"Die Welt" — No. 39 — Page 5
(continued from page 4)
…nothing but the left wing of the Catholic political economists, of Périn and Le Play, and Christian Socialists.
If, then, we have met with these doctrines founded upon huckstering neither in the Bible nor in the Talmud, shall we perhaps find them rather among the philosophers and the political economists who sprang from Israel? We shall meet with them neither in Ibn Gabirol nor in Spinoza. The Platonism of the one and the pantheism of the other had no room for an apology for huckstering. Nor is it the case with Ricardo; still less can it be a Marx or a Lassalle who teach anything of the kind. Quite the contrary! Will anyone be disposed to maintain that Colbertism, that mercantilism – in so far as they constitute economic theories – are Jewish social conceptions? Thomas Mun, Colbert, or François Melon are no Jews, and as little is Smith, in spite of his industrial system; nor Bentham either, who wrote "the Defence of Usury"; nor Turgot, who demanded entire freedom in the taking of interest upon capital. If there be a social system founded upon huckstering, it is assuredly not the system of "the German Jew Marx," as the worthy anarchist Bakunin called him — but the system of Saint-Simon, who said: "I have received the mission of wresting political power from the hands of the clergy, the nobility, and the judiciary, and of laying it in the hands of the men of industry."*)
Where, then, are we to find the trace of this "social system of the Jews which is founded upon huckstering?" Let us hear Marx. He says: "Thus not only in the Pentateuch, in the Talmud, in present-day society do we find the essence of the Jew of to-day, not as an abstract, as a most empirical essence." That is to say that the Jew, practically, within the society in whose midst he lives, exhibits a spirit founded upon huckstering, and that he has always exhibited this spirit. Stripped of all phrase-making, this means that the Jew, since his entry into the Christian world, has been fit for nothing but huckstering; and that assuredly is what we find at the bottom of all the judgments and all the theories which are directed against the Jews, or which lay claim to establishing clearness concerning the Jew in his economic relations. How could such an error ever spread abroad; how could it be taken up by men of keen and far-seeing mind? This I must yet set forth in conclusion.
Let us imagine to ourselves a historian who, in order to study a people, in order to portray its character, its philosophy, its ideal, should confine himself to submitting a single one of the classes within that people to his examination. If he takes account only of the proletarians, he will perhaps arrive at the conclusion that the social conception of this people is founded upon a disposition hostile to trade and upon labour. If, on the other hand, he extends his researches only to the bourgeois circles of finance, of industry, and of commerce, he will declare with just as much right that the social spirit of this people is founded upon huckstering. No nation will be able to escape the consequences of such a way of writing history.
Now this is precisely what has happened to the Jews. They have been regarded from the point of view of huckstering not only by the anti-Semites, but even by those Jews who set out to write their history. Upon certain points Drumont is at one with Grätz. The only thing that distinguishes them is that Grätz pleads extenuating circumstances. He too declares that the Jew carries on trade and engages in money-dealings, but only because he has been compelled to it. That is a fundamentally false assertion; in reality it is the Jewish bourgeoisie that devotes itself to huckstering and to money-dealings, and not "the Jews." The Jewish historians have in truth never written anything but the history of the Jewish bourgeoisie for the use of the Jewish bourgeois of their own day. They have not known the people, they knew nothing of it; they have avoided coming to know the people. Their history was written merely as a defence of the Jews with an eye to the Christians, a history composed for the purpose of exhibiting the ever-increasing assimilatory endeavours of the Jews — which is not correct. They were constantly held captive by the prejudice: to write no history of the Jews as a nation.
In truth, however, this history is not to be understood in any other way at all. The Jews have never ceased to be a people. If there are among them various types — that is to say, if they, as they are to-day, are not descended from a single pair — it is nevertheless none the less true that these ethnographic types, differing as they do among themselves, yet display none but their own peculiar trait of character. They have a like spiritual disposition. I speak in general terms; for if I study the English cast of mind, I shall not take as the object of my examination the children of the naturalised Englishmen living in France. (Conclusion follows.)
The Shares of the Jewish Colonial Bank.
The making out of the allotment letters (letters of allotment with acknowledgment of the deposit paid) was, as is known, brought to a close before the Third Basle Congress. This work had been delayed beyond measure by the inaccurate filling out of the subscription forms. Now the printing of the shares themselves has also been begun. The shares of the Jewish Colonial Bank are artistically appointed. Within a square of about 100 square inches there is drawn, upon a white ground, a geographically faithful map of Palestine in blue. The overprint is black. More than one half of the share is given over to the English text. The right-hand side belongs to the Hebrew translation. A narrow ornamental border frames the whole. In the four corners we find the origin of the bank and its purposes and aims set forth. In the upper left corner the Wailing Wall, with Jews at prayer before it. In the upper right the Jewish husbandman, who guides the plough and commits the seed-corn to the earth. But the bank furthers industrial undertakings as well. In the lower right a spacious factory hall. Besides agriculture and industry, commerce and traffic too are to flourish. In the lower left corner is drawn the perspective of a harbour upon the Jordan. Between the great merchantmen at anchor small barges dart through. Labourers are busied with the unloading of the wares. Over the bridge a train comes roaring.
The Philo-Semites and the True Interest of the Jews.
By Max Aram.
It is well known that beside the passionate enemies of the Jews there are also passionate friends and defenders of them, and that, as the former are called anti-Semites, so the latter are called philo-Semites. Whereas the Emperor Hadrian, who in the beginning had been no decided adversary of the Jewish movement, strove after the complete subjugation and extirpation of Israel from the time when, during his sojourn in Syria, he had penetrated more deeply into a knowledge of Jewish conditions of life and Jewish institutions, their love only grows the more passionate the closer the relations into which they enter with the Jews. Now the Jews would properly have no occasion to requite this love with any feelings save those of gratitude. Though it may otherwise now and then come to pass that God must protect a man from his friends, this can hardly be held to apply to them. But Zionism, which has after all brought up an entirely new conception of Jewry, must full often enter into a soft and gentle contradiction with those who, assuredly from the most sincere motives, represent Jewish interests. As it has more than once had to oppose the rabbis, who are certainly filled with love for Jewry, so may it fare with it in the case of the philo-Semites.
The categories of philo-Semites are exceedingly manifold. There are some who see in the weakness of the Jews perhaps a welcome opportunity of exercising the nobility of their soul, their magnanimity, and who in the act of protection may enjoy, in a more innocent sense, that which Nietzsche calls the "pathos of distance." And others again may stand in absolute need of an object for their altruistic disposition of soul. They may
*) Système industriel, pag. 167.