Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 30
(continued from page 3)
…equality and fraternity into deed, the power of the clergy seemed broken.
Now, although all these factors met together, although they were able to exert their effects for nearly a hundred years, nothing was ever to be seen of a process of fusion between Jews and Christians, because the Christian people would never hear of a fusion. By the well-known decree of the National Assembly of the 27th September 1791 the Alsatian Jews, together with their French co-religionists, were declared French citizens.
Their position, which had before been a precarious one, was altered as though by a stroke of magic.
They were no longer exposed to the caprice of the authorities and to the excesses of the mob; they were no longer hindered in their freedom of movement; all trades stood open to them; the special laws under which they had had to suffer were abolished; their economic position improved. The Jewish religion was placed upon an equal footing with the other religious communities; the State henceforth paid the salaries of the rabbis and bore the costs of public worship.
The Jews, who felt themselves citizens of the country that had bestowed liberty and equality upon them, now held it their sacred duty to do their utmost to assimilate themselves to their new fellow-citizens and to be nothing more than Frenchmen of the Israelitish confession.
In these ideas they were further confirmed by the resolutions of the great Sanhedrin which assembled in the year 1807, and by the counsels and encouragements of well-meaning Christians.
They adopted the manners and the bearing of their Alsatian surroundings. They sought so far as possible to give up their German-Jewish Jargon. Instead of devoting themselves exclusively to trade, they began to make themselves useful in every possible branch of human industry. Very soon one saw Jewish artisans, Jewish State officials, officers, physicians, advocates and so forth. The study of the Hebrew language was greatly neglected. The foundation of religious instruction was no longer the Bible, but a catechism which imitated the form of the Christian catechisms.
Religious instruction pursued the secondary aim of thrusting the national side of Judaism as far as possible into the background.
By degrees the idea of a Jewish people, and the expression "Jewish nation," by which until 1791 Jewry was officially designated, fell into oblivion.
That for a complete merging a conversion to Christianity would be needful — for this, however, the Alsatian Jew had no understanding. The missions to the Jews have always done bad business in Alsace. In the course of the last hundred years at most 40—50 Alsatian Jews have had themselves baptised. The reason lay doubtless in this, that the ideas of the age of enlightenment were still buzzing through the air: a baptised Jew would only have made himself ridiculous with the free-thinking bourgeoisie.
The connexion with non-French Jewry was severed so far as possible. As early as 1840 Heine was able to write: "The Jews in France have been emancipated too long for the bonds of the tribe not to have been loosened." This held good for Alsace also.
A feeling of belonging together, founded upon common origin and common sufferings, existed no longer. Men did not merely abide by the answer which the Assembly of Notables that preceded the Sanhedrin had given to the Government, that "a French Jew regards himself in England as a stranger even in his relations with English Jews." They went beyond it; they regarded the foreign Jews not merely as strangers, they began to hate them or to despise them as inferior.
Men had gradually gained the conviction that they owed their emancipation to their own strength and their own merit, that the unemancipated Jews of other countries were themselves to blame for their unhappy condition; and thereupon it was believed that the foreign Jews too might one day bring it as far as the French, if they would take French Jewry for their example. These ideas are perhaps best illustrated by the fact that of all the international Jewish charitable undertakings the "Alliance" alone became popular in Alsace and in the rest of France: for it sought to help the oppressed Jews chiefly by teaching them the French language and French manners and by setting French Jewry before their eyes as it were for an example.
The assimilation movement made considerable progress in Alsace in the first half of the century — in the towns it went forward at a rapid, in the country at a slow pace.
Yet, strangely enough, one never saw the process of fusion reach its end. As late as 1866 a writer friendly to the Jews, H. Mossmann (Etude sur l'histoire des Juifs de Colmar), was able to write: "Assimilation is proceeding slowly, but surely." As to the word "surely," one may dispute after the later experiences. The movement seemed unable to get past a dead point.
Jewry, for all its wooing, met with very little response from the Christian population. The Alsatian people had from the beginning refused to hear of the emancipation: it had resisted it with all its might, and had, gnashing its teeth, accepted the fait accompli in obedience to compulsion and not to its own impulse. The emancipation it had not been able to prevent; but to every craving for assimilation it opposed a lasting, unconquerable passive resistance. Hatred and contempt did not diminish; on the contrary, the envy excited by the rising prosperity of the Jews gave them fresh nourishment.
A fusion, or rather a temporary living together, had come about only where the State was able to make its influence felt: in the school, in the administrative services, in the army. For the rest, everything had remained as of old.
As before, the name "Jew," even without any epitheton ornans, remained a term of abuse. The country people continued to address the Jews, even the most respected among them, with the familiar "thou," and refused them the address of "Herr." Only fear of the police and the military restrained the populace from laying violent hands upon the Jews. As soon as the pressure of the Government relaxed, the populace rushed like a beast that no longer heeds its tamer into the Jewish quarters, to burn and to plunder. The Jews of Dürmenach, Altkirch, Thann and so forth still think with horror of the notorious "Judenrummel" of 1848.
The law knew of no ghetto any more; following an instinctive feeling, the Jews continued to dwell in their Jewish quarters or built new ones. The law permitted them to settle anywhere; nevertheless many places, as for example Ruffach, succeeded in remaining "free of Jews."
The Jews were obliged to keep up their own social clubs; in the inns they had their Jews' side, or found their own tables reserved for them. A few rich families were indeed tolerated in Christian society; this, however, had already been the case even before the emancipation.
