Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 47 · 22 November 1901
6printed page
scan 6 of 16
Facsimile · scan 6 of 16
Scan of p. 6
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 47.

(continued from page 5)

…too holy for anyone to make a game of it. Above all, they have rejected our demand for a candidate, with the stupid reasons of the huckstering politician. We wanted a candidate, not in order to make a parade of it, but in order to give the Conservative party a Jewish conscience, to offer it a lasting reminder of its public responsibility. They have thrust our hand from them. We shall shed no tear for it. We are young, fresh and glad in our work, and — have nothing to lose either.

So, then, we mean to go into the fight alone. And even if we should not carry the day, conquer we assuredly shall. For it will be a victory to have torn the fool's cap from the crown of the masqueraders, to have thrust the poltroons and the soft-treaders behind the stove, where they belong. And it will be a victory to steel our strength and to train our address in this struggle that is still new to us. Our device, however, shall be: Not for Conservatives and not for Liberals, but for living Judaism.

Eli Samgar.


Zionism in the London Maccabaean Club.

As we reported in our last number, the discussion upon Zionism opened by Dr. M. Bernstein in the London Maccabaean Club was, on the motion of Mr. Herbert Bentwich, adjourned to the 10th inst.

The continuation of the discussion accordingly took place on the appointed day under the chairmanship of Mr. Felix A. Davis. Among those present were: Colonel Goldsmid, Mr. Solomon A. R. A., Rev. M. Adler, Rev. J. Harris, Mr. Herbert Bentwich, Mr. Herman J. Cohen, Mr. L. J. Greenberg, H. S. Q. Henriques and Mr. J. Zangwill.

Mr. Herbert Bentwich recapitulated Dr. Bernstein's argument and remarked upon his conclusion ("The position of the Jewish community in England is endangered by the persecutions of the Jews in Russia and Roumania") that Dr. Bernstein had considered Zionism not from a religious or a national point of view, but from that of mere necessity. The Jewish community, however, was threatened not only by the immigration to which the Eastern Jews are driven, but also by the corruption of the Jewish character, which the persecutions bring about even when the oppressed Jews do not leave their homes. If the Jewish distress is a cancerous growth, then it must be removed, if the whole body of the people is not to be involved in the suffering. To-day Zionism is opposed on account of its national aspirations. But even before the national element in the Zionist movement had been emphasised, opposition was made to it. This, then, cannot be the only objection. So much the sadder and the more shameful for the anti-Zionists. In the question of founding a home for the persecuted Jews there is no collision between the duties of the Englishman and those of the Jew. It is an exclusively Jewish question, with which the English nation has nothing to do. It is impossible to create a remedy for the Jewish distress in Russia itself. This is also the view of the "Anglo Jewish Association", as it finds expression in its latest report upon the condition of the Jews in Russia and Roumania. There is therefore no other means of rescue than Zionism.

Mr. Ernst Lesser, who avows himself an "Englishman", admits that the position of the Jews in England is endangered by the persecutions of the Jews in Russia and Roumania. The English Jews, however, did not take a heathen (!) standpoint in judging this question. The average Englishman is free from sentimentality in his consideration of the immigration question, and asks himself merely whether the immigrant Jews have become good citizens and have rendered corresponding services in return for the advantages that have been offered them. The foreigner lacks the qualities which are most admired in the Englishman, and exhibits instead qualities which are most abhorred. It is hard to determine where anti-Semitism begins and hatred of the foreigner leaves off.*) If things continue to develop thus, the issue will be very sad.

Mr. Israel Zangwill set forth that he had always been of the opinion that the immigration of the Russian and Roumanian Jews into England was a danger for the Jews of this country. We have always been told that England is free, noble and high-minded. But when we study history we find that it has at all times been only a minority that was high-minded. The speaker had once said to a Jewish clergyman that the persecutions and the immigration of the Jews were the strongest argument for Zionism. Whereupon his interlocutor had replied that this was the most ignoble motive he had ever heard. Mr. Zangwill had rejoined that he adapted his arguments to his hearers of the moment. (Laughter.) The speaker's friend, Mr. Solomon J. Solomon, had raised against Zionism the objection that the English Jews, in the event of a Jewish polity being founded, would forfeit their nationality. Like his namesake, King Solomon, he wished to make a sharp division — between nationality and colonisation. But if one were to cut the Zionist child in two after that fashion, one would kill it. (Applause.) It is not enough to prepare a place in Palestine for the Jews where they would be persecuted further.

Mr. L. J. Greenberg finds it astonishing that in the debate no mention has been made of last year's London Zionist Congress, at which Dr. Mandelstamm dealt in detail with the condition of the Jews in Russia and Roumania and came to the conclusion that things are developing ever worse. The English Jews ought to speak somewhat more cautiously of the Jewish immigrants. The Jews who immigrated into England a hundred years ago now count among the so-called aristocracy of English Jewry.

Colonel Goldsmid avows himself a Zionist, but not altogether in the sense of the present party. The first duty of the Jews is to implant in their children the best qualities of the peoples in whose midst they live. The Jewish distress has at present reached such a summit that some place of refuge must be sought. But the soul of Zionism is faith. Faith alone it is that has upheld the Boers so long in their struggle.

Mr. Herman Cohen deplores the great ignorance of the members of the Maccabaean Club. He himself, for example, had never heard anything of Dr. Mandelstamm. If Zionism desires a rational colonisation, he joins himself to it.

Finally, on the motion of Mr. Henriques, which Mr. Zangwill supported, thanks were voted to the lecturer, Dr. Bernstein, and to the president.

The course and the results of the discussion are a notable success for the Zionist cause.


*) One sees that our assimilationist gentlemen are as like one another in every country as one egg is to another. (Note of the Editors.)