Page 4 — "Die Welt" — No. 6
(continued from page 3)
…is doing its best to further Jewish interests; 3. that my assertions condemning its work were the consequence of my ignorance of the facts.
Like many other defences, this one too proceeds by putting into my mouth many charges which I did not make, and in turn by disregarding those which I did make. I have never denied that the "Ica" is doing its best to further the interests of our people, any more than I should wish to deny that a general commanding an army desires the interest of his nation. What I questioned was the accessibility of the "Ica," or its method of furthering this interest, just as I may question the capacity of a general to save his country from ruin.
Mr. Claude Montefiore, in his opening address at the annual meeting of the Anglo Jewish Association, lamented that the work of that body suffered from the lack of an opposition. We hear the same from English Ministers, who feel bitterly the want of a strong opposition. Well, then, I tried to procure this opposition for Mr. Montefiore — not for the Anglo Jewish Association, with its sham income of 3000 pounds a year and a Council seat for every 50 pounds, but for the more important body in which he holds ministerial rank, the Jewish Colonial Association ("Ica"), where so many millions are in question. And now Mr. Montefiore is not satisfied either.
I did not accuse the "Ica" of rudeness. For I was not thinking of the discourtesy towards the "International Deputation," which was composed of eminent Jewish men, which was sent out by a mass meeting of eighteen hundred persons at Odessa to implore the "Ica" to succour the Palestinian labourers struggling with death by hunger and to help the colonists up, and which was never received, nor even given the opportunity of stating its case. But I am very glad to have been by chance the cause of an apology for this discourtesy having at last issued, through Mr. Claude Montefiore's declarations in answer to Dr. Gaster's assertions, and I am grateful to Doctor Gaster for having in this way contributed to the success of my Congress speech. I wish he could likewise move the "Ica" to an apology for its still harsher refusal to hear the Palestine labourers themselves, or rather the delegates of that poor colony Petach Tikwah, who travelled the long way from Palestine to Paris only to find the door of hope slammed before their grief-worn eyes. But I still refuse to acquit the "Ica" of the actions of the "Palestine Committee." And it is of no consequence to me whether the blame falls upon the whole Council or upon the single Committee. They may divide it among themselves, if they will. The "Ica" has repeatedly declared that it assumes responsibility for the Rothschild colonies. At the meeting of the Anglo Jewish Association on the 7th of January 1900, Mr. Claude Montefiore states that, despite his own opposition and that of two other English members of the "Ica," Messrs. Alfred Louis Cohen and H. Lousada, their motions were outvoted, and that the Anglo Jewish Association, in a resolution moved by the Chief Rabbi, wished the "Ica" success in its new task.
At the annual meeting of the 8th of July 1900 Mr. Montefiore said, word for word: "We have taken upon ourselves a heavy responsibility in taking over the Rothschild colonies. Beyond doubt our course of action was the only possibility of saving them, the only way in which the unhealthy elements could be eliminated and independence at last take the place of perpetual doles and subsidies."
"We have taken upon ourselves a heavy responsibility." Yes indeed, and they cannot deny it. No, notwithstanding that Dr. Gaster was so good-natured as to find a scapegoat for them in the secret Committee. Their own report, which I have here, admits — in four separate places — that they, the Central Administration itself, took over the Rothschild colonies. I do not in the least doubt the correctness of Dr. Gaster's assertions that there is a special "Palestinian Comitee." I know that Baron Edmund Rothschild nominally presides over it, but its influential members are members of the Council of the "Ica." Their hard-hearted letters are written on the paper of the "Ica" and signed in the name of the "Ica." Their office and their officials likewise belong to the "Ica." Technically separate, they are practically one. It is the "Ica" that inaugurated the new and cruel policy in Palestine, it is the "Ica" that would reap the glory of success, and it is the "Ica," too, that must bear the burden of blame.
And it is upon the report of the "Ica" itself that I base this blame. This report tells us that in the past year they sent away from Palestine 130 families, comprising 305 souls. What families? Beggars? No, not at all — labourers! Precisely that element of people which is sorely needed in Palestine, where there are so many schnorrers. That was my complaint at the Congress, and it is fully admitted. To send away from Palestine the real labour forces needed to develop that country is treason to the interests of the Jewish people.
"Nothing artificial shall be created to keep you here," one of them wrote to the despairing delegates. As though the whole Rothschild colonisation had not been an artificial creation. For Baron Edmund, that embittered angel of grace and disgrace, cannot shake off from himself the responsibility for the sudden change of policy on the part of the "Ica" and for its refusal to establish new plantations until the old ones pay. "Nothing artificial shall be created to keep you here." But something artificial was begun to get them away, namely: gifts of money and tickets to Australia and America. And just as in Ireland⁹), the strong went away, the weaklings stayed behind. And their work here was meanwhile, of course, given to Arabs, who are less skilful but better paid for it.
Mr. Montefiore is very eloquent on the subject of Roumania. Yet he is himself realising the Jewish Roumania in Palestine, characterised by these features: no rights, no work, no hope, exodus!
Oh yes. I know the Association is anti-Zionist. Mr. Montefiore has told us that the English delegates had opposed the taking over of the Rothschild colonies on the ground that it might create the impression that the "Ica" was supporting the Zionist movement, while those members of the Council who were in favour of taking over the Rothschild colonies were inspired by the noble motive that this taking over would mean a blow against Zionism. It is well to know that they are, or were, of such vehement hostility to our plan of rescue. If only we could learn what their own plan of rescue is!
I have been accused of ignorance. Why, ladies and gentlemen? Precisely because I have studied their work, because for years I have been studying their annual reports, so that I have convinced myself of their garrulity. As early as the year 1899 I wrote in an article
