Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 11 · 15 March 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 16
Facsimile · scan 4 of 16
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4. — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 11.

(continued from page 3)

…entrepreneurs concerned. In Jewish publicist writing not even positive proposals are made for undertakings which could give the labourers immediate employment. As such a positive proposal we now regard the following.

Let us found plantation joint-stock companies! The idea is as modern as it is full of promise. The Germans undertake such plantation companies throughout in their colonies in Africa. Now it is coffee, another time cacao, a third time bitter-orange plantations. We Jews must bring the same into application for Palestine. Let us found orange, olive and almond plantations, and always with observance of the share-certificate principle. The plantations to be established can furnish work to many Jewish labourers and contribute in great measure to the agricultural raising of the country.

We conceive for a beginning a joint-stock company with 500 shares at 200 Frcs. This number of shares could be raised without difficulty among the Zionists. If needed, a second issue of shares might follow in the second business year for the enlargement of the capital stock. We hold orange plantations for the present the most suitable, since in a comparatively short time — with right cultivation and choice of place, after 7-8 years — they yield a good return. Their sale, too, is assured. Olive plantations would be very desirable, whose product already finds employment in the country as an article of food. Their return, it is true, keeps one waiting somewhat longer. With expert cultivation one may have a rich return after 10-12 years. The almond plantations could be laid out on a smaller scale, since the sale of almonds is for the present not yet quite assured. The trees bear as early as the 8th year. The initiative for the founding of the company must, however, proceed from Europe, where the capital could be raised much more easily. But persons might also be found here in the country who would take part in the undertaking with money. It is self-evident that here too care would have to be taken not to place the undertaking in unreliable hands.

As the radical remedy for the solution of the labour question we have designated colonisation. One must bear in mind that for such a colonisation quite considerable means are necessary. Not, indeed, so unattainable as certain quarters have wished to represent them. First one must gain clearness upon the question how great is the number of labourers whom one would have to colonise. On the ground of exact knowledge of the conditions we assert that one would have to reckon with certain difficulties if one wished to pick out even 100 labourers fit for colonisation. Men have frequently spoken of 400 to 500 labourers' families. In so stating the question they took from themselves the courage to solve it in a satisfactory manner within a given term. There are at the present day about 100 labourers to be colonised.

Since, after close examination of the circumstances, we hold 12.000-15.000 Francs per family necessary for the colonisation, the sum to be raised for the 100 labourers amounts to 1,200,000 to 1,500,000 Francs. We conceive thereby that a family shall receive up to 400 Dunam of land and shall be equipped with the necessary buildings, cattle, farming implements, etc. The general expenses, sometimes considerable at the beginning, have herein been thought of as well.*)


*) As is known, Herr U. Ginzberg (Achad-Haam) in his report to the Odessa Committee demands 25.000 to 30,000 Frcs. per family. We hold this figure to be very much exaggerated.

We assert further that it is not so difficult to acquire the land. Only one must proceed with deliberation.

Of the system of colonisation we will speak in a following article.

In conclusion we emphasise once more that men must proceed to a remedy at once. The question is now burning, and it will be so still more, since in a few months the opportunity for work is likely to diminish yet further. Whatever road be taken, it must be entered upon with the utmost speed. Bis agit, qui cito agit.


The General Assembly of the Russian "Chowewe Zion."*)

Odessa, 8 March 1901.

From the proceedings of the first sitting the following further particulars are to be brought out:

Engineer Ussischkin (member of the Zionist Actions Committee) declares himself against the proposal of the special committee to send a commission of experts to Palestine. Before such a commission had discharged its task, the work of colonisation would go to ruin. It is incumbent upon us to approach the Ica with the demand that it consolidate and secure the work of colonisation, and that it prevent in particular an emigration of the colonists and labourers. We have the duty to demand this, and we have also the right to it, for we are the spokesmen of the Jewish nation. But should the Ica object to us that experience has shown that colonisation in Palestine is not capable of development, then we must point to all the causes which have hitherto stood in the way of a sound development, and must demand that a definite sum be transmitted to us with which we will undertake to place the colonies upon firm foundations. The speaker is also against the founding of domestic industries for the labourers, and insists rather that land be assigned to the labourers for tillage - not great peasant estates, but modest farms which suffice just for the nourishment of their families.

Herr Temkin (member of the Zionist Actions Committee) turns in sharp words against the system of tutelage, which now comes again in the shape of the Ica in order to commit the greatest wrong: to expropriate numerous colonists, to withdraw from them the clod of ploughland. But the Ica has no right whatever to do so! It did not create the work of colonisation, that it should be permitted to ruin it. We must move the Ica to place 4,000,000 Francs at the disposal of the colonists for the setting in order of conditions; the colonists would bind themselves to redeem this loan within 60 years. The speaker is likewise against the founding of domestic industries for the labourers. The labourers beg no gifts of us; they have the moral right to demand of the friends of Palestinian colonisation that they be made rooted in the soil. We must urge this their demand emphatically upon the Ica. The speaker believes that a delegation of the "Chowewe Zion" will certainly attain its end at Paris. But should the Ica be inaccessible to all representations, then we must, cries the speaker, invoke public opinion against it. The public opinion of the whole Jewish people, to whom the colonisation of Palestine is infinitely dear, will compel the Ica to do its duty.

Dr. Soskin (Jaffa) remarks that in Galilee there are great stretches of good ploughland to be bought, upon which the Ica might settle the labourers. He emphatically disputes the assertion of Achad-Haam, according to which the costs for the settlement of a labourer's family amount to 25,000 Frcs.; 12-15.000 Frcs. suffice for this. The speaker is for the creation of industries, namely for those labourers who have employment in the colonies but are dependent upon a subsidiary earning. He adduces a few branches of industry which might come into consideration, such as the preparation of eucalyptus oil, the production of charcoal, etc.**). The speaker can confirm to the colonists that in Syria there are good markets for table wines. He points


*) Cf. "Die Welt" Nos. 9 and 10.

**) Cf. the expositions of Dr. Soskin and Doctor Joffe in this number of our paper.