Page 2 — "Die ✡ Welt" — No. 13
(continued from page 1)
...incidentally — the first purpose of the Zionist Day, the creation of an Austrian general organisation, attained.
The debate upon the condition of the Jewish labourers and colonists in Palestine shaped itself into an enthusiastic and imposing demonstration of sympathy for our suffering brethren. Here too the Zionist Day was not content to enlist the Austrian organisation alone for a great work of relief, but desires at the same time to give the impulse to a relief activity on the part of the Zionists of all countries, which in these times of most pressing distress is to proceed by collections of money, and later by the intervention of the Jewish Colonial Bank.
The discussion of the points "Agitation" and "Press" likewise brought many fresh suggestions, and led, as may be gathered from the resolutions, to decisions which will be as advantageous for the Austrian Zionists as for the movement as a whole.
To sum up, we must say: much has been done, thoroughly, worthily, and well.
The Proceedings of the First Austrian Zionist Day.
First Day.
The proceedings began at 9 o'clock in the forenoon. In the state hall, decorated with exceeding taste with Zionist flags, emblems, Hebrew mottoes and views of Palestine, there assembled about 100 delegates and many guests. The gathering made an imposing impression; it was a Congress in miniature.
As convener, Herr Wilhelm Spitzer, chairman of the "Zion" in Olmütz, bade the delegates and guests a most cordial welcome and proceeded at once to the election of the bureau. There were elected, amid tumultuous applause: as president, Dr. S. Krenberger (Vienna); as vice-presidents, Rezek (Prague) and Spitzer (Olmütz); as secretaries, Tag (Vienna), Tauber (Kolin), Hickl (Bruenn) and Dr. Wahrheit (Cracow).
Dr. Krenberger (vigorously acclaimed) set forth in his opening address how gratifying it was that at last, after long endeavours, the work of the Austrian-Zionist organisation had been taken in hand. He developed in broad outline the programme of work of the Zionist Day. "Much matter," he concluded, "a great subject is committed to your decision. May all the delegates suffer themselves to be guided solely by the considerations of work, of objectivity, and of joy in creation." (Tumultuous applause.) Thereupon Herr Tauber (Kolin) read out the incoming correspondence. A great number of telegrams of greeting and demonstrations of sympathy had arrived. From the leaders of the movement cordial letters had come in, in which the significance of the Zionist Day and the value of the organisational work were emphasised.
Herr Berthold Feiwel (Vienna) then received the floor for the address upon the programme. In a speech of nearly two hours the rapporteur set forth that a completion of the Zionist (Basle) programme, and in connection therewith an extension of the labours of organisation and agitation, must take place. The defects in the programme were at bottom to blame for most of the faults to be observed within Zionism. The speaker criticised these defects in detail, and then continued:
"The chief thesis which led me directly to the programme is this: Zionism was not interpreted completely nor circumstantially enough at the first Congress; and none of the following Congresses, not even the fourth, has wholly repaired the fault. Between the two premisses, 'the existence of an immense Jewish distress and the invincibility of anti-Semitism' on the one hand — and the conclusion, 'the creation of a home secured by public law' on the other, the intermediate link is wanting. A word was once coined by one of our leaders: 'Zionism is Judaism on the way.' The word needs only a small completion by a single little word, and at once the whole significance and range of the sentence discloses itself to us: Zionism is also Judaism on the way. That is to say: Zionism is not only the people that suffers and is oppressed, and not only the people that desires a home, but Zionism is also the people for which, on the way, while it passes out of distress into deliverance, care must be taken, and which must be prepared for its commonwealth. That is an important, nay a dispensable, intermediate link which has been wanting in the logical chain of the Congress-Zionism hitherto; and out of the absence of this intermediate link, out of the insufficient presentation of Zionism hitherto, everything can be explained — everything, without exception.
Zionism began with a positive programme which at the same time contained a negation. The Jewish question is to be solved by the establishment of a home (that was the positive part, and it was proved), because all attempts to solve it in the lands of the present sojourn would fail (that was the negative part, and it too was proved). The first thesis was the foundation of the Zionist propaganda hitherto carried on; the second, the negative one, engendered a dogmatically grounded inactivity and the phlegm of the Zionists in all questions which concerned the present fortunes of the Jews in the Golus.
In small things and in great, this inactivity in the affairs of the present made itself felt in the obstacles that were prepared for Zionism, for its advance, for its development. The disadvantages which the agitation suffered through our not concerning ourselves with the present needs of Jewry would still have been the least of the losses. Far higher is the other loss to be rated: the discouragement of many Zionist fighters who had never perceived what their proper first Zionist task should have been, and who began to doubt the possibilities of Zionism because they had begun their work at the wrong end and therefore naturally could have no success, or not the right success. But most of all the gap in the programme injured the development of Zionism itself.
Our knowledge of our human material has not been increased. As yet we do not know precisely for what labours, callings and businesses we possess the suitable material and for what we do not; as yet we do not know its intellectual and cultural level; as yet we do not know how large the proletariat of labour, of unemployment, is; in short, we lack the most primitive foundations for the policy of colonisation which constitutes our final aim. Neither do we know — and this is an indispensable precondition for the establishment of a national commonwealth — how far and in what forms assimilation has remoulded the Jews of the several countries, how far and in what degree the Jews who are to be led to community already constitute a differentiated mass. And yet the moral and material obligation of the colonisers consists first of all, and at the very least, in a knowledge of the material which they propose to employ.
. . . Can one, or may one, wish that this material should be one thrown together by mere chance? Can it further be maintained that it is a matter of indifference how this people stands physically and intellectually? There were, and perhaps still are, Zionist Fautschrechtsdogmatiker who ascribe to Zionism the necessity of a law of nature, and who therefore abandon everything to historical necessity, or — what is the same thing — to chance.
There are others, again, who take their stand upon the theory of immiseration and believe that Zionism would be realised the sooner, the worse things went with the Jews and the more distress pressed upon them. That is an economic and political short-sightedness of the most dangerous kind . . . The danger is not excluded that distress, in every sense of the word, may before the founding of the home attain such a pitch that it degenerates, with the elemental force of gases bursting their vessel, into a catastrophe whose kind and character we do not know, but of which we must know that it would signify the end of Judaism. Quite apart from the fact that — even if no catastrophe supervenes — those who are stricken, and who for their own persons have no reason to be theorists of immiseration, may easily fall away from Judaism if they are set too long before the sad dilemma: baptism or hunger.
For us, however, yet another truth comes into consideration: Zionism requires for the colonisation that is one day to come the best possible material, the physically most vigorous, the intellectually most developed, the most understanding in social-political matters . . . For this there is need of that activity which we call the "preparation of the masses" . . .