Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 14 · 3 April 1901
7printed page
scan 7 of 32

7

How Do We Combat Anti-Semitism?

By Balduin Groller.*)

. . . I well believe that it was the fact of my being a co-founder and a member of the committee of the "Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism" which moved you to invite me to give a lecture upon the theme: "How do we combat Anti-Semitism?" I should hardly have chosen it myself, because I should have feared that I could give you no satisfactory answer.

We may give ourselves up to no illusions, nor do we wish to. Here I stand as a man who was one of the founders of this society, and I speak it out, deeply moved within me: the society has not fulfilled the hopes which the world set in it, neither has it fulfilled the expectations which we ourselves, whose child of sorrow it is, attached to it.

Schopenhauer says somewhere: When a book and a head strike together and it sounds hollow, it need not always be precisely the book that is to blame. If the "Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism" has, in spite of an honest will, brought it to no achievement worth naming — and if you take into account besides the outward circumstances, then perhaps you too will arrive at the milder view that the blame does not lie exclusively with the society. I can tell you, out of an exact knowledge of the circumstances and the facts, that an extraordinary amount of good will, an intimate devotion, nay a burning zeal, has been turned upon the cause, without our having brought it to any success worth naming. And I do not know what manner of spirit would have to descend in order, under the prevailing conditions and in these surroundings, to attain anything at all . . .

But let us at once attempt to come nearer to our question: "How does one combat Anti-Semitism?" Several methods will at once present themselves to us. The thing is so simple, if one looks out upon the world with a clear eye. There are, first of all, those who before God and man are called and entitled to check anti-Semitism: the school, the parliament and the government.

For the first, then, nothing else is needed than to preach in the school, according to all the ordinances of the Christian religion as well, the love of one's neighbour, to bring the children to the consciousness that in a man they have to honour and to love only the man; and then generations would grow up who would not only find anti-Semitism unintelligible, but would abhor it downright as a vice. We should need, then, nothing else than a corporation of teachers, a school board, a municipal administration that abolishes the unnatural and installs the natural. You see, the solution is as simple as it is utopian.

If the school does not fulfil this its task, then there is the legislature, the parliament. That surely will help. It is composed, after all, of the élite of the nations. It is surely a thing of course that the people should send its best men to deliberate upon the welfare of the people and of its component parts. That surely is so tremendously simple.

Yes, my honoured hearers, I could tell you a tremendous history of suffering: how we danced attendance in the antechambers of our ministers, of our eminent deputies, to speak to their consciences, that at last the one word, the redeeming word, might be spoken. And were I to tell you further how coolly, how repellently, with what a shrug of the shoulders we were received, I believe the flush of shame would rise into your faces, as it then did into ours, that we should have condescended to petition there where we had a right to demand.

But our parliament has surely a liberal party as well? (Interruptions.) I hear some expressions of displeasure. Permit me to present myself to you as an Old Liberal. I have unlearned — perhaps I am no longer young enough for it — how to raise my voice against Liberalism, which has always counted with me as something sacred. I cannot let go of it: Liberalism is the palladium of humanity and of humaneness, it is something uncommonly high and pure. The same I should not care to assert of those who among us have set themselves up as the bearers of Liberalism. Among them all not a single one has been found who would have found the courage, who would have felt the "categorical imperative" so mightily within him that he should have stepped forth and said: What a monstrous wrong is committed day after day upon thousands of the inhabitants of this Empire. Not a single one has been found, except Kronawetter.

From Plener and the burgomasters down to the "men of the people" of to-day, not one has found it worth the trouble to stand up for an oppressed and tormented mass of the population. That was plainly not important enough for them — there was no political profit to be looked for in it.

. . . Yes, but the government! Again, properly speaking, a tremendously simple matter. A word, a mighty, a vigorous word — and, be assured, if school, teachers and municipal administration had left the Jews in the lurch, if in the parliament the man had not been found, a word from the government would have taken effect. It would have taken effect, if perhaps not out of stirrings of humanity, then out of the lackey-like quality of human nature. For the number of those who want something of the government and are therefore ready to render it little services of love is legion. And if we, that is to say the "Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism", had won these circles, that too might have been attended with success for our society. We should have been able to say: We are combating anti-Semitism.

. . . We have not found the help of the government . . .

What remains but the counsel: Jews, help yourselves! But how? Could you promise yourselves any success from the establishing of a self-help which expresses itself in stirrings of brutality? It is known that the Jewish temperament is a lively, a passionate one. Now picture to yourselves the situation if the tormented, insulted Jew were to seize upon every occasion for a self-defence which does not properly lie in his nature. For — whatever men have said and still say of the Jews — one thing they have not said of them: that they had any particular bent towards brutality. And now the Jews were in self-defence to resort even to acts of violence. There they are, in the first place, in the minority, and in the second place, in the art of brutality their opponents are far superior to the Jews. It would be a right sorry expedient . . .

But there would still be a third means for the combating of anti-Semitism. It is apparently exceedingly effective, and is propagated not by Jews only, but by Christians as well. This third way out is indicated by a signpost upon which there stands to be read: Assimilation. That too would be something. One mingles, one mixes oneself in, one dives under in the stream of the peoples. The thing has even something ideal about it: the fraternisation of the nations! . . .

Yes, if only the means were worth anything! . . . I should like to remind you of an old bad joke — and bad jokes have sometimes the property of being really not bad at all. Out of the church comes the reverend parson, dripping with sweat, and behind him, panting and groaning, the sexton. "What has happened?" the sexton was asked. "There has been a baptism," he answered; "with Herr Kohn it still went, but Herr Schlesinger was not to be got baptised through" . . . The Jews are a race by themselves, and they are not to be "got baptised through". They carry the stamp about with them through generations. Always it will be said: "The Jew by descent!" A humiliation without example has been endured, one has bowed oneself, and it has helped nothing; One is not recognised on the one side, and one is excluded on the other side. That is baptism. And assimilation without baptism? Good God, one does indeed what one can. One assimilates oneself as well as it will go. But it is of no use. It is of use at the most with those rich Jews to whom anti-Semitism has never done any hurt at all . . . They go upon the turf, they carry it through — what a distinction! — to become members of a Jockey Club. They carry it through that at least within their hearing they are not personally affronted — behind their backs it most assuredly happens.

That, then, is assimilation, the fourth means, which unhappily has likewise not been approved by the facts.

And now, honoured hearers, I do not know whether any further means might yet be theoretically excogitated. That does not signify. But in this general distress an idea has arisen which is a sound one for this reason, that it does not reckon upon the false friends and does not turn to regard the enemies, and which does enclose within itself the sound fundamental thought that the Jews have to stand upon their own feet — and that is Zionism. The


*) We reproduce here, in abstract, the highly important lecture which the well-known writer delivered before the "Fünfhaus" branch society of the "Zion".