Page 4 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 3
This proposition is characteristic of the war which the Marxist doctrine is wont to wage against inconvenient facts and events: the Antisemitism of the organised and unorganised proletariate is traced back to the fact that "the Jews appear as the bearers of Capitalism." The barbarous Antisemitism of the Galician proletariate, then, has its ground in this, that the 700,000 beggars of Galicia appear to the Christian population as the bearers of Capitalism. The same holds good for Roumania, Russia, etc. Even though it cannot be denied that among the Jews of Western Europe an ascending class-movement has prevailed since their emancipation, and that therefore an influential bourgeoisie arose within a comparatively short time — it is nevertheless not possible, without doing violence to logic, to trace back to this development, as the sole cause, an Antisemitism that flows from a thousand springs. In this conclusion there would be wanting the premiss that Antisemitism had already condensed itself into a social problem before the age of modern Capitalism, nay, that it runs like a red thread through the entire history of "civilised mankind." The world was not, after all, created by the Communist Manifesto, and history was historical even before Karl Marx. Zetterbaum sets forth for us in graphic fashion the grounds upon which the non-proletarian classes made use of Antisemitism: "Nobility, Church, and militarism under the spell of a view of things centuries old and in the belief that the spreading of a hostile world of thought and feeling guaranteed them their continued existence; the governments and the Christian great bourgeoisie hailed in the recruiting power of Antisemitism a dam against revolutionary development; the Christian 'intelligence' rejoiced at being able by means of Antisemitism to put out of the way the dangerous competitor, the active Jew." All that is unassailable and true; only the question as to the cause of Antisemitism is thereby not answered, but evaded. Above all it is not true that all the classes enumerated made use of a hatred of the Jews already finished and inviting employment: the truth is rather that each of these classes, so unproductive in the Marxist sense, itself produced Antisemitism, and that too without regard to the position in modern society which was created for it only by capitalist development. Further, Zetterbaum's tableau of motives contains no explanation why every class made use of Antisemitism with success, who had strewn in the soil the seed of Jew-hatred which afterwards shot up so luxuriantly into the blade! That, in our opinion, is the chief problem, which lies at the bottom of the Antisemitism of our own days as well; and every attempt at a scientifically unprejudiced solution of this problem brings us to the Zionist standpoint of race.
- Zetterbaum's second fundamental proposition runs: "The Jewish bourgeois demands the 'Jewish' State of antiquity, the bourgeois Antisemite the 'Christian' State of the Middle Ages."
Again there shows itself the endeavour to stamp as a bourgeois movement every movement that does not fit into the pack of the "Marxist-revolutionary" movement. For the same reasons for which the popular Antisemitism is excused, nay defended, by Social-Democratic parliamentarians on the score of "Jewish Capitalism," Herr Zetterbaum declares the Zionist movement to be a purely bourgeois movement. Happily the contrary is true: our masses of adherents in the East are anything but bourgeois, as little so as, for example, the victims of the Moravian anti-Jewish excesses, whom the former Social-Democratic deputy Berner stamped as exploiters. Our Zionist proletarians are, to be sure, no wage-proletarians in the Marxist sense, for they are in part unemployed and beggars, in part they enjoy a dependent "independence" — but Zionism interests itself not only in a workers' proletariate capable of organisation, but also in a beggar-proletariate not yet capable of organisation, and for that reason the proletarians are with us also in the majority.
In Herr Zetterbaum's second leading proposition there lies, besides the incorrectness already established, an untruth as well. Zionism does not strive after the Jewish "State of antiquity," but after a "publicly and legally secured home" for the host of the Jewish unemployed, which desires to develop itself, unimpaired by the Antisemitic world-boycott, into a proletariate capable of organisation. This home is not identical with the "social State" of Messrs. Zetterbaum and comrades. Zionism has never given itself out as the solution of the social question; it will be only the solution of a social question — the Jewish question — and as such a step upon the way to the self-emancipation of the Jewish proletariate.
- Leading proposition: "For the class struggle within Jewry the Zionists have no room."
This proposition illustrates the well-known fact that freedom of thought in the organisations of "the comrades" may be exercised only in the manège of the well-trodden theory of the class struggle. Persons, thoughts, and feelings are put into uniform, registered, classified — woe to everything that is not capable of Marxism! The Jewish people, now, is not yet ripe for Marxism — and that is its undoing. Herr Zetterbaum himself depicts the world-embracing Antisemitism as a means to the end of the boycott, of the shutting out of the Jew from every branch of gainful occupation. "His sources of livelihood are more and more threatened, and to his intelligence the way to State employment, to office, is barred." In the diagnosis of the Jewish disease Social Democracy was always great; only in the therapy does it leave a good deal to be desired. What does Herr Zetterbaum counsel the Jewish people, threatened in its very existence? Trade-union organisation and the class struggle! Truly, one must marvel at the degree of frivolity with which the Jewish question is handled on the part of Jewish Social Democrats! Beggars and unemployed are to be organised for the struggle against exploiters who are not there? Helots whose labour-power lies fallow and does not even pass as a "commodity" are to enter upon the "wage struggle" against employers to whom they themselves would gladly render service as strike-breakers — if it should ever come so far at all. All this only to save the honour of the class-struggle theory! When Social Democracy shall first have given the masses of the Jewish unemployed the opportunity of being exploited, then the Jewish proletariate will organise itself in trade unions also! We understand well enough the indifference of Social Democracy towards the ruin of the Jewish middle class — is it not, after all, a proof of the theory of increasing misery that has become threadbare? — but we do not understand it when Jewish Socialists would drive the drowning back with poles from the saving shore of Zionism into the flood. Is the Jewish people to wait until the social catastrophe, the great Kladderadatsch, arrives? No, Herr Zetterbaum, the Jews do not wish to fall as victims of that rigid fidelity to dogma which, in spite of the fac-
