Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 50 · 13 December 1901
16printed page
scan 32 of 52
Facsimile · scan 32 of 52
Scan of p. 16
English · AI translation, checked against the German
  • 16 -

(continued from page 15)

…up. In the smaller circles, with their closer family cohesion, older forms of speech and old words pass over from the parents to the children, the more so in proportion as the splinter of a people in question is literarily cultivated, that is to say, as the greater number of its members are able to read, whereas otherwise the speech of the children is the regular source of new dialectal formations. For this reason not only the Persian and Bokharan Jews, but the Parsees also, have preserved in their dialects much old linguistic material out of the Sassanid age which among the remaining Iranians has been lost. From the same cause one finds the oldest form of the Arabic language existing today among the Bedouins, who live after a patriarchal fashion and among whom a regular interchange between the fathers and the sons takes place in word and in song. In precisely the same way one must seek old Turkish linguistic material in the first place not among the Osmanlis, but among the Crimean Tartars and in Adlerbeidschan. Among the Jews, however, the seclusion from the body of the people whose language they had but shortly before adopted has regularly repeated itself. Thus we see the Jews preserve the Aramaic tongue longer than any Arameans. Out of the Byzantine age the Jews in Macedonia, as well as their Karaite brethren in Constantinople and Jerusalem, have developed further after their own manner an older form of modern Greek. The Jews whose fathers were once banished from the fields of Spain have to this day, in the Turkish and Arabic Orient which took them in under its protection, not ceased to cultivate and to speak the language of their enemies and oppressors, a language which they have indeed mingled with Hebrew words, yet have preserved in an older form than have the inhabitants of the Pyrenean peninsula. The millions of German Jews who in the later Middle Ages had to flee out of Germany into Poland have faithfully preserved in their new home the language of the land that shut them out. Whoever would find old German linguistic material well conserved must make acquaintance with the dialect of the Jews of Poland and Russia, “German” in the proper sense of the word, in which more old words are preserved than in any other German dialect whatsoever. The very hard “ch,” which in the mouth of the Polish Jews strikes the German's ear so disagreeably, he, like the Alemannian, has rescued over from the ancient pronunciation of German. Yet many a poetical word which in German poetry seems to us archaically beautiful will not please us at all in the same meaning and the same application in the daily usage of the “Jargon Jews.”

E. M. Lilien: Golus.

E. M. Lilien: Golus.

But what, then, is the reason why other dialects of the German language do not strike us as distortions. while in face of Judaeo-German we condescend, for our own part too, credulously to repeat the insult that lies in the designation “Jargon”? For what is a “Jargon” other than the language of a people distorted in the mouth of a foreigner. A jargon is German in the mouth of Russians or Englishmen who, after a short sojourn in Berlin or Hamburg, begin to talk gibberish. A jargon is the Arabic which the Europeans in the Holy Land unhappily speak. A jargon is that which one reads in the mouth of the Negroes or the Indians in those trashy books wherewith it is permitted to corrupt the taste and the views of our youth. But to call a jargon the language which has propagated itself in the mouth of the Jews of the East from father to son, and which has developed and grown on naturally, be it their Spanish, Greek, Iranian (Persian and Caucasian) or German, is as little admissible as so to abuse the language of the Transylvanian Saxons, or that of a Fritz Reuter and a Klaus Groth. One must not, however, suppose that it is only the language of the Russian and the like Jews that is so named, although these have contrived, in unconscious and slavish submissiveness, to pass the insult on in their own mouths; no, every dialect of which Jews make use in their peculiarity has to put up with the same. The natural scientist, who of all men should be the least inclined to give the organic development of a language the same name as the broken speech and gibberish of unpractised foreigners, has paid no heed to this where Jewish dialects were concerned. Thus Wilhelm Geiger, in the so eminent Grundriss der iranischen Philologie of himself and Kuhn, takes no exception whatever to designating Judaeo-Persian regularly as a jargon, although in the same paragraph he is obliged fully to concede the archaic character of this Jewish tongue and its manifold points of contact with the Pazend. And it will not occur to him for a single moment to call the similar dialects of the Parsees by the same name. Therefore neither can one give place to the supposition that the designation Jargon for Judaeo-German is merely due to a, for a philologist, not well an-