Die Welt · Vol. V, No. 50 · 13 December 1901
4printed page
scan 4 of 52
Facsimile · scan 4 of 52
Scan of p. 4
English · AI translation, checked against the German

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 50.

(continued from page 3)

...our eyes has entered upon its course of development — all this induces us to a more detailed discussion than has otherwise been the case. That in this year too we shall not fail in the fullest objectivity — upon that our readers may rely.

Once again Basle makes ready for the reception of those men who come to us as the envoys of hundreds of thousands of their brethren scattered over the whole earth, in order in earnest converse to take counsel and to take action upon the weal and woe of the Jewish people. Whatever political or religious standpoint one may occupy, to whatever confession one may belong, one will not be able to refrain from bringing the fullest sympathy to the stout-hearted men who in a few days will come to us to take part in the Fifth Zionist Congress. From far distances will they again appear; hundreds, thousands of kilometres separate many of them from their homes. And not as to the first Congresses, not in the fair summer season do they come, not in order, beside their work, to wander for recreation among our beautiful mountains and Alpine valleys and to delight themselves in the glories of nature; no, the hard winter season has been appointed for this year's Congress. It will not be the sultry temperature which prevails within our Casino hall in the summer season that will stand hindering in the way of the labours — although even in glowing heat the work never flagged — but days of abundant work will lie before the delegates; the time will not be allowed to pass away in speeches alone, but intensive work will have to be accomplished in order to dispose of the programme of work drawn up by the party leadership. The task is an uncommonly large and many-sided one. Apart from the reports upon the situation of the Jews in the various countries and upon the state of the Zionist movement in general — with, as the "Clou," Dr. Max Nordau's speech once more — apart from this, the deliberation upon a new statute of organisation laid before the Congress by the leadership will occupy a broad space in the proceedings. Of what importance this part of the session will be may appear from the fact that the President of the Vienna Actions Committee and spiritus rector of the movement, Dr. Th. Herzl, will appear at the rapporteurs' table in order to sustain the proposal. That will be a veritable feast for the ears of Zionists and non-Zionists alike. For Dr. Herzl is . . . . . . . a speaker who weighs every one of his words and who, in sentences as brief as they are pregnant, says exactly, without "if" and "but," that which he means to say, because it must be said if he is not to be misunderstood. Since the new statute of organisation has already been made known in its broad outlines to the various country committees and has already been deliberated upon within the various groups, the deliberation will probably run its course smoothly. To be sure, one must not conceal from oneself that certain radical-Zionist circles will find much in it not rigid enough. Once again the whole energy and — diplomacy of the presiding board will be needed to reconcile the antagonisms that clash together and to lay the spirits of discord. One will simply have to bear in mind the well-known rule, that too keen an edge is easily notched, and that too tight a strain will make even the strongest rope snap. And therefore both parties will have to apply themselves to the utmost reserve.

In the barely four years of its existence Zionism has accomplished a triumphal progress which has not its like in the history of political movements; it has not only won for itself the sympathies of the great masses within the Jewish people, but — and this says much — has made friends of those circles which signify a factor upon the great stage of the world. That has been proved not only by the Palestine journey of the German Emperor in its day, but still more by the reception of the Zionist deputation by the Sultan at the beginning of last summer. And it is but a few weeks since, in a great London society of the high aristocracy devoted to colonial policy, amid the thunderous applause of the whole assembly, an English publicist equally famous as Zionist and as poet, Israel Zangwill, was permitted to speak in a two hours' address upon the future of Palestine as a Jewish land. It would be worth the trouble to reproduce the speaker's words. For to-day we will let our greeting to the Zionist delegates die away in the words and in the wish in which that oratorical masterpiece died away: "Give the land without a people to the people without a land!"

Jewish Settlements.

By Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, Berlin.

When Zionist friends lay before me the question how I would organise a province "according to my ideas," I must answer that I know no answer to it. My thoughts have always turned solely upon purely economic organisations, and I am a politician only in so far as I hold the unshakable conviction that all political organisation grows as a naturally given consequence out of the economic foundation, as the logical superstructure of a given substructure, the former standing to the latter as the consequence stands to the premise. I therefore do not doubt in the least that the form of economic organisation planned by me will in the course of time also engender a peculiar kind of political articulation: but this conception entirely forbids me to wish to begin with the political organisation, to wish to "fabricate" a State. The State is an organism; one can plant it and tend and protect it during its growth: but one cannot make it, one must "let it grow."

The only thing which from this standpoint the prudent economist may propose is the plan of a purely private-economic organisation, which at the outset may embrace only a limited number of cells of society, that is to say of families. This organisation has, in the case which here occupies us, where the question is of the expatriation and the social provision of hundreds of thousands of the most wretched and most unhappy human beings, a whole series of difficult conditions to fulfil: it must first of all, as the foundation of every further development, possess the guarantee of private-economic prosperity; it must secondly reckon with being carried on by men whose bodily capacity for work, whose psychical power of resistance, and finally whose previous training stand upon a very low average level: it must thirdly afford the possibility of stretching, with relatively small initial capital, a broad framework which can gradually be filled in densely with masses of men, without the social evils of even a "relative over-population" setting in; and the wholly enormous capitals required for the filling in of this framework must be capable of being created simultaneously with the ever denser settlement within this framework, or, what is the same thing, a credit basis of sound bearing power must here be formed, in order to be able to obtain considerable portions of these necessary capitals upon moderate conditions in the general capital market; and fourthly the underlying private-economic organisation must indeed also be public-economic in so far that out of it, in organic growth, a "commonwealth" of its own can arise, wherein of course the outward form of government and the form of dependence upon existing political powers is at the outset wholly indifferent.

These are difficult conditions: let us see how far it is possible to satisfy them.

That the fundamental organisation can only be an agricultural one goes without saying. All human civilisation has grown out of primary production. This wisdom stands at the beginning of all economic science: "Il faut donc cultiver le pied de l'arbre et ne pas borner nos soins à gouverner les branches: laissons les s'arranger et s'étendre en liberté, mais ne négligeons pas la terre qui fournit les sues nécessaires à leur végétations et à leur acroissement": so wrote the first creator of a scientific system of national economy, F. Quesnay, the founder of Physiocracy¹), and science would have advanced further had it never departed from this sole soil capable of bearing it. All its errors down to the present day may be traced back to the fact that ever since Adam Smith it has got into the blind alley of what I have called the "industry-centric" conception, a conception which has forgotten this most important connection of all national economy, the enduring dependence of all industry upon primary production.

Now, in the founding of a new national economy no one will be able to think industry-centrically: here it appears at once even to the prejudiced that all industry and all commerce can unfold only in such measure as the


¹) Oeuvres, edited by August Oncken, Frankfort-on-Main and Paris 1888, page 208.