Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 21 · 23 May 1901
5printed page
scan 5 of 16
Facsimile · scan 5 of 16
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 21 — "Die Welt" — Page 5

(continued from page 4)

…movement, in its direct as well as in its indirect consequences. Under purposeful leadership Zionism makes steady progress. Its first aim is to gather sufficient funds to obtain Palestine from the Sultan, under whose sovereignty the Zionist plan is to be carried out."

"A considerable sum has already been raised for this purpose, and every town, almost every village in the world, has its group of enthusiastic Zionists. I should like to point out that this money has in general been brought together not by rich Jews, but by the poorer Jewish classes. The rich take little interest in the cause of the people's liberation. They are for the most part people who have a sense for money-making alone and who have lost their Jewish patriotism. They stand at the top of the social ladder in the chief centres of the world. Their position is secure, they have no profit to gain from Palestine, and therefore they trouble themselves but little about the plan. That, however, does not damp the glowing enthusiasm of the Zionists in the least. The money comes from almost every spot of the earth, and in a few years a sufficient sum should be gathered to fulfil our longing. Then, after we shall have taken possession of the land, we shall not be so foolish as to throw great masses of uneducated, untrained Jews into the country; rather shall we turn Jewish shrewdness to account by sending out trained husbandmen, artisans, merchants, and men and women generally, who under the direction of practical idealists will form a firm foundation for the model community that is to come."

In the further course of the interviews Zangwill occupied himself with the newly founded giant work of a Jewish Encyclopædia, from which he hopes for a summing-up and a consolidation of the intellectual elements of Judaism.


Russian-Jewish Society for the Scientific Foundation of Zionism.

Vienna, May 21st, 1901.

In compliance with the wish of several fraternal Zionist societies and friends who, their attention having been drawn by the notice of our constitution in "Welt" No. 14, take an interest in our society, we are in the agreeable position of being able to furnish you with a detailed report in the sense of our programme ("Scientific Foundation of Zionism").

In the very first days after its constitution the society opened its activity with a lecture by Herr M. Schmidt upon "Zionism and Social Democracy," at which several guests from among the Russian-Jewish student youth of opposing convictions had also appeared.

With the most exact knowledge of his subject the lecturer set forth the fundamental principles of political Zionism, from which it followed that it is to be regarded as a necessary historical and social-economic phenomenon within Judaism.

Polemising against the Social-Democratic opponents of Zionism, the lecturer traced the cause of this opposition back to the materialistic conception of history founded by Marx, which, as is well known, confines the whole social order merely within the framework of the so-called "economic structure" and denies the co-operation of psychical factors in the development of history.

With regard to the "State of the Future," so often held up before us by the Social Democrats as in a panorama, the lecturer set forth among other things the following:

"We Zionists, who likewise strive after a State, can very well picture to ourselves the prospects of a 'State of the Future'; only we must, in the first place, oppose the sanguine advocates of the latter, who will not take into their reckoning the inevitably recurring periods of reaction and the protracted course of development of human civilisation; and secondly, we do not believe in the solution of the Jewish question said to follow upon the 'State of the Future.' For the Jews have survived the culminating points of the Egyptian, Syrian, Greek, Roman, Spanish, and now also of the general European (18th and 19th century) civilisation, and yet the Jewish question has not thereby vanished from the order of the day; the contrary is the case: the Jewish question gains ever more and more in extent and in intensity.

That we may not have to repeat the historical error and to expiate it, we Zionists desire at last to tear the Jewish people out of its abnormal position, to place it upon an equality with the other nations in national freedom and in the possibility of livelihood and of development upon national soil, and to help it to be able to fight in rank and file with all the peoples, as an equal participant, for the general civilisation.

This lecture was followed a fortnight later by a paper by stud. techn. A. Bohomolny upon the "Opponents of Zionism."

The Assimilationists as well as the Orthodox, the Jewish bourgeois as well as the Jewish Socialists, were all subjected by the lecturer to a searching criticism, and the arguments commonly brought forward by them against Zionism were most brilliantly refuted.

In reply to the reproaches of the Social Democrats on account of our alleged "separatism," Herr Bohomolny pointed to eminent political economists who see the healthy development of human society secured only through the freedom and the national-political independence of all nations.

Further, the lecturer pointed to the Polish Social Democrats, in whose programme national-political liberation occupies the foreground. "And why," concluded Herr Bohomolny, "should these rights be withheld from us Jews on the part of the Social Democrats?"

The conclusion of the Zionist-Socialist trilogy of lectures was formed by the lecture delivered a few days ago by Herr stud. med. S. Chaikis, which bore the title "State of the Future and Jewish State."

In broad outlines the lecturer depicted the historical development of Socialism and of Zionism, the present position of both movements, and raised the question whether it were possible to discover points of contact between the two — which question he answers in the affirmative.

In support of this the lecturer showed that the points of contact sought for do in fact exist, namely: in the historical necessity of both ideas, in the present activity of their adherents, and even in their ultimate aims.

With the aid of Jewish history the lecturer showed that political Zionism is no theory sprung from the studies of the learned, but rather a new formula for the longing after Zion that has ever dwelt within the Jewish people, and that the attempts to solve the Jewish question in another manner have always failed.

Further, the lecturer pointed out that the cultural-economic activity of the Social Democrats coincides completely with that of the Zionists.

"And in the same way," concluded the lecturer, "the points of contact between the Zionists and the Social Democrats are to be found in the ultimate aims as well, since both strive after the founding of a new State upon modern foundations."

Upon all the papers, which several Social Democrats also attended, there followed very lively and downright passionate debates, conducted on both sides with earnestness and with scientific spirit, which contributed much to the elucidation of the themes and to the clear statement of our standpoint.

In conclusion we note that we have marked out for the future a cycle of new papers upon Zionism and its currents, as well as upon the institutions and currents within Judaism. For the first paper of this series Herr M. Schmidt has announced himself for next Saturday with a lecture bearing the title "A Criticism of the Currents in Zionism."

Upon this occasion we request that all communications be addressed to: M. Schmidt, IX., Eisengasse 5, care of Joh. Kremenezky.