No. 7 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
...endeavours to take into account which influenced their circumstances: liberalism, which would level and blur out and extinguish all peculiarities, and the "Abwehr" endeavours, which would deny every Jewish national consciousness. It was of uncommon importance for them how Zionism might be received by the Christians. All these fine ramifications of the soul must be recognised if one would weigh the great suggestions which Max Nordau has given in the essays printed in this journal. Nordau has set up the demand that the Jews of Zionist mind should give up their political rights among the host peoples and all aggressive endeavours after the extension of certain claims to posts of officers and of officials, and has thus led Zionism back to its most high-minded, noblest and most unfalsified form. He has therewith given a mighty and imperishable impulse, and has been overwhelmed, no less than any other man of a great initiative, with the most spiteful attacks. It may now be set forth, assuredly without too much difficulty or constraint, how that which Nordau demands might order the present circumstances of the Jews and at the same time — what is, after all, of weightier moment — further the high ideals of Zion of the whole of Jewry.
It would be, even in the present, a considerable betterment of the Jewish lot if the Jews confessed themselves to that high-minded Zionism which draws the ultimate consequences; if they gave up their political rights and laid them aside, as soldiers pile their muskets into peaceful pyramids. Perhaps it might be objected that, if the Jews and the other peoples loosed the bands of a common activity, a deadly coldness and estrangement must gain ground between them. Perhaps one might call to mind how between married people indifference already leads over into an embittered enmity. But in reality the case may stand precisely the other way. Already now we find among the non-Jews a more than friendly understanding for the sentiments of the Zionists. The Freiherr Börries v. Münchhausen, a Germanic aristocrat, allies himself with the artist Lilien, the Zionist, in a common work of art full of Jewish content; even in orthodox German parsonages, which otherwise do homage to the spirit of Stöcker, Zionist students are still gladly seen; and in the Berlin Academic Reading Hall — to the deep soul-anguish of the "Abwehr" Mittheilungen! — the Zionist representative and the German Nationals maintain sincerely friendly relations with one another. Thus we can calculate almost in mathematical formulas how greatly these friendly sentiments of the other peoples would grow if once the Jews, with a sincerity excluding every doubt, drew the ultimate consequences from their Zionist confession. Jews of national feeling might surely have the widest understanding for the national demands of the other peoples; nay, having themselves recognised the worth and the necessity of national peculiarity, they would find the separative claims of the others justified also. These tendencies of a conscious nationalism grow ever stronger, the more the peoples attain self-government through republicanism or constitutionalism. To be sure, the great masses live to-day as of old in a sweet, poetic envelopment; the national feelings enter so strongly into consciousness only with isolated abstract natures, that they govern their whole life of feeling. But these isolated ones, who yet influence the newspapers and the political agitations with peculiar strength, are also the bearers of the anti-Semitic endeavours; and if they let themselves be disarmed by the sincerity of the Zionists, then with that, in truth, not less than everything is won. The confidence which in the spring-time of liberalism had engendered such beautiful moods was bound to be lost soon and for ever beyond rescue, because the logical foundations for that intoxication of enthusiasm were wanting. Now that the peoples have once bethought themselves of the material difference between themselves and the Jews, an understanding is possible only between the consciously national, the Nationalists, and the Zionists. If it may be inborn in the human soul ever to strive into immeasurable distances and to find rest only in the tumult of infinite intimations; if the breathing and whispering of joy and confidence alone can make our hearts creative, lay the foundations of new buildings and bring up a new spring, then Zionism can already give glorious perspectives for the present.
If now, in spite of this, some honest Jews, from want either of logical power of conception or of sufficient survey, may persist in holding that the Zionists by every connivance play into the hands of the anti-Semites and injure the other Jews, it may be held up against them that it is precisely those most frantic for assimilation, who mix themselves conspicuously in the struggles of the parties, that worsen the situation of the whole of Jewry. They themselves mean it honestly enough when they say that they feel themselves only as Social Democrats or as Liberals, and they put far from them all solidarity with a united Jewry; but the solidarity exists — if indeed not in the consciousness of most Jews, yet objectively — in this, that the one must do penance for the other. If, for example, a Jewish Radical or Social Democrat seeks, more or less demagogically, to prejudice the masses against the demands of the landowners, how much embitterment against the whole of Jewry must then not gnaw at the hearts of the agrarians! If a Jew places himself at the head of striking workmen, how will he not embitter the factory-owners against the Jews as a whole! One might thus rather demand of every Jew that, in forbearance towards the other Jews, he tactfully hold himself aloof from all participation in political struggles. Heine tells somewhere how a sentimental young Berlin lady walks with her mother through the Thiergarten. When the mother again and again went into raptures over the green trees, she cries out to her: "Mother, what business are the green trees of yours!" Mother, what business are the green trees of yours!
The Jews on their side would become, through the constraint of their Zionist confession, more high-minded, more composed, more straightforward. The thousand petty, painful bickerings which arise for the Jews out of the contradiction between their inborn nationality and their craving for assimilation would fall away, and thus there would also be taken from them that oppressive nervousness into which most were thrown by the bare word "Jew". The Jews would then, even in the foreign land, have earth beneath their feet again.
Yet all the advantages for the present situation of the Jews would still be little if they did not also enclose within them a furtherance of the highest and ultimate ideals. It is to be assumed that the indifferent Jews too, if they saw in what esteem the Zionists stood with the Christians, would likewise adopt the Zionist sentiment. Mephisto is not the only one who is a part of that force which ever wills the evil and ever works the good. One might say in a paradox that they would see in the Zionist confession the most convenient and most promising assimilation. In this, however, the strict inner logic of the Zionist confession, which
