Die Welt · Vol. III, No. 42 · 20 October 1899
3printed page
scan 7 of 20
Facsimile · scan 7 of 20
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 42 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3.

(continued from page 2)

…is at best only a class State with somewhat more liberal principles, and it is not worth the enormous exertion which you make in order to alter the form of wage-slavery.

How few of these speakers are clear about the actual conditions. Certainly, in Galicia, in Russia as elsewhere, Jews in considerable numbers are Socialists, that is to say, they vote at the elections for the Socialist candidate and declare themselves for a better future of the working masses. But in the East as little as in the West have they in any larger number really professed the Marx-Lassallean doctrine. The best proof of this is furnished precisely by the circumstance that Zionism has remained victor everywhere where it has competed with Socialism. And that is entirely intelligible, for the masses trouble themselves little whether the doctrines of the socialisation of the means of production, of the theory of increasing misery and of catastrophe, be correct; they wish rather to attain a betterment of their material standard of living and a satisfaction of their ethical needs. Yes indeed, such a satisfaction too, however much men inveighed against "ethics" at the Hanover party congress. And with us Jews the ethical need is stronger than with anyone else whatever. And therefore, precisely through the ethical content, the national idea, has Zionism won the victory. If our fellow-tribesman Bernstein had still needed a proof that the materialistic theory of history is only in a limited degree correct — for he has in fact, if not in so many words, attacked it — he would have needed only to point to the history of the race from which he springs. One sees that it may be very useful even for a Socialist theorist to be versed in his own past and present. Certainly the Jew wishes to migrate thither because Palestine promises him a better life as well. But why does he not migrate just as gladly to Cyprus? To be sure he wishes to live under liberal administrations; but why then do the English Jew and the American become our adherents? They are surely better off in their highly civilised country than we are able to offer them within any foreseeable time in the ancestral homeland. And let it not be said that these are people who even after the success of our idea would remain in their homes. A very great part would joyfully journey home along with us, upon grounds by no means material, and would feel more at ease in the mother-land than in the father-land. Beside the material interest there runs a strong idealistic one, and that in good part helps to determine the history and the course of movements. But even if that itself were not correct — and about theories one may dispute — what in particular have our Eastern brethren to hope from Socialism? The theory of increasing misery and the prospect of an early catastrophe have got an awkward hole in them. Auer was able, amid the stormy applause of the assembly, to turn Bebel's prophecies of the "speedy collapse" into ridicule, and assuredly everyone who is no party fanatic will assume with us that neither in Eastern nor in Western Europe is the great expropriation to be expected already during the Paris World's Exhibition. Rather will it keep men waiting a very long while. Now, if that be so, the raising of the masses can be provided for only by immediate reforms. Upon that men were agreed in Hanover too. But in Russia, in Roumania, it is surely scarcely possible to carry through incisive reforms by bringing influence to bear upon the Governments. In constitutional Germany the condition of the working class improves through this, that the other parties exercise their activity with an eye to the Socialists. Because Social Democracy grows strong, social policy is pursued. Are the Jews, then, there where nothing of the sort is so much as thought of, to wait quietly for the great collapse, which will perhaps come in 4—500 years or perhaps not come at all? What are those poorest of the poor to do in expectation of the great day, who know not how upon the coming morning they shall quiet their hungering children? This hope neither warms nor satisfies, and all the theories in the world cannot help one over it.

Now men say to us: You too point to a State of the future. Certainly. But the commonwealth which we wish to create will not be created in unforeseeable ages. It can arise within a few decades.

We cherish no extravagant expectations that our goal will be realised to-morrow, but we give ourselves up to the hope that within a foreseeable time it will be a Utopia no longer. For what we desire is tangible, dependent solely upon the favour of political combinations and upon our own firm will, and is not based upon wavering and much-contested theories.

And if a Jewish commonwealth comes into being, then it will be no land of slaves for the poor and no place of exploitation for the capitalists. For that we have better sureties than all class struggles can offer us and all laws for the protection of labour can furnish. For these two thousand years we have possessed a legislation for the protection of labour which is laid down not in outward casuistry, but in fundamental, lapidary paragraphs of law. We are bound to a social policy of the largest style; we all desire it, and we need wring it from no one. The employer, indeed, may not keep back over night the wage which he owes the workman. He must, indeed, care for him as for his own child, by force of the same law which obliges the workman not to let his work slacken and not to greet the friend who wanders past, because he thereby steals his master's time. And provision is made that our doctrine shall not remain upon paper, that it shall become living and take effect. For a Zionist commonwealth can never and will never forget that it was not the rich and the great in Israel who brought it help in its despair, but the producers of material and spiritual values. But because this is so, the theory of the "class struggle" also has no ground among us.

We have never divided the people into artificially separated estates, we have never set up barriers between poor and rich, between nobility and burgher class; a nobility we have recognised only in the spiritual relation, and that nobility has hammered shoes, hewn stones and fashioned household gear. What class, then, should be fought against among us? If, therefore, the labour organisations have no significance whatever for a struggle within our own camp, and if for the East they cannot come into question upon other grounds, the state of things in Holland, England, America is nevertheless quite another. There sit broad masses which, without precisely seeing their salvation in the final goal of Socialism, can only profit by the great labour movement. The English-Jewish and American-Jewish trade unions can procure many an alleviation for their brethren who suffer under the worst methods of exploitation, can improve their standard of living and raise their legitimate self-respect. To the scientific and political education of the masses also they can but contribute. With such tendencies we are entirely in agreement; so long as no attempt is made to swear Zionism to the unproved theoretical programme of a definite political party, we not only gladly allow free play to the need for organisation of individual strata, but we rejoice in it.