No. 34 — "Die ✡ Welt" — Page 3
(continued from page 2)
…but only about their own future and that of their children. They strove only to gain a firm hold in the land, which cannot be attained through dependent labour and through subventions. Only when the colonies passed into the administration of the "Ica," and this made known its will to do nothing for the labourers, did the labourers begin to emigrate, because every hope had vanished for them of creating in the land a settled existence for themselves and their children.
The esteemed writer of the article relates further: "In this matter the deputation now reports to us that it has received promises whereby work will be procured for the labourers." So once more work upon the ground of philanthropy! Besides this, however, we should like to ask the esteemed writer of the article how it comes about that he tells with such assurance of victory of the promises mentioned, while the deputation itself by no means awakens any delusive hopes and has come to the perception that, in spite of the many promises, there will be neither work nor settlement? These promises were made earlier already, without the intercession of the deputation, and have now only been repeated, because it was hoped that they would quiet individual members of the delegation.
The esteemed writer of the article also brings the gratifying news that the estate of Kefar Saba has been acquired and that Jewish agricultural labourers have been sent thither. But does the esteemed writer of the article know that the work upon this newly acquired estate lasted only one month; that the number of Jewish labourers who were taken on is far smaller than the number of Arab labourers, namely 18 Jews against 40 Arabs; and that even this small number was taken on only unwillingly, "out of mercy"?
We do not indeed deny that Baron Rothschild is one of those who promise little and keep much, and we well believe that he will make the soil of Charan a gift to the labourers, as he has promised, after all the concessions shall have been granted. Only, the deputation, which was present at the giving of the promise, nevertheless does not speak of it as of a settled matter, whereas the esteemed writer of the article so presents the affair as though the labourers might take possession of the soil even now and lacked nothing but a "dowry of 10,000 francs per family." He now raises the question: "Why do the labourers regard an extensive estate as a quite worthless thing, if they do not get a 'dowry of 10,000 francs' along with it?" He adduces many proofs that one can settle with far smaller sums as well, in order at last to conclude thus: "When the basis for a settlement is given, as in this case, the organisation of the labourers ought to show that they are as fit for colonisation as the country-folk of all other peoples." The writer of the article is entirely in the right. We admit without more ado that the organisation of the labourers must prove its power of adaptation to the most unfavourable conditions. We can tell him still more: there exists among us already a kind of plan of settlement, the realisation of which requires no "dowry of 10,000 Frcs.," nor one of 5000 Frcs. either. But the matter has this hitch, that the deputation has in fact effected nothing and has not procured the basis for the settlement of the labourers. For, as Mr. Meiersohn declared, the soil of Charan will be fit for settlement only after a period of several years, and who knows what will have happened by then. Why, then, does the esteemed writer of the article awaken false notions in his readers? Let him but once make the attempt to obtain from the "Ica" the allotment of some estate for a part of the labourers, which can be settled at once. We would in that case pledge ourselves to show that we can accomplish great things without support, provided that we were wholly independent, without any tutelage, in our actions.
Wadi-Chanin, 8 Ab 5661.
(Signatures follow.)
Eastern Jewry in the Light of a Berlin "Israelite."
In No. 31 of the Hebrew weekly "Hador," published by the firm "Achiasaf" in Warsaw, Dr. S. Bernfeld relates very interesting particulars of a conversation which he had a short time ago with an eminent Berlin Jewish scholar, who also holds a leading part in communal life. The conversation, which at the outset turned upon quite indifferent things, took of a sudden a turn in the direction of Jewish questions of the time and of the day.
Dr. Bernfeld remarked that western Jewry was in an unarrestable decline and must in time dissolve altogether, unless extraordinary events should call a halt to the process of decomposition. He pointed out further that in those lands whose Jewish population receives, from whatever causes, a steady influx from the East, Jewry is still tolerably firm of foot, whereas in the remaining lands of the West it is to all appearance dwindling away. One need only look at Italy, which a generation before our own still harboured a lively Jewish life (it is enough to call to mind the names Luzzatto, Reggio, Almanzi and so forth), but which to-day shows, in respect of Jewry, a desolate emptiness. The future of Jewry rests therefore solely and alone in the lands of the East.
Thereupon the said scholar, out of the leading German-Israelite circles, replied:
"My youth fell in a time of peace and of toleration, in the end of the sixties and the beginning of the seventies. I do not know how the great Jewish multitude then thought and felt, but the currents of mind within the educated I can describe to you very exactly. Jewry was to us an ethical and a historical conception. The greater part of its religious usages had already become strange to our spirit. But in renouncing these we did not become unfaithful to Jewry, whose historical and ethical kernel we rather held high. If it is now believed that in this way Jewry was bound to go back, that is an error. The multitude still held fast to the religion of the fathers, and we educated men loved the Jewish memories. And since on that account we had by no means to suffer or to endure any disgrace, we remained Jews. The knowledge of Jewry did indeed decrease more and more, but that lay in the circumstances of the time; for even now, when the hostilities have chained us more firmly to Jewry, we still cannot perceive that the knowledge of it is spreading among us. That depends, as has been said, upon divers circumstances, upon which historical development alone can work, and not any one of us. There may be found among us to-day, when we are anxious for our future, open-handed people who give large sums of money for literary undertakings that concern Jewry. But do you really believe that Jewry will be preserved in this artificial fashion? The movement must proceed from the lower strata; they must hold fast to Jewry, and not first receive the impulse from us. For the rest: however the matter may stand, there is for the present no fear that Jewry will wholly perish. An absorption in honour might still find us ready, but a forced fusion never and at no time. Worm-eaten fruits fall off in any case, yet the tree does not on that account cease to bear fruit, and were it only, as you say, because the influence of the eastern Jews hinders Jewry in the West from going wholly under. If Jewry in Italy and the Scan-
