, as a Jewish society, it ought long since to have known. In truth, it is hard here to refrain from a satirical tone: the singular justification of the enquête convoked, the speech of the "Union's" spokesman generally, the enquête programme as drawn up, everything, everything provokes it. The right to convoke the enquête the "Union" believed it could draw — besides from the good will which it professes to possess — from a certain "negative factor," namely from its "objective" position towards all the parties of Galicia. Leaving the "good will" of the "Union" out of account for the present, this negative factor appears to us utterly insignificant, and the right drawn from it inadequate and ill-founded. How many local societies, here and elsewhere — social, political, or, for example, the veterans' associations — do not likewise stand "objectively" towards "all parties" of Galicia? But does there follow from that alone the title to take the initiative in a question of such high, such universal importance as the Jewish question is? For nothing else than a local society is the "Union," in spite of its hyperbolical name. We believe that a mere setting side by side of these two so unequal magnitudes — the Viennese "Union" and the Jewry of Galicia, the Viennese "Union" and Jewry — suffices to place in its true light the nullity of these aspirations of the "Union," and the gravity of the Jewish question as well. Let us not be misunderstood. We hail with joy every sign of sympathy, every suggestion in the cause of our people; it is open to every man to counsel and to labour in his own way. But we have the right and the duty to demand, in national affairs, a certain intellectual subordination to the sovereignty of our people. For to-day such a sovereignty exists; the "Union" knows it, it must know it. By this, however, we understand nothing else than that regard — to be exercised of free will and dictated by the national conscience — for all that is of moment to Jewry as a whole, for all that passes within the entire Jewish people. The convoking of the enquête by the "Union," therefore, the compilation of the programme, but above all the isolated manner of treating this Jewish question, with deliberate disregard of the general question and movement of Jewry, cannot be judged and condemned sharply enough. For it looks — at least the "Union" would fain create this appearance — as though the questions it puts had never before been discussed, as though they were here raised for the first time.
Has the "Union," which in its last question touches upon the possibility and the modes of an organisation of the Galician Jews, heard nothing at all of a Jewish-national organisation? Elsewhere, and here in Austria, to which, as is well known, Galicia also is to be reckoned. And nothing of the one and the other Congress of Jewry? And that there these very same questions were dealt with, economic, cultural, national, only in another order, only in a deeper connection, only from wider points of view!
As for the condition of the Jews of Galicia, their misery is assuredly not of to-day's date. If the words which Prof. Menger spoke many years ago concerning the misery of the Galician Jews have clung so well in the memory of the "Union" — and the reminiscence of its spokesman proves as much — how comes it that it resolves upon action only now, so late? Under the impression, perhaps, of the late occurrences in Galicia? Well, the brutal excesses may perhaps furnish the "Union" with a stronger argument than the other grounds which called forth our national movement. But assuredly it was also the indirect effect of the Zionist movement which literally put the questions into the "Union's" hand. It would therefore have been the "Union's" bounden duty to point, were it but in a few words, to the general national movement of Jewry. The absence of such a reference, which would have been to us a sign of a natural rapport between Jews and Jewry — this absence we regard as a grave sin of omission. We Zionists need, and also possess, much faith; but the "Union" gives us many a ground for doubt — doubt, namely, of its sincerity. If it gave us occasion for this by its silence, it gives it no less by its speech. In what the "Union's" spokesman said we light upon a sore contradiction. At the beginning of his speech he declares that the aim of the enquête is the truth, the complete truth concerning the condition of the Galician Jews and concerning the causes which have brought that condition about. Now the truth, it must be said, is a fair aim, an aim "devoutly to be wished," as the great Shakespeare says. Permit us also to become a little poetical: the speaker was so here likewise. Another poet floated before his mind, also one of the great, Homer. Or rather his, Homer's, much-sung hero Achilles; whose spear, which heals also the wounds it deals, the speaker prettily compared with the truth, which is indeed to exert a like effect. This was at the beginning of the speech. But at the end of it the speaker declared that he had still to make the communication to the assembly that, by a resolution of the "Union," the minutes would not be published. And why not? And, to speak literally with the speaker: the stenographic minutes would not be published. And why not? And upon what ground not? And what becomes of the spear of Achilles which the "Union" had proposed to wield "without fear"? To this we are answered: the healing is to proceed in secret. Or, again to speak literally: the non-publication is necessary in order that "the gentlemen may with all composure" make their depositions. We do not comprehend this delicate caution of the "Union" towards the experts, because we do not believe that there will be found among them denouncers of Jewry who would have cause to fear publicity. And neither do we comprehend the delicate forbearance towards Jewry, for which, as we likewise believe, a public course of healing will answer better than a secret one. Forbearance alone is not good. Otherwise, in the questions of the enquête, the "Union" knows right well how to combine both modes of treatment, the severe with the tender. Tender, for example, mild, liberal we call the
