Die Welt · Vol. IV, No. 38 · 21 September 1900
2printed page
scan 2 of 16
Facsimile · scan 2 of 16
Scan of p. 2
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 2. — „Die ✡ Welt“ — No. 38.

(continued from page 1)

…in their ghetto-like social segregation created gradations of their own for themselves, a thing which from the general point of view appears odd enough. They have their own social clubs for the simplest strata: dealers who travel with their wares to the annual fairs, master tinsmiths, master shoemakers, people whose daughters attend only the Jewish elementary school and not the higher girls' school. Then the greatest number of the middling, settled merchants have joined together in a social club. A smaller circle, finally, encloses something like the aristocracy of the Jewish population: the better merchants, physicians, junior barristers, advocates, and here and there an isolated Jewish gymnasium master, who, surviving from an older generation, still occurs in the East of Germany as one of the unica. These “Ressourcen” seek to maintain a tone of sociability as stilted, as genteel, as nearly courtly as may be, and can yet make upon the impartial onlooker only a painful and singular impression.

These Jews, living apart in a depressed and, as it were, self-evident subordination, the properly articulated Christian social circles would never have attempted to attack and to shake. The persecution could spring only from the blind hatred of the mob, born of a real and contemptible superstition. The officers and the higher officials stood there already too far from the Jews to have looked on at this persecution otherwise than with indifference. Only the manorial proprietors on the verge of bankruptcy, on the one hand, and on the other such ambitious subaltern officials as had, after their term of military service, obtained upon the strength of the civil-employment certificate a post with the revenue or the municipal authorities, and sent their sons to the gymnasium, may have taken pleasure in the blindly raging assault of the mob.

All the threads, then, that might lead over from the general economic, sociological or psychological aspects of the so-called “Jewish question” to this Konitz infamy are wanting. The collapse is therefore, in the outward sense, not so very grievous. It alters properly nothing anywhere, and least of all in the metropolitan centres of the German Jews, in their social position. But Heine, or Börne, says somewhere that if the emancipation of the Jews were already completely accomplished, and there remained forbidden them only the eating of onions, the sense of the onion-restriction would be just as painful and oppressive as that of the former complete exclusion. Even though the Konitz affair is to be regarded as a local hazard, it touches nevertheless every Jew, wherever he may dwell and however nearly he may have approached assimilation. The disgrace must overshadow the serenity of every Jewish heart.


Jewish Domestic Servants.*)

By Rosa Pomeranz.

„ . . We have a great duty to fulfil towards our poor sisters in the East. Hunger drives them by thousands into the neuriigsten houses of the whole world. Let these creatures be trained up for us as domestic servants. In every town of Galicia the community must found a servants' school. In the West we will place as many of them as they can train“ — so says, finely and wisely, the esteemed author of the article „Jewish Domestic Servants“.

Frankly confessed: I was astonished, and to some degree also — ashamed, that just this essay should proceed from a masculine pen. — Who knows better the significance of the question here touched upon, with all its attendant circumstances, its deep-lying causes and its painful consequences — than woman? Who is more called to reflect first and most earnestly upon the most satisfactory possible solution of this problem, so momentous for thousands of feminine existences, and to turn the results of mature deliberation to practical account — than precisely the Jewish women of the European East?

Yet no matter: the subject has been placed “under discussion” — for which sincere thanks are due to the author — and it is now the duty of the Jewish woman to approach the matter more closely. If I do so perhaps as the first, it is, I hope, not as the only one; and the opinions and counsels gathered may become the ground upon which this part-edifice of Jewish social activity in the Zionist sense shall be built up and endure to the blessing of many. With full right the author of the above-mentioned essay thinks first of all of “the poor sisters in the East”. For the West has for feminine labour a great field unknown among us: industry.

Here those forces lie fallow — not to rest for a season, but to pine slowly away amid inhuman privations and a thousand kinds of sorrow.

Here I must point to a circumstance which in its peculiarity presents a strange confusion of ideas, a perversity of ethical views such as must appear positively incomprehensible precisely among Jewish girls: in their opinion the factory hand stands higher than the servant girl. And the young Jewesses who emigrate have always the intention of becoming the former. As though the monotonous service at the lifeless machine — with the often very lively factory inspector or overseer in the background — were no service at all, or at least a pleasanter and a fitter one than service with respectable, well-meaning people and co-religionists.

But this prejudice — however strongly it still subsists at present — might yet yield to rational instruction and to better insight. The centre of gravity lies elsewhere.

„In the West we will place as many of them as they can train“ — that sounds so consoling, so full of promise, and it would bring the author uncounted tears and words of thanks if the “parties interested” could read his words.

But “they” — I mean the Jewish communities of Galicia — will found no servants' schools; in the current century they will assuredly not get so far. (This is no jest.) From that quarter nothing is to be expected. We, however, do not merely project; we desire and seek something practicable.

Now two such schools were indeed created by the late Baroness Hirsch; and if I am not mistaken there exists one also in Lemberg, founded and maintained by the Jewish Ladies' Association there.

Suppose the case that several more such institutions were created out of private exertions and private means, able to train so many girls that not only the need within the country were covered (up to now we too have here, unhappily, but few good Jewish servants), but that the surplus might find remunerative and agreeable service abroad — even that would still not be the one sufficient expedient capable of settling the Jewish servant question once for all.

People simply do not observe, or do not know, the circumstances which make it almost an impossibility for Polish or Russian Jewish girls to be placed as servants with the better families abroad.

From what class are the serving girls of the East recruited?

From the very poorest!!

For the Polish-Jewish father who can raise so much as a dowry of 200 Gulden sends his child into no stranger's house, and will not suffer that his daughter be anyone's maid. He marries her off — however unreasonably. She is then at least “in a home of her own”.

The conditions under which the poorest, or indeed the orphaned, Jewish girls of the East grow up I neither can nor will describe — it is not in place here.

The result of these simply degrading conditions is: a complete lack of any education whatever, so far as the notion of order and cleanliness, or even of manners, is concerned. Had the Baron Hirsch Foundation created girls' schools as well, much good would have arisen in that direction.

The poor Jewish parents do indeed send their daughters to school almost without exception — but of education there is no question there. They are — the poorer and the more wretched, the more perceptibly so — the pariahs of the class, the butt of the


*) Cf. the article „Jewish Domestic Servants“ by H. York-Steiner in No. 32 of the „Welt“.